Man Spent Four Days in Closed New Haven Restaurant, Police Say

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-05-03.

A Restaurant Break-In and Self-Isolation Claim in 2020

In April 2020, with Connecticut's restaurants closed to diners because of COVID-19, police in New Haven arrested a man they said had climbed into a shuttered Cuban café and spent about four days inside, eating its food and working through its bar. The 42-year-old was found asleep in the restaurant with a bottle of rum and charged with burglary, larceny and criminal mischief.

The story spread around the world as a lockdown oddity, often told as a man who "quarantined himself" in a restaurant. The facts are less amusing for the owners: a small business, already shut by the pandemic, lost thousands of dollars of stock.

What police say happened

According to the New Haven Police Department, officers were called to a burglary in progress at Soul de Cuba Café on Crown Street, in the city's downtown, at about 11:30 a.m. on Tuesday 14 April 2020. A manager doing a routine check of the closed restaurant had found a man sleeping inside, a bottle of rum close by.

Officers detained the man nearby on Crown Street and identified him as Louis Angel Ortiz of New Haven. Security footage reviewed afterwards showed him getting in through a side window on the previous Saturday, which means he had been inside, on and off, for several days before anyone noticed.

Police said that during that time he helped himself to food, liquor and beer, and that he also carried drinks and other property out of the building. The restaurant's management estimated its losses at several thousand dollars, including roughly 70 bottles of liquor that were either drunk or taken.

The restaurant behind the headlines

Soul de Cuba is a downtown café serving home-style Cuban food, with a bar alongside the kitchen. Like every sit-down restaurant in Connecticut, it had been barred from serving customers inside since mid-March 2020 under the state's emergency orders, leaving many places closed altogether or limited to takeaway.

That context matters. A closed restaurant with a stocked kitchen and bar, and nobody there for days at a time, is an easy target. For a business already losing most of its income, replacing 70 bottles of spirits and the contents of a kitchen was a real blow.

The charges, explained

Some early reports said Ortiz was charged with "robbery". That is not what police listed, and the difference is important. In US law, robbery means taking property from a person by force or the threat of force. Entering a building unlawfully to commit a crime inside is burglary. The New Haven police release listed these charges:

  • Burglary in the third degree, which in Connecticut covers unlawfully entering or remaining in a building with intent to commit a crime there.
  • Larceny in the third degree, a theft charge that in Connecticut generally applies when the value of the property is above $2,000.
  • Criminal mischief in the first degree, which relates to damaging someone else's property, and in the first degree generally to damage above $1,500.
  • Failure to appear in the second degree, linked to a separate warrant from East Haven.

Police said he was held in lieu of a $12,500 bond and taken to New Haven Superior Court for arraignment. As with any arrest, these were allegations at the time, and a charge is not a conviction.

Why the "self-quarantine" angle stuck

Many outlets framed the case as a man quarantining inside a restaurant, because it landed at the height of stay-at-home orders, when much of the world was stuck indoors and craving a meal out. It is easy to see why the image of someone with an entire Cuban kitchen and bar to himself went viral.

The framing does not hold up, though. Quarantine is a public-health measure taken in your own home or in a designated place; it gives no right to occupy someone else's property. Police treated the case as a straightforward break-in, and that is how it should be understood.

Empty businesses during lockdown

The New Haven case was one of many reports in spring 2020 of closed businesses being targeted. With shops, bars and restaurants shut and city streets far quieter than usual, police in several US cities reported break-ins at closed commercial premises, even as some other crimes dropped. Liquor, cash registers and electronics were frequent targets.

Owners in many places responded by emptying their tills, moving alcohol off-site, boarding up windows, or paying someone to check on the premises daily. Insurance was another worry, because some policies have conditions about buildings left unoccupied for long periods.

Practical lessons for owners of closed premises

For anyone who has to leave a shop, café or office empty for a while, whether for a pandemic, renovation or a seasonal closure, the Soul de Cuba break-in suggests a few simple precautions:

  • Check in often and at varied times. Here, the manager's routine visit is what ended the four-day stay. Daily checks would likely have caught it sooner.
  • Use cameras you can view remotely. The café's video helped police piece together what happened, but a live alert might have prevented the losses.
  • Secure side and back openings. Police said entry was through a side window, a common weak point that is easy to overlook.
  • Remove or lock up high-value stock. Alcohol, cash and electronics attract thieves; storing them elsewhere reduces the incentive.
  • Read your insurance policy. Find out whether long closures change your cover and what steps the insurer expects.

The story is remembered as a strange lockdown tale, but at its heart it is a reminder of how exposed small businesses were during the 2020 closures.

Sources: NewsChannel 5 (Scripps), April 2020: Police: Man spends days eating, drinking bottles of liquor inside restaurant closed due to COVID-19, citing the New Haven Police Department's statement.

COMMENTS