Virginia Pastor Arrested After Calling 911 for Help Gets an Apology

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-22.

Virginia Sheriff Apologises to Black Pastor Arrested After a Racist Threat

In June 2020, a 61-year-old Black pastor and Air Force veteran in rural Virginia called 911 for help after being surrounded and threatened by a group of people, and ended up being the one taken away in handcuffs. Days later the local sheriff apologised, the charge against the pastor was dropped, and five members of the group were charged instead, including with hate-crime offences.

The pastor is Leon K. McCray Sr., who leads a church in Woodstock, in Shenandoah County. His case drew national attention because it happened in the same weeks that the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis had sent protesters into the streets across the United States, and it seemed to capture, in one small-town afternoon, the complaint many Black Americans were making: that calling the police does not always bring them protection.

Here is what happened, what each side said, why the original charge collapsed, and what the case shows about self-defence and policing.

What happened on 1 June 2020

McCray owns an apartment property in Edinburg, a town of about 1,100 people in the Shenandoah Valley. On 1 June he was visiting it when he saw a man and a woman who did not live there dragging an old refrigerator towards his dumpster. He asked them to stop and leave. According to McCray, they became angry and confrontational.

The pair left, but the man came back with three other people. McCray says the group surrounded him, shouted racist abuse and threatened to kill him, and that one of them charged at him. He was legally carrying a concealed handgun under a valid permit. Fearing for his life, he drew it, which stopped the advance, and called 911.

When Shenandoah County deputies arrived, McCray says, they did not let him give his side. They took his gun, handcuffed him in front of the people who had threatened him, and drove him away, while the group remained. He was charged with brandishing a firearm. McCray later said one officer told him he disagreed with the decision but had to make the arrest.

The pastor’s account

McCray described the experience in a sermon at his church, Lighthouse Church & Marketplace Ministries International, on 7 June. He spoke of a humiliation that went far beyond the charge itself, telling the congregation that he felt "literally, like I had been lynched without being killed."

He pointed out that he had served 24 years in the US Air Force, retiring as a master sergeant, had worked for years as a real estate investor, and had never been arrested in his life. His frustration was not only that he was arrested, but that the people he says assaulted and threatened him were not dealt with at the scene. He argued that charges against them should have been brought from the start.

A video of the sermon and his story spread quickly online, and local and national media, including The Washington Post and Fox News, picked it up.

The sheriff’s apology and the new charges

Shenandoah County Sheriff Timothy Carter met McCray two days after the incident. He then asked the prosecutor to drop the brandishing charge and publicly apologised. Carter said the charge was not appropriate and added that "if I were faced with similar circumstances, I would have probably done the same thing."

After reviewing the case, the sheriff's office obtained new warrants. Five people from Edinburg were charged and held without bond:

  • Donny Salyers, 43, Farrah Salyers, 42, and Christopher Sharp, 57, were charged with felony abduction, assault by a mob and assault as a hate crime.
  • Dennis Salyers, 26, and Amanda Salyers, 26, were charged with assault by a mob and assault as a hate crime; Dennis Salyers was also charged with assault and battery.

Some of them had initially faced only assault or trespassing charges. Sharp's lawyer said his client, a tenant of the Salyers family, believed they had permission to use the dumpster and had taken the refrigerator back before leaving. Like anyone charged with a crime, all five were entitled to the presumption of innocence.

The sheriff's office also placed two supervisors on unpaid administrative leave while it investigated how the call was handled. Some early reports described them as the two arresting officers, but The Washington Post identified them as supervisors. Carter also issued a statement stressing his office's commitment to the county's minority communities, and to residents' right to bear arms.

Why the brandishing charge did not hold

Virginia's brandishing law makes it a misdemeanour to point, hold or wave a firearm in a way that reasonably makes another person fear being shot. But the same law contains an important exception: it does not apply to someone acting in excusable or justifiable self-defence.

On McCray's account, he was facing several people who had threatened to kill him and one who was rushing at him. Displaying a legally carried gun to stop that attack, and immediately calling the police, is a textbook example of the kind of situation the exception exists for. That is essentially what the sheriff concluded when he said he would have done the same.

The case raised an uncomfortable question that gun-rights advocates and civil-rights advocates both noticed. Virginia allows law-abiding citizens to carry a concealed weapon for protection. If a Black permit holder who uses that right defensively, and then calls 911, is the one arrested, the right is not being applied equally.

A story that fitted a national moment

The incident took place one week after George Floyd was killed by a Minneapolis police officer on 25 May 2020, and during the wave of protests against police brutality that followed. Many people saw McCray's experience as a small but familiar example of a wider pattern: Black callers treated as suspects when they ask for help.

It is worth being precise about what the case does and does not show. The sheriff moved quickly to admit the mistake once he heard McCray's side. What it shows is how decisions made in the first minutes of a call, about who is believed and who is handcuffed, can shape everything that follows. McCray himself said he appreciated the sheriff's response but wanted lasting change in how the county handles such calls.

What can help in situations like this

Lawyers and civil-rights groups commonly give a few pieces of advice to anyone who has to defend themselves. Call 911 yourself and say clearly that you are the one being threatened. Follow officers' instructions calmly, even if you feel wronged. Ask for names and badge numbers, write down what happened as soon as you can, and identify witnesses. And if you are arrested after defending yourself, speak to a lawyer before making any further statement.

Watch the pastor tell his story

The video below includes McCray describing the encounter and its aftermath in his own words.

Sources: The Washington Post (June 2020): A Black pastor was arrested after he called 911 for help; Fox News (16 June 2020): Black pastor arrested in Virginia; hate-crime charges filed.

COMMENTS