Rayshard Brooks Shooting: What Happened and How the Case Ended

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-14.

Rayshard Brooks Killed by Atlanta Police; Police Chief Resigns

Rayshard Brooks, a 27-year-old Black man, was shot and killed by Atlanta police officer Garrett Rolfe late on 12 June 2020 in the parking lot of a Wendy's restaurant. A sobriety check turned into a struggle, Brooks ran with an officer's Taser, and Rolfe fired his handgun, hitting him twice in the back. The next day Police Chief Erika Shields resigned and protesters burned the restaurant. Murder charges followed, but in August 2022 a special prosecutor dropped all charges against both officers.

The case came less than three weeks after George Floyd's death in Minneapolis, and it quickly became one of the most debated police shootings of that summer.

What happened at the Wendy's

According to the detailed account compiled on Wikipedia from police video and investigators' findings, Officer Devin Brosnan was called at about 10:42 p.m. to a report of a man asleep in a car blocking the drive-through at the Wendy's on University Avenue in south Atlanta. He woke Brooks, who moved the car, then called for an officer trained in drink-driving checks.

Rolfe arrived and, for more than 25 minutes, the encounter was calm. Brooks agreed to a pat-down, a field sobriety test and a breath test, which read 0.108%, above Georgia's 0.08% limit. He offered to leave the car and walk to his sister's home nearby.

When the officers moved to handcuff him at about 11:23 p.m., Brooks resisted. In the scuffle he grabbed Brosnan's Taser and fired it, punched Rolfe, and ran across the lot. As he fled he turned and fired the Taser toward Rolfe, missing him. Rolfe fired three shots from his pistol; two struck Brooks in the back. He died after surgery, and the county medical examiner ruled the death a homicide. Brosnan was treated for a concussion.

Brooks worked in restaurants, had been married for eight years and was a father of three daughters and a stepson. Reports at the time said he had spent part of that day at a child's birthday celebration.

Protests and the police chief's resignation

Video of the shooting spread quickly. A largely peaceful protest took place in Atlanta on Saturday, 13 June, and that evening the Wendy's was set on fire, along with several cars nearby. Two people later pleaded guilty to arson-related charges.

That same day Chief Erika Shields offered to step down. The mayor's office framed the move as a chance to rebuild public trust, saying Shields had stepped aside so the city could move forward "with urgency and rebuilding the trust so desperately needed throughout our communities." Rolfe was fired and Brosnan was placed on administrative duty.

The tweet above, from WSB-TV reporter Michael Seiden, identified the two officers. Brosnan's surname is misspelled in it.

Was the shooting justified? Two views

The debate split sharply. Some commentators argued that the case differed from George Floyd's: Brooks had resisted arrest, taken a weapon and fired it toward an officer. In their view, an officer facing a Taser shot could reasonably fear being incapacitated and losing his own gun.

Others said a fleeing man with a weapon that had already been fired, running away from officers, did not pose the kind of deadly threat that justifies shooting him in the back. The Brooks family's lawyer, Chris Stewart, told the BBC: "You can't shoot somebody unless they are pointing a gun at you." Police policies generally class Tasers as less-lethal rather than harmless, a distinction that sits at the heart of this argument.

In the BBC video reports, family members and protesters describe how the death landed in a city already marching for Floyd.

The charges and how the case ended

On 17 June 2020, Fulton County District Attorney Paul Howard charged Rolfe with felony murder and ten other offences, and Brosnan with aggravated assault and violations of oath. Brosnan was presented as a cooperating witness, though his lawyer disputed that description. The announcement was followed by a "blue flu" sick-out among Atlanta officers.

Howard lost his re-election bid that year. In 2021 his successor, Fani Willis, sought to hand the case off, a judge disqualified her office, and special prosecutor Pete Skandalakis took over. On 23 August 2022 he dropped all charges, concluding that Rolfe's use of deadly force was objectively reasonable and that neither officer acted with criminal intent.

Rolfe had already been reinstated by Atlanta's Civil Service Board in May 2021, which found his firing had not followed due process. In November 2022, Brooks's family reached a $1 million wrongful death settlement with the City of Atlanta.

Why the case still matters

The Brooks shooting raised questions that police departments still wrestle with: when a routine stop for an impaired driver should end in arrest rather than another option, how officers should respond to a fleeing suspect with a less-lethal weapon, and how prosecutors should handle charges against officers in a politically charged moment.

It also showed how one night can reshape a city. Atlanta saw a change of police leadership, months of protest around the burned restaurant, and in July 2020 the shooting death of eight-year-old Secoriea Turner near the occupied site, a tragedy that shifted local debate again.

The worldwide protests of 2020 drew on many cases like this one. Looking at the full record, from the first call to the dropped charges, is the best way to understand both the grief and the disagreement that followed.

Sources: Wikipedia: Killing of Rayshard Brooks; BBC News, June 2020; NPR, 23 August 2022; KPQ: Atlanta police chief resigns. Tweet by Michael Seiden, WSB-TV.

COMMENTS