Galwan Valley Clash 2020: Why India and China Came to Blows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-20.

India's Military Preparations During the 2020 China Border Dispute

On the night of 15 June 2020, Indian and Chinese soldiers fought a brutal hand-to-hand battle in the Galwan Valley in Ladakh, high in the Himalayas. Twenty Indian soldiers died, including their commanding officer, Colonel B. Santosh Babu. China admitted only in February 2021 that four of its soldiers had been killed, although independent and US intelligence estimates put Chinese deaths higher. It was the first deadly clash between the two nuclear-armed neighbours since 1975, and in the days that followed India put its forces on a war footing while both governments insisted they still wanted talks.

This guide explains what happened at Galwan, why the border is disputed in the first place, how India prepared for the risk of a wider conflict, what China said, and how the standoff was eventually wound down.

What happened in the Galwan Valley

Tension had been building since early May 2020. On 5 May troops brawled with fists and stones on the shores of Pangong Tso, a long lake that the border crosses, and on 10 May there was another scuffle at Naku La in Sikkim, far to the east. Both armies then moved thousands of extra soldiers and equipment closer to the frontier.

The deadly fight came at a spot known as Patrol Point 14, near where the Galwan River flows into the Shyok. Reports describe several hundred men fighting for hours in darkness, on narrow ridges above a freezing, fast-flowing river. Under agreements going back to the 1990s, troops in the area did not open fire on each other, so the clash was fought with fists, rocks, batons and improvised clubs, some reportedly wrapped in barbed wire. Some of the Indian dead are believed to have fallen into the river or died of their injuries in the cold.

In the first confused days, Indian outlets such as the Press Trust of India quoted unnamed sources citing US intelligence that around 35 Chinese soldiers had been killed or wounded. China gave no figure at all until February 2021, when state media honoured four soldiers who had died. Independent estimates of Chinese deaths have varied widely, so the exact toll on that side remains uncertain.

Why the India–China border is disputed

India and China share a frontier of more than 3,000 kilometres that has never been fully agreed. In the west, China controls Aksai Chin, which India claims as part of Ladakh. In the east, China claims most of the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh. Between the two armies runs the Line of Actual Control, or LAC: a de facto boundary whose exact course each side reads differently on the ground.

The two countries fought a short war over these claims in 1962, which China won decisively. In 1967 India came out ahead in clashes at Nathu La and Cho La in Sikkim. After an ambush in 1975 in which Indian soldiers were killed, the border stayed free of combat deaths for 45 years, kept quiet by a series of agreements on patrolling and on not using firearms. Galwan shattered that record.

Part of the reason for the 2020 friction was construction. India had been building roads and airstrips that brought its forces closer to the LAC, including a strategic road to the Daulat Beg Oldi air base near the Karakoram Pass. China had long built up its own side. Each viewed the other's projects as an attempt to change facts on the ground.

How India prepared for a possible war

In the days after the clash, India sent clear signals that it was ready for escalation if diplomacy failed. The Times of India described forces as being on an almost war-like alert along the LAC. Fighter jets and helicopters were moved to forward bases in Ladakh, and the armed forces were given emergency powers to buy weapons and ammunition quickly to top up war reserves. Indian media also reported that the navy was deploying ships towards the Strait of Malacca and the Indian Ocean, a reminder that pressure on land could be answered at sea, where much of China's trade passes.

On 20 June 2020 India changed its rules of engagement so that commanders on the LAC could allow the use of firearms in "extraordinary" situations. That was a significant shift away from decades of practice.

India's response was economic too. By November 2020 the government had banned more than 200 Chinese apps, including TikTok and others from ByteDance and Tencent, citing security and privacy. It tightened checks on Chinese investment and contracts, and stepped up work on border roads.

There were also claims of conflict in cyberspace. Some Indian media reported attempted cyber attacks traced to China in this period, and in the same week Australia's prime minister said his country was being targeted by a sophisticated "state-based" actor, which many commentators assumed to be China. These reports were not independently confirmed in detail, and Beijing denied involvement.

What China said

Beijing's public line was to calm talk of war while blaming India for the clash. Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian (a spokesman, not the foreign minister) said the trouble began because Indian front-line troops crossed the LAC in breach of an agreement reached at a commanders' meeting and attacked Chinese personnel who had come to negotiate. India rejected that account and said Chinese troops had tried to change the status quo.

At the same time, Zhao stressed the wider relationship, saying the world's two largest developing countries had far more common interests than differences and should follow the consensus reached by their leaders. That two-track message, firm on the incident and soft on the relationship, set the tone for months of talks.

The United States said it was following the situation closely and hoped for a peaceful resolution, without offering to mediate. India has generally preferred to handle its border disputes bilaterally.

How the standoff was wound down

De-escalation was slow and happened sector by sector. Troops pulled back partly from Galwan, Hot Springs and Gogra in mid-2020. In February 2021, after many rounds of talks between corps commanders, both sides completed a pullback from the north and south banks of Pangong Tso. Talks continued into 2022, with buffer zones agreed at several friction points.

In late 2024 the two governments reached a further understanding on patrolling in the remaining disputed areas, and on 3 December 2024 India's foreign minister, S. Jaishankar, told parliament that disengagement in eastern Ladakh had been achieved in full. That ended the most dangerous phase, but large numbers of troops remain on both sides of a line that is still undefined.

What the Galwan clash changed

Galwan showed how quickly an old, quiet dispute could turn lethal, even without a shot being fired. It hardened public opinion in India against China, pushed New Delhi closer to partners such as the United States, Japan and Australia, and led both countries to keep far more soldiers and infrastructure on the high plateau than before 2020.

It also showed the value of the old rules. The no-firearms practice that made the fight so savage is also probably what kept the death toll in the tens rather than the hundreds. For anyone trying to understand India–China relations today, the summer of 2020 remains the turning point.

Sources: Wikipedia: 2020–2021 China–India skirmishes; Gulf News, 20 February 2021; Press Trust of India on X/Twitter, 17 June 2020. Indian Air Force photo: Pablo Lopez/Flickr, Creative Commons.

COMMENTS