Canada's C$4 Billion Pay Top-Up for Low-Wage Essential Workers

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-05-25.

Canada's Essential-Worker Pay Support Announcement in 2020

On 7 May 2020, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced that Canada's federal government had reached agreements with the provinces and territories to raise the pay of low-wage essential workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. Ottawa committed up to C$3 billion, and the provinces and territories were expected to add roughly C$1 billion, for a combined package of about C$4 billion. Crucially, it was not a single national raise: each province and territory decided which workers qualified and how much extra they would receive.

The measure was a temporary top-up rather than a permanent increase to the minimum wage, and it came with a pointed message from the prime minister about who keeps a country running in a crisis.

What was announced and who it was for

In the spring of 2020 most Canadians were told to stay home, but supermarket cashiers, cleaners, care-home aides, food-plant workers, delivery drivers and many others kept going to work. Many of them earned at or near the minimum wage, and many worked in places where the virus spread easily.

Explaining the decision, Trudeau said: "If you're risking your health to keep this country moving and you're making minimum wage, you deserve a raise." He also acknowledged that the pandemic had exposed how economically vulnerable many of the people society depends on really were.

The federal guidance focused on essential workers earning less than about C$2,500 a month. Some reports at the time gave the figure as roughly $1,800; that was the approximate amount in US dollars, not Canadian dollars. Front-line health and care workers and some food-sector staff were generally given priority, but the exact eligibility rules were left to each provincial and territorial government.

How the provinces put it into practice

Because provinces set the details, a worker's experience depended heavily on where they lived. Several provinces had already begun their own schemes before the federal deal, and the new money helped fund or extend them. Examples reported at the time included:

  • Quebec: an incentive worth about C$890 million for roughly 600,000 low-income essential workers, paying C$1,600 over four months, backdated to mid-March.
  • Ontario: a temporary pandemic payment of C$4 an hour for many front-line workers, especially in health care, long-term care and social services.
  • Saskatchewan: a top-up of C$400 a month for 16 weeks for lower-paid workers caring for vulnerable people, such as in long-term care, child care and shelters, who earned under C$2,500 a month.

Other provinces and territories designed their own versions over the following weeks. The patchwork meant that two people doing almost identical jobs in different provinces could receive quite different amounts, and some groups, such as certain retail or agricultural workers, were included in one place and not in another.

The crisis in long-term care

The urgency was driven above all by what was happening in nursing and long-term care homes. Around 80% of Canada's COVID-19 deaths in that first wave were among residents of long-term care facilities, one of the highest such shares among wealthy countries. By late May 2020 Canada had recorded more than 80,000 confirmed cases and over 6,000 deaths.

Staff shortages were severe. Many care aides worked part-time at several homes to make a living, which helped the virus move between facilities, and many fell ill themselves. The situation became so serious that the federal government sent more than 1,600 members of the Canadian Armed Forces into care homes in Quebec and Ontario. Quebec Premier François Legault said the province's biggest challenge was a lack of staff in its health system. Trudeau himself said soldiers should not be the ones caring for seniors and promised to work with the provinces on a lasting solution.

Support and criticism

The principle of rewarding essential workers had support across party lines, but the details drew criticism. Unions and opposition politicians said help had been slow to arrive and worried it would be a one-off gesture.

Sharleen Stewart, president of SEIU Healthcare, one of Canada's largest health-care unions, argued that the lowest-paid workers were among those keeping people alive and caring for their loved ones. She said they needed to see the money quickly, without bureaucratic delays, and called for a lasting living wage rather than emergency pay. New Democratic Party MP Peter Julian made a similar point: in his view, the pandemic had exposed problems that already existed, particularly the lack of adequate resources in seniors' care.

How it fit with Canada's other pandemic measures

The wage top-up sat alongside a much larger set of federal programmes. The Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) paid C$2,000 every four weeks to eligible people who had lost income. One concern was that some low-wage workers might earn barely more by working than by staying home on CERB. Topping up essential workers' pay helped make sure that those who kept working were not worse off for taking the risk.

The same period brought an extra C$300 per child through the Canada Child Benefit, a one-time boost to the GST credit, support for students and the extension of the work-sharing programme.

What the episode taught

A few lessons stand out from the 2020 debate:

  • "Essential" and "well paid" are not the same thing. Many of the jobs society could least do without were among the lowest paid.
  • Federal programmes depend on provinces. In areas like health and labour, Ottawa can fund and encourage, but provinces deliver, which produces uneven results.
  • Temporary bonuses do not fix structural problems. Reviews of the first wave pointed to low wages, part-time work and understaffing in long-term care as long-standing issues that the pandemic made impossible to ignore.

For workers in Canada, the 2020 top-ups have long since ended. Anyone checking their own entitlement to pay, sick leave or other benefits today should look at the current rules of their province or territory and of the federal government, which have changed several times since.

Sources: Prime Minister of Canada: agreements to boost wages for essential workers (7 May 2020); Radio Canada International: feds and provinces reach deal on pay top-up; CNN: Canada raises wages for essential workers.

COMMENTS