Why France and Turkey Clashed Over Libya in 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-02.

France and Turkey Exchanged Accusations Over Libya in 2020

In the summer of 2020, Libya's civil war turned into an open quarrel between two NATO allies. President Emmanuel Macron accused Turkey of flooding Libya with weapons and Syrian fighters in breach of a United Nations arms embargo. Ankara answered that France had quietly backed the eastern commander Khalifa Haftar for years and was behaving like a former colonial power. Behind the insults lay a real military contest, a tense encounter between warships, and fears that Egypt might send its army across the border.

This guide explains who was fighting whom, what each government actually said, what happened at sea, and how the confrontation cooled once the front line froze later that year.

Libya's war and the foreign powers behind it

Libya never settled after the fall of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011. By 2014 the country had split between rival authorities, and the conflict that followed is usually called the Second Libyan Civil War. In the west, Tripoli was held by the Government of National Accord (GNA), the administration recognised by the UN. In the east, the House of Representatives in Tobruk sided with Haftar's self-styled Libyan National Army (LNA).

Each camp leaned on outside friends. The GNA's main backers were Turkey and Qatar. Haftar received support from the United Arab Emirates and Egypt, while Russian private military contractors from the Wagner group fought on his side. France officially supported the UN-backed government, yet critics, including GNA officials, accused Paris of helping Haftar too, and the GNA publicly condemned France alongside Egypt, the UAE and Russia. France consistently denied taking sides.

In April 2019 Haftar launched an offensive on Tripoli. It stalled, and in the first half of 2020 Turkish help tipped the balance. Ankara's parliament approved a troop deployment on 2 January 2020, and Turkey sent drones, air-defence systems, military advisers and naval support. It also transported fighters recruited from Syrian armed groups it sponsored; by September 2020 monitors cited estimates of around 18,000 Syrians sent to Libya. By June 2020 the LNA had been pushed away from the capital.

What Macron and Ankara said

On Monday 29 June 2020 Macron spoke to reporters during a visit to Germany and did not hold back. Speaking of Turkey's role, he said:

"I think it is a historic and criminal responsibility for a country which claims to be a NATO member."

He also said, without publishing evidence, that Turkey was bringing large numbers of fighters from Syria into Libya, and he repeated that France backed a political solution rather than Haftar.

Turkey's foreign ministry hit back the next day. Its spokesman Hami Aksoy accused Paris of trying to revive its old colonial influence in the region and argued that France bore an "important responsibility in dragging Libya into chaos" through its support for what he called illegitimate structures. The jab was aimed at France's long history in North Africa: Algeria, Libya's neighbour to the west, was ruled from Paris until its independence in 1962, and Tunisia and Morocco were French protectorates until 1956.

The exchange was unusually harsh for two members of the same military alliance, and it fed into a wider dispute over Turkish gas exploration and maritime claims in the eastern Mediterranean.

The confrontation at sea in June 2020

Much of France's anger traced back to an incident on 10 June 2020. A French frigate, operating under NATO's Mediterranean mission, tried to inspect the cargo ship Çirkin, which was sailing towards Libya under Turkish naval escort. Paris said the Turkish warships locked onto the French vessel with their fire-control radar three times, a step that normally signals readiness to fire, and described the episode as hostile under NATO rules of engagement. Ankara denied harassing the frigate and said its ship was carrying humanitarian goods.

NATO opened an inquiry, but no public verdict was ever published, and France later said it would step back from the NATO maritime operation in protest. The cargo question was answered elsewhere: the European Union later concluded that the Çirkin had violated the UN arms embargo in May and June 2020, and on 21 September 2020 it imposed sanctions on the ship's operator, Avrasya Shipping. Turkey also refused several requests from European warships under the EU's Operation Irini to inspect vessels bound for Libya.

Why Sirte became the flashpoint

With Tripoli secure, the GNA and its Turkish backers turned east towards Sirte, Gaddafi's hometown on the central coast. Sirte matters because it is the gateway to Libya's "oil crescent," the string of terminals and fields that produce most of the country's export revenue, and to the Jufra air base further south.

Egypt, which shares a long desert border with eastern Libya, made clear it would not accept a GNA advance there. In June 2020 President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi warned GNA forces not to cross the front line and said Egypt had the right to intervene; the GNA called this a declaration of war. Our earlier report covers how Egypt threatened to send troops if Sirte was attacked. Meanwhile, Russian contractors and other foreign fighters were reported moving towards Sirte to reinforce Haftar's lines.

That is why the France–Turkey argument mattered beyond diplomacy. If either side had pushed for Sirte, several outside armies could have been drawn into direct contact, and the arms embargo would have become even more meaningless.

Claims worth checking

"France fought for Haftar"

France denied military support for Haftar and officially recognised the GNA. There were credible reports of French intelligence contacts and military personnel in the east, which fuelled suspicion, but the evidence never amounted to the kind of open, large-scale backing that Turkey gave the GNA. The fair description is that France was accused of tilting towards Haftar, while the UAE, Egypt and Russian contractors were his main foreign supporters.

"Only Turkey broke the embargo"

UN experts reported embargo violations by several states and companies on both sides throughout the war. Turkey's shipments were among the most visible because they came with naval escorts, but they were far from the only ones.

"Extremists ruled GNA territory"

Haftar and his backers often argued that Islamist militias, and even cells linked to ISIS or al-Qaeda, operated inside western Libya. Armed groups of many ideologies did exist across the country, and ISIS had once seized Sirte itself in 2015 before being driven out in 2016. Yet the GNA was not run by such groups, and the label was frequently used as political ammunition by all sides.

How the standoff ended

The feared battle for Sirte never came. On 21 August 2020 both the GNA and the authorities in the east announced a ceasefire, and on 23 October 2020 military delegates from the two sides, meeting as the 5+5 Joint Military Commission under UN auspices, signed a permanent ceasefire agreement. In March 2021 an interim Government of National Unity took office to prepare for national elections, which were later postponed.

Turkey stayed. Its parliament has repeatedly renewed the troop mandate, most recently extending it from January 2024 for another two years, and Turkish companies have returned to Libyan construction and energy projects. France, for its part, kept pressing for foreign forces and mercenaries to leave, a demand that has still not been fully met.

What the dispute tells us

The 2020 quarrel is a useful case study in how proxy wars work. Outside states rarely declare that they are fighting; instead they supply drones, advisers, cargo ships and hired fighters, and then accuse each other of exactly the same behaviour. When reading about any foreign involvement in a conflict, it helps to separate three things: who a country formally recognises, what military help it can be shown to have provided, and what its commercial or strategic interests are. Our companion article on Turkey's economic stakes in Libya looks at the last of these, and the earlier report on the NATO inquiry into the June naval incident covers the first reactions.

For Libyans, the most important outcome was that the ceasefire largely held. The country remains divided between rival authorities, but the large-scale fighting that made the summer of 2020 so dangerous has not returned.

Sources: Al Jazeera, 30 June 2020; Wikipedia: Second Libyan Civil War; Wikipedia: Turkish military intervention in the Second Libyan Civil War.

COMMENTS