The June 2020 Maya Doomsday Claim: Why the Maths Was Wrong

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-18.

The 2020 Maya Calendar Doomsday Claim, and Why It Was Wrong

In June 2020 a viral claim said the Maya calendar had not predicted the end of the world for 21 December 2012 after all, but for 21 June 2020. The idea spread through tabloid websites and social media, citing a supposed scientist named Paolo Tagaloguin who had worked out that the switch from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar meant we were "really" still in 2012. The short answer: the arithmetic was wrong, the Maya never predicted the end of the world in the first place, and 21 June 2020 came and went like any other Sunday.

The story is still a useful case study in how doomsday rumours work, so here is where it came from, why the numbers fail, what the Maya Long Count actually records, and how to spot the next version of the same hoax.

Where the 21 June 2020 date came from

The claim went like this: when the world moved from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar, 11 days were "lost" every year. Multiply 11 days by the 268 years since Britain switched in 1752, divide by 365, and you get about eight years. Subtract eight years from 2020 and, so the argument went, the Maya end date of 2012 lands in the present.

The quotation was said to come from a tweet that had since been deleted. Posts repeating it circulated widely, like the one below.

Astronomer Phil Plait, writing for SYFY Wire, tried to trace the source and found nothing. He could not find a Twitter account for anyone of that name, and the tabloid stories mostly linked to each other in a circle, with some links leading nowhere. There is no good evidence that a scientist called Paolo Tagaloguin exists or made the calculation.

Why the calendar arithmetic fails

The whole claim rests on one mistake. The change from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar was a one-off correction, not an ongoing yearly loss. As Plait put it: The Gregorian calendar does not lose 11 days per year!

Here is what actually happened. The Julian calendar, introduced under Julius Caesar, added a leap day every four years without exception. That made its average year slightly too long, so over the centuries the calendar drifted away from the seasons. In 1582 Pope Gregory XIII introduced a corrected calendar: ten days were skipped once, so that Thursday 4 October 1582 was followed by Friday 15 October, and a new leap-year rule dropped three leap days every 400 years. Under that rule, century years such as 1900 are not leap years unless divisible by 400, which is why 2000 was one.

Countries adopted the new calendar at different times. Britain and its colonies switched in 1752 by dropping 11 days, again just once. Greece was the last European country to switch for civil purposes, in 1923. Today the gap between the two calendars is 13 days, not eight years, and the Julian calendar survives mainly in the church calendars of some Orthodox Christians.

There is a second problem too. The 21 December 2012 date had already been converted from the Maya system directly into the Gregorian calendar, so bringing the Julian calendar into it at all makes no sense.

What the Maya Long Count actually says

The Maya used several interlocking calendars. The one behind the 2012 story is the Long Count, which counts days from a fixed starting point in the distant past, rather like a car's odometer. Its large units are called b'ak'tuns; each lasts 144,000 days, or about 394 years.

The date written 13.0.0.0.0 marks the completion of the 13th b'ak'tun. Most scholars place it on 21 December 2012 using the standard correlation, though some prefer 23 December, and the exact match between the Maya and Western calendars is still debated. After 13.0.0.0.0, the count simply carries on, in the same way that 1999 rolled over into 2000.

Only one known Maya inscription, Tortuguero Monument 6 from what is now Mexico, refers to the 13th b'ak'tun in any detail. It is partly damaged, and scholars read it as describing a ritual or the presence of a god, not a catastrophe. Mayanist Mark Van Stone summed up the specialists' view: The notion of a 'Great Cycle' coming to an end is completely a modern invention.

How the 2012 doomsday story grew

The idea that 2012 would bring disaster owed more to modern culture than to the Maya. One strand came from the Nibiru myth, the claim that a hidden planet would collide with Earth, which appeared from 1995 and was first tied to May 2003. When nothing happened, believers attached it to the end of the 13th b'ak'tun.

Roland Emmerich's 2009 disaster film 2012, which earned nearly $770 million worldwide, added spectacle, and its marketing campaign included a fake scientific "institute" that convinced some viewers the threat was real. NASA received thousands of anxious questions and published an explainer in 2009. It stated that There is no credible evidence for any of the assertions made in support of unusual events taking place in December 2012.

The fear was real for some people. A May 2012 Ipsos poll across 21 countries found that 8% of adults felt fear or anxiety about the world ending that December, and about one in ten agreed that the Maya calendar marked the end of the world.

The "ring of fire" eclipse coincidence

Part of what made the June 2020 claim spread was timing. On 21 June 2020 there was an annular solar eclipse, when the Moon passes in front of the Sun but is slightly too far from Earth to cover it completely, leaving a bright ring. The narrow path of annularity crossed parts of central and east Africa, the southern Arabian Peninsula, Pakistan, northern India, southern China and Taiwan, with the ring lasting at most about 38 seconds.

Eclipses are among the most predictable events in nature; astronomers can calculate them centuries in advance. A coincidence between an eclipse and a rumour is exactly that, and the same June date is also the northern solstice every year.

The wider context helped too. 2020 had already brought a pandemic, lockdowns and wildfires, and a frightening headline found a ready audience. You can read more on Maya civilisation and on real scientific warnings about global risks elsewhere on the site.

How to spot a doomsday hoax

Predictions of the end of the world have a perfect record of failure, but new ones keep appearing. A few quick checks help:

  • Find the original source. If every article links to another article, and none to a named expert or a published paper, be wary.
  • Check the expert. A real scientist usually has a university, a publication record or a professional profile you can find.
  • Test the maths. Many hoaxes rely on one simple error, like treating a one-time change as a yearly one.
  • Ask specialists in the field. On the Maya, archaeologists and epigraphers have been clear for years that no doomsday was predicted.
  • Notice moved deadlines. When a predicted date passes and a new one is announced, the theory is being rescued, not confirmed.

The weekend of 21 June 2020 passed quietly, as 21 December 2012 had before it. The Maya left behind a sophisticated calendar and a remarkable record of astronomy, and that achievement is far more interesting than the myths attached to it.

Sources: SYFY Wire (Phil Plait): No, the Maya did not predict the end of the world on 21 June 2020; Wikipedia: 2012 phenomenon; Wikipedia: Gregorian calendar; Wikipedia: Solar eclipse of June 21, 2020; The Register: NASA says world not ending in 2012 (November 2009).

COMMENTS