Why a Montana Man Facing 64 Child Sex Abuse Counts Walked Free

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-26.

In July 2020 a Cascade County judge in Great Falls, Montana, gave William Edward Miller Jr., then 51, a one-year deferred sentence on a single felony count of sexual abuse of children, plus six months on a misdemeanor that his time in jail already covered. He had once faced 64 felony counts. Because he had spent more than a year in custody waiting for the case to end, he left the courthouse the same day. Below is what the court actually decided, how a case of that size shrank to two convictions, and why the outcome angered so many people.

A Montana Sentencing Report Raised Questions About a Plea Agreement

What sentence did William Miller Jr. receive?

On Monday, 20 July 2020, District Judge Elizabeth Best imposed two sentences that ran at the same time. For the felony, Miller received a one-year deferred sentence with conditions that, according to local reporting, included court-ordered sex offender treatment in the community. For a misdemeanor count of unsworn falsification to authorities, he was given six months in the Cascade County Detention Center.

The jail term existed mostly on paper. Miller was credited with 384 days already served, more than the six months imposed, so there was nothing left to serve. That is why headlines at the time said he “walked free”.

Many early reports, including the earlier version of this story, called the felony sentence “suspended”. The more precise word is deferred, and the difference matters, as explained below.

How 64 counts became two convictions

The case began in February 2019, when a 14-year-old high school student told police that Miller had raped her at her home roughly a year earlier and had allowed an 11-year-old boy to assault her while he watched. Miller was arrested that month.

Investigators then examined his phone and laptop. According to the Great Falls Tribune, as summarised by FOX affiliates, they reported finding images of child sexual abuse and bestiality. In August 2019 prosecutors filed 64 counts of sexual abuse of children.

By the time of sentencing, almost all of that had been dismissed under a plea agreement. Miller pleaded guilty to one felony count and one misdemeanor. The felony rested on a single photograph of a 17-year-old girl. She later married him, and by the 2020 hearing she was 19. She testified that she had taken the picture herself two years earlier and asked the court to clear the charge. “William is a kind, compassionate, empathetic man. Never has he manipulated or controlled me,” she told the judge, according to the Tribune’s account.

The rape allegation brought by the 14-year-old did not lead to a conviction in this plea. Public reporting at the time did not explain why prosecutors dropped those counts.

Deferred versus suspended: why the wording matters

Both terms describe sentences served outside prison, but they work differently.

  • Suspended sentence: the court imposes a sentence and then sets it aside on conditions. The conviction stays on the record.
  • Deferred sentence: the court postpones imposing any sentence for a set period. If the person follows every condition and commits no new crime, the plea can later be withdrawn and the charge dismissed.

That second outcome was the source of much of the anger. Reports explained that if Miller completed his year without a new offence, the felony could be removed from his record. Earlier coverage also claimed he could ask to come off the sex offender registry; we could not confirm what registration conditions applied, so treat that detail as unconfirmed.

Why plea bargains are so common, and so contested

Roughly nine in ten criminal cases in the United States end with a plea agreement rather than a jury trial. Prosecutors use deals to secure a certain conviction when evidence is weak, when a victim or witness may not testify, or when a trial could retraumatise a child. Defendants trade the risk of a long sentence for a smaller, guaranteed one.

Legal scholars have long criticised the system. Some argue it pressures innocent people into pleading guilty, while others say it lets people accused of grave crimes escape with token punishments because the details are negotiated privately, away from a jury.

Deals that reward cooperation can look even stranger from the outside. Mafia underboss Sammy “The Bull” Gravano admitted to 19 murders, testified against John Gotti and received a five-year sentence in 1994, much of which he had already served. Nothing in the public record of the Miller case suggests he cooperated with authorities in that way, so comparisons like this explain the system rather than this particular outcome.

What the public record does not tell us

It is tempting to fill gaps with guesses, but several questions were never answered publicly:

  • Why prosecutors judged the rape allegation and the image counts too difficult to take to trial.
  • Whether problems with evidence, witness availability or a child’s ability to testify shaped the deal.
  • What exact conditions, monitoring or treatment the deferred sentence carried.

Without the court file, readers can fairly ask whether the outcome protected children well enough, while avoiding claims about secret deals or informant status that no source supports. If you want to follow a case like this, court records in Montana district courts are generally public, and county attorneys’ offices can be asked to explain charging decisions.

If a child you know may be at risk

Cases like this stay in the news because they touch every parent’s worst fear. If you suspect a child is being abused, contact local police or your state’s child protective services. In the United States, the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline (1-800-422-4453) offers confidential advice around the clock. A child who discloses abuse needs to hear that they are believed and that telling was the right thing to do; specialists can take it from there.

Sources: Great Falls Tribune report via FOX 5 Atlanta (July 2020) · KIRO 7 / Cox Media Group (July 2020) · Wikipedia: Plea bargain · Wikipedia: Sammy Gravano

COMMENTS