Originally published 2020-07-19.

Map of the maritime zones claimed under the 2019 Turkey–Libya memorandum, as shown by Turkish broadcaster TRT World. The lines reflect Turkey's position, not an agreed or internationally recognised boundary.
In July 2020, five governments, Greece, Cyprus, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Bahrain, sent a joint diplomatic note to UN Secretary-General António Guterres. Their request was specific: the UN Secretariat should not register the maritime memorandum that Turkey had signed with Libya's Tripoli-based Government of National Accord (GNA) in November 2019. They argued that the document was never validly in force, that the GNA had no authority to conclude it alone, and that it ignored the rights of other coastal states, above all Greece and its island of Crete.
The note did not change the paper trail. According to the UN Treaty Series, Turkey registered the memorandum with a registration date of 11 December 2019. Registration, however, is an administrative step. It does not mean the UN endorses a boundary, and the deal remains contested. Here is what the memorandum says, why so many neighbours objected, and how it fits into the wider struggle over Libya and the Eastern Mediterranean.
What Turkey and the GNA signed in November 2019
On 27 November 2019, in Istanbul, Turkey and the GNA signed two memoranda. One covered security and military cooperation. The other, the subject of the July 2020 complaint, set out a line dividing the two countries' "maritime jurisdiction areas" in the Mediterranean, meaning the continental shelf and exclusive economic zones (EEZs) where a state holds rights over fishing, seabed resources, oil and gas.
The line itself is short. Boundary researchers at Sovereign Limits describe it as roughly 18 nautical miles long, defined by just two coordinates. What made it explosive was where those points lie. Turkey and Libya are not neighbours across open water: Crete and other Greek islands sit between them. By drawing a shared boundary that treats the sea south-east of Crete as Turkish and Libyan, the memorandum effectively gives Crete almost no maritime zone on that side.
The memorandum entered into force on 8 December 2019, according to the treaty record. For Ankara, it secured a legal claim to a wide corridor across the Eastern Mediterranean and a say in any pipeline or drilling plans there. For the GNA, it came packaged with Turkish military support at a moment when its forces were under heavy attack.
Why Greece, Cyprus, Egypt and two Gulf states objected
The joint note to the Secretary-General, delivered on 9 July 2020 and reported in the Greek press a few days later, laid out several arguments:
- Not in force for Libya. Under UN rules, only instruments in force between the parties can be registered. The speaker of Libya's House of Representatives, the eastern-based parliament, had told the UN in writing that it never ratified or accepted the memorandum.
- Signed beyond the GNA's powers. The GNA was created by the 2015 Libyan Political Agreement, endorsed by UN Security Council resolution 2259. That agreement requires the Presidency Council to approve international agreements collectively, with parliamentary approval. The note said the council's head signed alone.
- A questionable mandate. The five states argued the GNA's term had lapsed and that its Presidency Council, weakened by resignations, no longer represented all of Libya's regions.
- Harm to third countries. They said the deal raised tension and threatened regional stability, and that its line violated the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
Greece, the European Union and the United States were among those who publicly rejected the line as inconsistent with the law of the sea. Cyprus saw it as part of the same Turkish policy that challenges Cypriot offshore licensing blocks. Saudi Arabia and Bahrain had no Mediterranean coastline at stake; their signatures reflected the regional rivalry with Turkey and their alignment with Egypt.
The law of the sea and the question of islands
At the heart of the dispute is a legal disagreement about islands. Under Article 121 of UNCLOS, inhabited islands like Crete generate the same maritime zones as mainland coasts. Greece relies on that rule. Turkey has not signed UNCLOS and argues that large islands lying close to another country's coast should not cut it off from the sea, and that fairness, rather than strict equidistance, should guide boundaries.
International courts have sometimes reduced the effect of small islands when drawing lines. But Crete is Greece's largest island, with more than 600,000 residents, and few legal scholars outside Turkey believe it could be treated as having no shelf toward Libya. A boundary that two parties draw while ignoring a third state lying between them also cannot bind that third state. That is why most governments treat the memorandum as having no legal effect on Greek rights.
The Libyan war behind the maritime map
The memorandum cannot be separated from Libya's civil war. Since 2014 the country had been split between authorities in the west, later the UN-recognised GNA in Tripoli, and the east, where Khalifa Haftar's self-styled Libyan National Army (LNA) was allied with the House of Representatives. Haftar launched an offensive on Tripoli in April 2019. Turkey's military help, including drones and Syrian fighters recruited through Turkish channels, turned the tide in 2020 and pushed the LNA back.
The LNA received support from the United Arab Emirates, Egypt and Russia, while France was widely seen as sympathetic to Haftar. The conflict also had an ideological edge: Ankara has long been friendly to political Islamist movements, while Egypt's government treats the Muslim Brotherhood as a terrorist organisation and saw some GNA-aligned militias in that light. Claims at the time that ISIS operated "within GNA territory" were too broad; the group was largely driven out of its stronghold in Sirte in 2016, with remnants hiding mainly in the southern desert.
Sirte, Egypt's red line and the road to a ceasefire
By mid-2020 the front had moved to Sirte, the coastal city that guards the approaches to Libya's main oil terminals. In June 2020, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi called the Sirte–Jufra line a red line and said Egypt was prepared to intervene if it was crossed, a threat covered in our report on Egypt's warning over Sirte. Egypt's parliament later approved the possible deployment of troops abroad.
Weeks after the UN note, Greece and Egypt signed their own partial maritime boundary agreement in August 2020, presented in Athens and Cairo as a direct legal answer to the Turkey–GNA line. The two lines overlap, so the map now carries competing claims. The summer of 2020 also saw a tense naval stand-off between Greece and Turkey over the survey ship Oruç Reis.
Fighting did not reach Sirte. In October 2020 Libyan military delegations agreed a nationwide ceasefire, and in 2021 a new interim Government of National Unity replaced the GNA. That government kept the 2019 memorandum and in 2022 signed a further energy cooperation deal with Turkey, which Greece and Egypt also rejected.
How to read maps and claims in this dispute
Coverage of the Eastern Mediterranean often shows striking maps, including the one above. Before trusting any of them, it helps to ask three questions:
- Who drew it? A map from a state broadcaster shows that state's claim, not a settled border.
- What kind of document backs it? A bilateral memorandum, a note to the UN, a court ruling and a fully agreed treaty carry very different legal weight.
- Who was left out? A sea boundary agreed by two countries cannot take away rights from a third country whose coast lies in between.
The practical outcome so far is a stalemate. Turkey and Libya's Tripoli authorities treat the line as valid; Greece, Cyprus, Egypt, the EU and many others do not. Without negotiation or a court case accepted by all sides, the overlapping claims are likely to remain a source of friction, and the people of Libya, who have endured more than a decade of conflict, still wait for a single, stable government.
Sources: Ta Nea: joint note of Greece, Cyprus, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Bahrain to the UN (15 July 2020, in Greek); UN Treaty Series: registration record I-56119; Sovereign Limits: Libya–Turkey maritime boundary; European Parliament question on the Turkey–GNA memorandum (2019). Map: TRT World.

COMMENTS