First published June 21, 2020.

Falestine after the procedure, and the moment her claws were cut at Rafah Zoo. Image credit: FOUR PAWS USA.
In early 2019, photos and video from Rafah Zoo in the southern Gaza Strip showed a veterinarian cutting the claws of Falestine, a 14-month-old lioness, so that visitors and children could handle and play with her. The images drew condemnation from animal welfare groups around the world. Within weeks the international charity FOUR PAWS had negotiated the closure of the zoo, and in April 2019 Falestine and more than 40 other animals were moved to a sanctuary in Jordan.
Here is what happened, why vets regard declawing a big cat as so harmful, and what the case shows about animal attractions that promise close contact with wild animals.
What happened at Rafah Zoo
According to Associated Press reporting carried by Fox News in February 2019, the lioness was first sedated and placed on a table so that a vet could stitch a bleeding wound on one paw. About two weeks later, the vet, Fayez al-Haddad, clipped her claws further while a colleague held her head. Gaza had no specialised animal hospital, so the work was done at the zoo itself. FOUR PAWS later described the procedure as being carried out with garden shears.
Her teeth were left intact. The aim, the zoo's staff said, was simply to make her safe enough to touch.
One of Many: A face of Sorrow. This 14-month-old lioness suffered unimaginable cruelty after she was declawed with garden shears in an amateur & dangerous medical procedure. With our help she’ll be rehabilitated by a team of specialized veterinarians https://t.co/9BZkjiNg4d pic.twitter.com/OTw5yTnCIv
— FOUR PAWS USA (@FOURPAWSUSA) March 24, 2019
FOUR PAWS shared images of the injured lioness in March 2019 as it prepared to take her and the other animals out of Gaza.
Why the zoo said it did it
The zoo's owner, Mohammed Jumaa, told reporters he wanted to reduce the young lioness's aggression so that she would be friendly with visitors. The vet framed it as a way to draw families. "The claws were cut so that they would not grow fast and visitors and children could play with her," he told the AP, adding that the zoo hoped to bring happiness to children and raise visitor numbers.
The context matters. Gaza's economy has been under severe strain for years, the territory's private zoos struggled to afford food and veterinary care, and Gaza's only animal care practice was then reported to be facing closure for financial reasons. None of that makes the procedure acceptable, but it helps explain how animals ended up in such conditions.
Why declawing a big cat is so harmful
A cat's claw grows from the last bone of the toe. Removing it properly means amputating that bone, which is why welfare groups and many vets compare declawing to cutting off a person's fingers at the last knuckle. Even in a sterile clinic it is painful surgery; done at a zoo table, the risk of infection and lasting damage is much higher.
For a lion, claws are not optional. They are used to grip prey and food, climb, balance, groom and defend themselves. FOUR PAWS warned that natural behaviour becomes almost impossible without them, calling the procedure one that "causes long-lasting damage." Declawed big cats can also develop chronic pain and changes in how they walk, which can lead to joint problems over a lifetime.
Declawing also does not make a lion safe. She keeps her strength and her teeth, and an animal in pain may become more defensive, not less. Wildlife experts generally agree that big cats should never be handled by the public at all.
⚠️SHOCKING footage revealed: young lioness brutally mutilated!
— FOUR PAWS (@fourpawsint) February 14, 2019
The owner of the oldest zoo in Gaza allows visitors to play with this lioness & therefore cruelly removed her claws with garden shears! We strongly demand the closure of the zoo! #SaveGazaAnimals pic.twitter.com/t2gJoxKJTB
(This post is no longer available on X.)
FOUR PAWS first publicised the footage in February 2019 and called for the zoo to close. That post has since been removed from X.
Rafah Zoo's record and the rescue
Falestine was not the first animal to suffer there. In January 2019, four lion cubs at the zoo died from cold during harsh winter weather. The owner was also quoted saying he planned to remove the claws of her two brothers, doing it himself if no vet was available, and that he had once amputated an injured fox's leg with a circular saw. FOUR PAWS called those statements "beyond horrific."
A FOUR PAWS petition calling for the zoo's closure gathered close to 150,000 signatures. The charity had already closed two other zoos in Gaza, Al-Bisan and Khan Younis. On 20 March 2019 it announced an agreement to evacuate Rafah Zoo's animals, and the mission began in early April.
More than 40 animals were moved, including five lions, a hyena, monkeys, wolves, porcupines, foxes, cats and dogs. They travelled almost 300 km to Al Ma'wa for Nature and Wildlife in Jordan, a rescue centre run jointly by FOUR PAWS and the Princess Alia Foundation. Dr Amir Khalil, the FOUR PAWS vet who led the mission, said the charity was happy to finally put an end to the animals' suffering, and called it the group's biggest rescue to date.
What happened next
The story did not end neatly. In August 2019, only a few months after the closure, the family behind Rafah Zoo reopened it with two adult lions, three new cubs, an ostrich and a pair of monkeys, according to Israeli news site Ynet. Activists described cages of only a few square metres, and FOUR PAWS said the animals were not being kept in conditions suited to their species. The charity also stated that it does not pay owners for animals, although it had covered medical care and food during the rescue.
The episode shows how hard it is to fix animal welfare problems through one-off rescues alone. Without enforceable rules on keeping wild animals, and without the money to run proper facilities, the same pattern can repeat.
How to spot an attraction that harms animals
Falestine's story is extreme, but the business model behind it, charging visitors to touch or play with wild animals, exists in many countries. Some signs to watch for when travelling:
- Hands-on contact with big cats, bears or primates. Cub petting, walking with lions and selfie sessions usually depend on animals taken from their mothers, restrained or physically altered.
- Animals that are unusually docile. Wild predators that tolerate crowds may be sedated, declawed or have had teeth removed.
- Constant breeding of babies. A steady supply of cubs for photos raises the question of what happens when they grow up.
- Small, bare enclosures. Good facilities give animals space, shade, places to hide and things to do.
- Genuine sanctuaries do not breed or sell. Look for accreditation from bodies such as the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries or a recognised national zoo association.
Choosing to watch animals from a respectful distance, in the wild or at accredited facilities, removes the demand that drives stories like this one. Falestine was lucky enough to get a second chance; many animals in similar places never do.
Sources: Fox News / AP: Gaza zoo declaws young lioness; FOUR PAWS: owner plans to remove claws of more lions; FOUR PAWS: rescue of over 40 animals from Rafah Zoo; Ynet via York University: Gaza zoo reopens; FOUR PAWS USA (image).

COMMENTS