Shake Shack and the NYPD Bleach Claim: What Investigators Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-17.

Shake Shack Drink Allegations Prompted an NYPD Investigation in 2020

In June 2020 three New York police officers fell ill after drinking shakes from a Shake Shack in lower Manhattan, and police unions said the drinks had been deliberately laced with bleach. Within hours the NYPD's own detectives concluded there was no criminality by Shake Shack's employees. According to CBS New York's sources, the most likely explanation was an accident: cleaning solution that had not been fully rinsed out of the shake machine. The officers were treated in hospital and released.

The episode is worth revisiting because of how quickly a poisoning claim spread, and how much damage an early accusation can do even after investigators reject it.

What happened on the evening of 15 June 2020

The officers were assigned to a protest detail in lower Manhattan during the demonstrations that followed the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer on 25 May 2020. On the evening of Monday 15 June, they took a meal break at the Shake Shack at 200 Broadway, near Fulton Street.

After starting their drinks, they noticed an unusual taste and smell and became concerned. They were taken to Bellevue Hospital, where they were treated and released. A sample of a shake was sent to a laboratory for testing.

It is also worth remembering what bleach exposure usually looks like. Household bleach has a strong, distinctive smell, which is often why people stop drinking after a sip or two, as the officers did. Small accidental exposures are common and often cause only mouth or throat irritation or an upset stomach, but anyone who swallows a cleaning product should get medical advice promptly, for example from a doctor or a poison control centre. In this case the officers were checked at Bellevue and released the same night.

The union allegation

That night, the Police Benevolent Association (PBA), the union for New York's rank-and-file officers, sent an alert to members. It said the officers had found that a toxic substance, believed to be bleach, had been placed in their beverages. The Detectives' Endowment Association also initially described the contamination as intentional.

The PBA went further on Twitter, in a post it later deleted, saying the incident showed that officers cannot even take meal without coming under attack. The union urged members to be careful when eating or drinking in uniform. The claim spread rapidly on social media and in some news outlets, and the restaurant's staff were, in effect, accused of attempted poisoning before any evidence had been examined.

What investigators found

The investigation moved fast. Early on Tuesday 16 June, NYPD Chief of Detectives Rodney Harrison posted that, after a thorough investigation by Manhattan South detectives, it had been determined there was no criminality by Shake Shack's employees.

The Detectives' Endowment Association, which had first described the act as deliberate, then said investigators had found no criminality, noted that the officers were not seriously harmed, and thanked Shake Shack for its cooperation. Sources told CBS New York that the incident appeared to be accidental and was possibly caused by cleaning solution left in the shake machine after it had been cleaned.

Simple logic pointed the same way. A shake goes from the machine to an employee to the customer. No other customers reported problems, and detectives did not find evidence that anyone had tampered with the officers' drinks.

How Shake Shack responded

Before the result was known, the company posted that it was horrified by the reports and was working with police. After detectives cleared its staff, Shake Shack said it was relieved that the officers were all right and that it was still working to understand exactly what had happened.

The original tweet is embedded above. It shows how a company had to respond publicly to a criminal accusation within hours, without yet knowing the facts.

Why the story spread so fast

June 2020 was a tense moment between police and protesters across the United States. Some police officers knelt or marched with demonstrators, while others faced hostility on the street. In that atmosphere, a report that officers had been poisoned fitted an existing story for many people, and it was shared widely before anyone checked it.

The case also showed a recurring problem in breaking news. A first claim, especially one from an official-sounding source such as a union, gets far more attention than the later correction. Many people who saw the poisoning headlines never saw the finding that no crime had taken place.

This matters for the people involved. Fast-food workers were named, at least implicitly, as suspects in a serious crime. Once police cleared them, the fair outcome is that they should not remain under suspicion, online or anywhere else.

Lessons for reading a breaking story

  • Separate the stages. A suspected substance, a medical finding and evidence of intent are three different things. Early reports often merge them.
  • Notice who is speaking. Unions, companies and campaign groups have an interest in how a story is framed. Their statements are part of the story, not the final word on it.
  • Look for the official outcome. Here the result came within a day and was clear: no criminality by staff.
  • Food safety is real too. Cleaning chemicals left in equipment can make people sick. If a drink smells or tastes of chemicals, stop, tell staff, and seek medical advice if you feel unwell.

Read on its own, the first headline suggested a deliberate attack on police. The full record tells a quieter story: a probable cleaning mistake, a swift investigation, three officers who recovered, and restaurant workers who were cleared.

Sources: Boston.com (16 June 2020); CBS News; Shake Shack's statement on Twitter (embedded above).

COMMENTS