Originally published 2020-05-05.

Yes, the ozone layer over Antarctica is slowly recovering, and a 2020 study in Nature found that this recovery has already had a measurable effect on the weather of the Southern Hemisphere. Around the year 2000, the band of strong westerly winds known as the southern jet stream stopped drifting towards the South Pole, a trend that had run for decades. The researchers traced this pause to the Montreal Protocol, the 1987 treaty that phased out ozone-destroying chemicals. They also warned that the pause may not last, because rising carbon dioxide pushes the winds in the opposite direction.
What the 2020 Nature study found
The paper, titled “A pause in Southern Hemisphere circulation trends due to the Montreal Protocol”, was published on 25 March 2020. It was led by atmospheric scientist Antara Banerjee, who began the work at Columbia University in the group of Lorenzo Polvani and was by then a CIRES visiting fellow at NOAA in Boulder, Colorado. Co-authors included John Fyfe of Environment and Climate Change Canada and Darryn Waugh.
The team looked at several linked features of the southern atmosphere: the position of the mid-latitude jet, the Southern Annular Mode (a seesaw of air pressure between Antarctica and the mid-latitudes) and the width of the Hadley cell, the tropical circulation that shapes where dry zones lie. In the late twentieth century all three were shifting poleward. Around 2000 those trends stalled, and in some measures reversed slightly.
Using a detection and attribution method, which compares observed patterns with model simulations of different causes, the authors showed that natural variability alone could not explain the pause. The change in stratospheric ozone could. Polvani summed it up in a Columbia University release: The pause is a direct consequence of the Montreal Protocol.
Polvani and Seok-woo Son had predicted this outcome in a 2008 modelling study. The 2020 paper was important because it found the signal in real observations, not only in models.
Why the ozone hole moved the winds
Ozone in the stratosphere absorbs ultraviolet light and warms the air around it. When chlorine and bromine from CFCs and halons destroyed ozone over Antarctica each spring, the polar stratosphere grew colder. That cooling strengthened the temperature contrast between the pole and lower latitudes and tightened the polar vortex, and its effects reached down into the lower atmosphere, nudging the westerly winds and their storm tracks southward.
Rising greenhouse gases push in the same poleward direction. Before 2000 the two influences worked together. Once ozone-depleting chemicals in the stratosphere peaked and began to decline, the ozone effect started to ease, roughly cancelling out the push from carbon dioxide. The result was a stand-off rather than a reversal.
A common misconception in early coverage was that the jet stream “causes hurricanes”. It does not. The Southern Hemisphere jet steers mid-latitude storm systems and rain-bearing fronts; tropical cyclones form under different conditions.
What this means for rainfall and Australia
The jet’s position matters for people on the ground because it decides where storms and rain fronts track. Earlier research linked the poleward shift to changes in rainfall over parts of South America, East Africa and Australia, and to changes in ocean currents and salinity in the Southern Ocean. Southern Australia in particular has seen a long-term decline in cool-season rainfall, and the southward drift of rain-bearing systems is one of the factors studied.
The 2020 paper itself was cautious. It suggested that the pause could affect rainfall and Southern Ocean circulation, but it did not show that rains had already returned to any particular region. Claims that ozone recovery will bring back Australian rainfall should be treated as a hypothesis under study, not a result.
A pause, not a happy ending
The researchers chose the word “pause” deliberately. Speaking about the paper, Banerjee explained that the poleward trends might resume, stay flat or reverse, adding: It's the tug of war between the opposing effects of ozone recovery and rising greenhouse gases that will determine future trends.
Some early retellings of the study claimed Banerjee blamed China’s rising emissions for the temporary nature of the change. That is not what the study or its press releases said. The tug of war is between ozone recovery and greenhouse gases worldwide. Separately, scientists did discover in 2018 that illegal production of the banned chemical CFC-11 was continuing in eastern Asia, and later studies traced much of it to eastern China. Emissions fell sharply after that was exposed, a sign that the treaty’s monitoring system works.
The 2019 ozone hole and the long road to recovery
The study arrived months after the Antarctic ozone hole of 2019 reached a peak of about 16.4 million square kilometres (6.3 million square miles) on 8 September. NASA and NOAA reported it as the smallest observed since 1982, not since 1987 as is sometimes said. The cause was mainly weather: unusual warming in the stratosphere weakened the polar vortex that year. NASA’s Paul Newman cautioned that it was not a sign that atmospheric ozone is suddenly on a fast track to recovery.
Real recovery is slow and steady. The Montreal Protocol, signed on 16 September 1987, is the only UN treaty ratified by every country. Scientific assessments project that ozone over Antarctica will return to 1980 levels around 2066, over the Arctic around 2045 and over most of the rest of the world around 2040. The 2016 Kigali Amendment extended the treaty to phase down HFCs, replacement chemicals that do not harm ozone but are powerful greenhouse gases.
The video below covers the news of the study and the shrinking ozone hole.
What the ozone story teaches about climate action
The ozone layer is often described as the best example of global environmental cooperation. Scientists identified the problem in the 1970s and 1980s, governments agreed a treaty within two years of the ozone hole’s discovery in 1985, industry developed substitutes, and the atmosphere began to respond within about fifteen years.
The 2020 study adds a further lesson. Cutting a pollutant does not only fix the original problem; it can ripple through the climate system, here shifting winds that shape rainfall across a hemisphere. It also shows the limits of that success. Ozone recovery alone cannot hold the jet stream in place while carbon dioxide keeps rising. The next stage of the tug of war depends on the same kind of cooperation, this time on greenhouse gases.
Sources: Banerjee et al., Nature 579 (2020): A pause in Southern Hemisphere circulation trends due to the Montreal Protocol; Columbia Climate School, State of the Planet: Ozone treaty stopped jet stream drift; NASA: 2019 ozone hole is the smallest on record since its discovery; Wikipedia: Montreal Protocol.

COMMENTS