Originally published 2020-07-05.

In July 2020 a team led by physicists at the MIT LIGO Laboratory reported in the journal Nature that quantum fluctuations were nudging the 40-kilogram mirrors inside the LIGO gravitational-wave detectors. The movement was about 10-20 metres, roughly ten billion times smaller than a hydrogen atom, but it was the first time this quantum "kick" had been measured on an object of human scale.
The result was a milestone in precision measurement rather than a sign that everyday objects behave strangely. Here is what the researchers did, why it was hard, and what it does and does not tell us.
What the experiment showed
Quantum mechanics describes the world at the scale of atoms and particles, where the rules feel very unlike ordinary life. One of its predictions is that even "empty" space and a steady laser beam are never perfectly calm. There are always tiny random fluctuations, a basic consequence of the uncertainty principle.
Light carries momentum, so when it reflects off a mirror it pushes on it slightly. Because the number of photons arriving moment to moment fluctuates randomly, the push fluctuates too, and the mirror jiggles. Theory predicted how large that jiggle should be for LIGO's heavy mirrors. The 2020 study measured it, and the answer matched the prediction.
Nergis Mavalvala, one of the leaders of the work, summed up why it mattered: the team had seen quantum effects on something "as large as a human".
How LIGO works
LIGO, the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory, has two detectors, at Hanford in Washington state and Livingston in Louisiana. Each is shaped like an L with two arms 4 kilometres long. A laser beam is split, sent down both arms, bounced off mirrors at the far ends and recombined.
If nothing disturbs the mirrors, the two beams return in step. A passing gravitational wave stretches one arm and squeezes the other by a fraction of a proton's width, and the returning beams fall out of step. LIGO made the first direct detection of gravitational waves on 14 September 2015, from two black holes merging over a billion light-years away, and three of its founders received the 2017 Nobel Prize in Physics.
To sense such small changes, the mirrors are suspended and isolated from ground vibration, heat and almost every other disturbance. That isolation is what made the quantum kick visible at all.
The quantum squeezer
LIGO's quantum noise comes in two linked forms: uncertainty in the light's phase, which blurs the timing of the returning beam, and uncertainty in its amplitude, which produces the fluctuating push on the mirrors. Quantum rules allow one to be reduced only if the other grows.
The MIT team, including Haocun Yu, Lee McCuller, Maggie Tse and Lisa Barsotti, built an add-on called a quantum squeezer that feeds specially prepared "squeezed" light into the detector. By changing the squeezing angle, they could trade phase noise for amplitude noise and back again.
They measured the detector's total noise, subtracted the classical noise from ordinary vibrations, and isolated the quantum part. Running the squeezer at 12 different angles revealed correlations between the quantum noise in the laser and the movement of the mirrors. Using those correlations, they reduced the mirror motion to about 70% of its normal level, beating what physicists call the standard quantum limit, the minimum noise expected from a laser of a given power.
Why we do not feel quantum kicks
If quantum fluctuations push on LIGO's mirrors, they push on everything, including us. McCuller explained the difference in an interview: our own thermal motion is far larger, "too large for these quantum vacuum fluctuations to affect our motion measurably."
In other words, the jiggling of warm atoms swamps the quantum effect in everyday objects. Only after LIGO's engineers had removed almost every other source of motion did the faint quantum push stand out. McCuller also noted that each mirror outweighs, by a factor of about a billion, the nanoscale objects in which other groups had previously measured this effect.
What it means for gravitational-wave astronomy
The practical payoff is sensitivity. Quantum noise is one of the main limits on how faint a signal LIGO can pick up. Squeezed light had already been installed at both sites before the third observing run began in April 2019, and the 2020 study showed in detail how quantum noise affects the mirrors and how it can be managed.
Lower noise means LIGO and its partner observatories, Virgo in Italy and KAGRA in Japan, can hear weaker and more distant collisions of black holes and neutron stars. Physics World named the study one of its top ten breakthroughs of 2020.
Common misunderstandings
- "The mirrors were in two places at once." No. The study measured random pushes from quantum noise in the light, not a superposition of a large object.
- "Quantum particles pop in and out of existence everywhere." This is a popular way of describing vacuum fluctuations. Physicists treat the "virtual particles" involved as a mathematical picture; they cannot be detected directly, though their combined effects, such as the Casimir effect, can be measured.
- "The result has not been published." Early coverage sometimes said so, but the paper appeared in Nature on 1 July 2020, days before many news stories.
- "This explains the Big Bang." Not directly. In the theory of cosmic inflation, quantum fluctuations in the very early universe were stretched to cosmic size and are thought to have seeded galaxies and the small temperature differences seen in the cosmic microwave background. Some physicists, such as Alexander Vilenkin, have also proposed that the universe itself began as a quantum event, but those ideas remain speculative. The LIGO mirror study tests established quantum theory, not the origin of the cosmos.
What the experiment does show is how far precision engineering has come: humans can now hold a 40-kilogram object so still that the restless quantum nature of light becomes the thing moving it.
Sources: MIT News, 1 July 2020: Quantum fluctuations can jiggle objects on the human scale; Futurism: Lee McCuller on quantum kicks; Wikipedia: LIGO; Wikipedia: Quantum fluctuation; Wikipedia: Cosmic inflation.

COMMENTS