Did George Floyd and Derek Chauvin Work at the Same Nightclub?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published May 30, 2020.

Yes, according to the woman who owned the club. In late May 2020, days after George Floyd died under the knee of Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, former owner Maya Santamaria told local station KSTP that both men had worked security at her Latin nightclub, El Nuevo Rodeo. What her account did not show is that the two men actually knew each other. That gap is the most important thing to understand about this story, and it is easy to lose in a headline.

Floyd and Chauvin's Reported Nightclub Employment in 2020

What the former club owner said

Santamaria ran El Nuevo Rodeo on Lake Street in south Minneapolis for about 17 years before selling the business. The same building housed La Raza, a Spanish-language radio station she also led, and NPR noted that the building burned during the unrest that followed Floyd's death.

Her description of the two jobs was specific. Chauvin, she said, had worked at the venue as an off-duty police officer for most of its life. In her words, as reported by NPR: "Chauvin was our off-duty police for almost the entirety of the 17 years that we were open." Floyd worked as a bouncer. According to KSTP, the two were on the payroll at the same time as recently as 2019.

She added two details that shaped how people read the story. First, she did not recognise Floyd in the bystander video at first, because he looked so different on the ground; it was a friend who pointed out that the man was one of her former guards. Second, she was critical of Chauvin's conduct at the club, saying he had "a real short fuse" and reached for mace or pepper spray in situations she felt did not call for it.

Did Floyd and Chauvin know each other?

Nobody has shown that they did. Santamaria herself said she was unsure whether the two men had ever met and could only say that their paths may have crossed. The roles also kept them apart: Chauvin mostly worked outside the building, while Floyd and the other guards worked inside. On a busy night the club reportedly used several doormen at once, so sharing an employer did not mean sharing a shift, let alone a friendship or a feud.

A few days later a former co-worker told a television station that he believed the two had clashed at the club. That claim, which we covered in a follow-up piece, came from a single person and was not confirmed by other witnesses. It never became a central part of the criminal case.

It is easy to see why the nightclub link spread so quickly. People who watched the video wanted to understand how a man could kneel on another man's neck for more than nine minutes, and a prior grudge would have offered a simple explanation. But a coincidence of employment is not evidence of motive, and treating it as one risks distracting from what the video and the later trial actually showed.

How the criminal case unfolded

When the nightclub story broke, Chauvin had just been arrested. On 29 May 2020 he was charged with third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter, and on 3 June prosecutors added a more serious count of second-degree murder. The three other officers at the scene, Thomas Lane, J. Alexander Kueng and Tou Thao, were charged that same day with aiding and abetting.

On 20 April 2021 a Hennepin County jury convicted Chauvin on all three counts, and in June 2021 he was sentenced to 22½ years in prison. He later pleaded guilty to federal civil rights charges and received a 21-year federal sentence in July 2022, served at the same time. The other three officers were convicted in federal court in February 2022 and later pleaded guilty to, or were found guilty of, state manslaughter-related charges, with sentences of roughly three to five years.

The prosecution's case rested on the restraint itself: how long it lasted, Floyd's repeated pleas that he could not breathe, and the medical evidence about how he died. Whether the men had once worked under the same roof was not what decided the verdict.

A country in protest: the last week of May 2020

The nightclub claim surfaced during one of the most turbulent weeks in recent American history. Protests began in Minneapolis on 26 May, and by 28 May demonstrators had set fire to the city's Third Precinct police station. Unrest soon spread to dozens of cities.

Several incidents from those days made international news. CNN correspondent Omar Jimenez and his crew were arrested by Minnesota State Patrol troopers during a live broadcast on 29 May and released about an hour later, after Governor Tim Walz apologised. That evening, protesters damaged the outside of the CNN Center in Atlanta. In Louisville, Kentucky, seven people were reported shot during a protest over the March 2020 police killing of Breonna Taylor, and in Detroit a 19-year-old man was shot dead near a demonstration.

Journalists were frequently caught up in the violence. The U.S. Press Freedom Tracker later counted at least 100 journalists arrested and more than 100 physically attacked by police while covering the protests, and many people were injured by so-called less-lethal rounds, including some who lost sight in one eye.

The Breonna Taylor case followed its own long path. Louisville agreed in September 2020 to pay her family $12 million and to adopt police reforms, and in November 2024 a federal jury convicted former officer Brett Hankison of violating her civil rights.

Tucker Carlson's reaction and the wider debate

Commentary split sharply along political lines. On Fox News, host Tucker Carlson, whose name was sometimes garbled in early write-ups, condemned the Minneapolis unrest on 27 May and called it "a form of tyranny", according to The Daily Beast. In later broadcasts he reportedly argued that rioting was worse than the other wrongs in the news that spring, from police brutality to the viral Central Park confrontation with a Black birdwatcher.

Critics asked why the destruction of property drew stronger outrage from some commentators than the deaths of Floyd and Taylor. Supporters of Carlson's view answered that riots harm the very neighbourhoods they claim to defend, including many small businesses owned by immigrants and people of colour. Both arguments were part of a national conversation about policing, protest and public order that continued well beyond 2020.

Reading breaking-news claims carefully

The nightclub story is a good case study in how early reports work. A few habits help when a dramatic detail appears in the first days after a major event:

  • Check who is the source. Here, almost everything traced back to one former owner speaking to one local station.
  • Separate the claim from the conclusion. "They worked at the same club" is not the same as "they knew each other", and neither is the same as "this explains the killing".
  • Look for follow-ups. Later reporting and the trial record give a clearer picture than first-day headlines.
  • Notice what the courts relied on. A jury verdict is based on evidence presented and tested, not on the most viral angle.

Floyd's death changed public debate about policing around the world. The detail that he and the officer who killed him once worked at the same Minneapolis nightclub remains a striking coincidence, but on the evidence available it is just that.

Sources: NPR: George Floyd and Derek Chauvin were co-workers, says former club owner (citing KSTP); Wikipedia: Murder of George Floyd; Wikipedia: George Floyd protests; Wikipedia: Killing of Breonna Taylor; The Daily Beast. Videos: YouTube news clips from May 2020.

COMMENTS