Caspian Seal Beaten for Selfies in Kazakhstan: What Happened

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-10.

Witnesses Reported a Seal Being Beaten for Photographs in Kazakhstan

In July 2020 a short video filmed on the Caspian Sea coast of Kazakhstan, near the village of Kuryk in Mangystau Region, caused outrage across the country and abroad. It appeared to show a group of men in shallow water striking a young Caspian seal until it stopped resisting, then pulling it onto the beach so that children could be photographed with it before it was put back in the sea. Kazakh officials condemned the scene and said they were looking for the people involved. Whether the seal survived was never confirmed.

The incident drew attention to an animal many people had never heard of: the Caspian seal, a small seal found nowhere else on Earth, whose numbers have collapsed over the past century.

What the video showed and how it spread

The clip circulated widely after Kazakh model and influencer Yevgeniya Mukasheva shared it on social media, asking how anyone could throw stones at a defenceless pup and laugh. It was not clear whether she filmed it herself or reposted it from someone else.

British tabloids then picked up the story, quoting a witness who said the men beat the seal until it passed out and that, after the photographs, "they threw the motionless body back into the sea." The witness added that they did not know whether it lived. Because the footage is short and the people filmed were not publicly identified at the time, details of exactly what happened before and after it remain unverified.

How Kazakh authorities responded

A spokesperson for Kazakhstan's Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources, named in reports as Saken Dildakhmet, publicly condemned the behaviour as outrageous. He warned that harassment of this kind harms the Caspian's wildlife and could change how seals behave around people, and he described the animals as friendly and curious creatures that deserve admiration.

Officials said they were seeking the people responsible. Reports at the time stated that cruelty to animals of this kind could carry a prison sentence of up to two years under Kazakh law. We were not able to confirm whether anyone was later charged.

Meet the Caspian seal

The Caspian seal (Pusa caspica) lives only in the Caspian Sea, the world's largest inland body of water, bordered by Kazakhstan, Russia, Azerbaijan, Iran and Turkmenistan. It is one of the smallest true seals: adults are typically around 1.3 metres long, though large males can reach about 1.8 metres.

Its life cycle depends on ice. In late autumn females travel to the shallow northern Caspian, which freezes in winter, and give birth on the ice in late January or early February. Each mother has a single white-coated pup weighing about 5 kg. In warmer months the seals spread through the rest of the sea, which is how a young animal could end up in the shallows near Kuryk in summer.

Like many seals, Caspian seals are curious and may approach people or rest close to shore. That is not an invitation to touch them. A seal on a beach or in shallow water is often resting, moulting or simply young and inexperienced.

Why the species is endangered

About a century ago the Caspian seal population was estimated at around 1.5 million. By 2005 estimates had fallen to roughly 104,000, a decline of more than 90%, and the species is classed as Endangered on the IUCN Red List. Recent counts disagree: one 2022 estimate put the population below 70,000, while another suggested about 168,000. Either way, numbers are a small fraction of what they once were.

The main pressures include:

  • Fishing nets. Bycatch, mostly in illegal nets, is thought to kill thousands of seals a year; one estimate put the toll at more than 17,000 in 2019.
  • Historical hunting. Large-scale commercial hunting during the twentieth century removed huge numbers of pups and adults.
  • Loss of winter ice. Warmer winters shrink the ice where pups are born, and shipping routes and icebreakers can disturb breeding areas.
  • Disease and pollution. A distemper outbreak killed more than 10,000 seals along the Kazakh coast in 2000, and pollution from industry and oil extraction may weaken immune systems.
  • Mass die-offs. In 2022 about 2,500 dead seals were found on the Russian coast of the Caspian, and the cause was never clearly established.

Against that background, deliberate cruelty to a single pup may seem minor in population terms, but it reflects the attitudes that conservation depends on changing.

The wider problem of wildlife selfies

The Kuryk video is an extreme case of a common problem: wild animals being grabbed, chased or handled for photographs. Animal welfare groups have documented dolphins pulled from the water, sloths passed between tourists and baby animals kept as photo props. Even when no one intends harm, handling causes stress, can separate young animals from their mothers and can spread disease in both directions.

Seals can also bite, and their mouths carry bacteria that cause serious infections in people. Habituating them to humans makes them more likely to approach boats and beaches, where they face more danger.

What to do if you meet a seal on the shore

  • Keep your distance. Give the animal a wide berth; wildlife guidance generally recommends staying tens of metres away from seals on land. If the animal looks at you or moves, you are too close.
  • Keep dogs on a lead and children calm and back from the water's edge.
  • Never touch, feed or move a seal, and do not try to push it back into the sea; resting on land is normal behaviour.
  • Use a zoom lens for photographs instead of getting closer.
  • Report injured animals or cruelty to local wildlife authorities, and if you film an incident, keep the original file with its date and location.

The outrage over the Kuryk video showed that most people instinctively side with the seal. Turning that instinct into simple habits on the beach, and into support for protecting the Caspian's remaining wildlife, is what gives the species a better chance.

Sources: Wikipedia: Caspian seal; incident as reported by the Mirror and LADbible in July 2020; video originally shared by Yevgeniya Mukasheva.

COMMENTS