Ahmaud Arbery Murder: Charges, Trial, Verdicts and Sentences

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-05-12.

Father and Son Charged With Murder in Ahmaud Arbery’s Killing

Ahmaud Arbery, a 25-year-old Black man, was chased and shot dead while out running near Brunswick, Georgia, on 23 February 2020. For more than two months nobody was arrested. Then, on 7 May 2020, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation charged Gregory McMichael, 64, and his son Travis McMichael, 34, with murder. A neighbour who filmed the killing, William "Roddie" Bryan, was arrested two weeks later.

All three were convicted of murder in November 2021 and sentenced to life in prison, and in 2022 a federal jury also found them guilty of hate crimes. This is the full story of the case, from the shooting to the sentences, and why it changed Georgia law.

What happened on 23 February 2020

Arbery was jogging through Satilla Shores, a small residential area in Glynn County just outside the coastal city of Brunswick, shortly after 1 p.m. His family said running was part of his daily routine.

Gregory McMichael, a former police officer and investigator for the local district attorney's office, saw him pass and later told police he thought Arbery looked like a man suspected in a series of break-ins in the neighbourhood. He and his son armed themselves, Gregory with a handgun and Travis with a shotgun, and set off after Arbery in a pickup truck. Bryan joined the pursuit in his own vehicle.

The chase lasted several minutes. Gregory McMichael claimed they called out for Arbery to stop because they wanted to talk to him. Bryan's phone video shows Arbery running towards the stopped truck, moving around it, and then struggling with Travis McMichael over the shotgun. Three shots were fired, and Arbery died in the road.

Arbery was unarmed and was carrying nothing stolen. There was never any evidence linking him to a burglary. At most, he had been seen looking around a house under construction, as other people from the area had done.

Why no one was arrested for ten weeks

The delay became a scandal of its own. Gregory McMichael had worked for years in the office of Brunswick District Attorney Jackie Johnson, and she stepped aside from the case. A second prosecutor also recused himself after it emerged that his son worked in Johnson's office; before doing so he had written that the McMichaels acted lawfully under Georgia's citizen's arrest and self-defence laws.

Arbery's mother, Wanda Cooper-Jones, has said police initially told her that her son had been involved in a burglary and was shot by a homeowner. That account turned out to be untrue.

In September 2021, Johnson was indicted on charges of showing favour to McMichael and obstructing police. She was later found not guilty of obstruction, and the remaining charge was dismissed on a technicality.

The video that changed the case

On 5 May 2020, Bryan's cellphone video was published online after a local lawyer passed it to a radio station, reportedly at Gregory McMichael's request. It spread across social media within hours and caused national outrage.

The state's Georgia Bureau of Investigation took over the case and arrested the McMichaels two days later. Bryan, who had been treated as a witness, was arrested on 21 May. Arbery's family lawyer, S. Lee Merritt, called the killing "a modern-day lynching," and protesters marked what would have been Arbery's 26th birthday on 8 May by running 2.23 miles in his memory.

Weeks later, the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis sparked worldwide protests. Arbery's name was among those most often heard in the Black Lives Matter demonstrations of summer 2020, alongside Floyd and Breonna Taylor.

The murder trial and sentences

The state trial opened in Brunswick in October 2021. The defence argued that the men were making a lawful citizen's arrest and that Travis McMichael fired in self-defence. Prosecutors answered that they had no legal grounds to detain Arbery and had chased him like prey with weapons.

On 24 November 2021 the jury, which included only one Black member, returned its verdicts:

  • Travis McMichael was convicted of malice murder, felony murder and other charges.
  • Gregory McMichael was acquitted of malice murder but convicted of felony murder and other charges.
  • William Bryan was acquitted of malice murder but convicted of felony murder and other charges.

On 7 January 2022, Judge Timothy Walmsley sentenced both McMichaels to life without parole, plus 20 years. Bryan received life with the possibility of parole after 30 years.

The federal hate crime convictions

A separate federal case followed. On 22 February 2022, a jury in Brunswick found all three men guilty of interference with Arbery's rights, a federal hate crime, and of attempted kidnapping. The McMichaels were also convicted of using a firearm during a crime of violence. Evidence included racist messages and comments the men had made before the killing.

In August 2022, Travis McMichael received life plus 10 years, Gregory McMichael life plus 7 years, and Bryan 35 years in federal prison.

How Georgia law changed

The case had lasting effects on Georgia's statute books:

  • Hate crimes law: In June 2020 Georgia, until then one of a handful of states with no hate crimes law, passed legislation allowing tougher sentences for crimes motivated by race and other characteristics.
  • Citizen's arrest: In May 2021 the state repealed and replaced its Civil War-era citizen's arrest law, which the defendants had relied on. The new rules sharply limit when private citizens may detain someone.

Arbery's family continues to campaign in his name. His case is now widely taught as an example of how racial assumptions, armed vigilantism and close ties between suspects and local officials can delay justice, and how a single video can force a case back into the open.

Sources: Wikipedia: Murder of Ahmaud Arbery; witness video recorded by William Bryan, as published in May 2020.

COMMENTS