Originally published 2020-05-02.

In late March and April 2020, as China declared victory over its first Covid-19 wave, foreign reporters described markets in southern China selling live animals again, including dogs, cats, and bats and scorpions offered as medicine. The reports caused outrage around the world. The key fact often lost in the anger is that China had not lifted its new ban: on 24 February 2020 its top legislature had outlawed eating terrestrial wild animals, and that ban stayed in force. What the reports showed was the gap between that law, its many exemptions, and what was happening on the ground.
What the reporters saw
The most widely shared account came from a Daily Mail correspondent in China at the end of March 2020. In one market, the correspondent described cats and dogs crammed into small, rusty cages and animals being slaughtered on a filthy floor. In Dongguan, in Guangdong province, a stall advertised bats and scorpions as remedies for illness.
The correspondent also described the mood among shoppers and traders: "Everyone here believes the outbreak is over and there's nothing to worry about anymore." And on the markets themselves: "The markets have gone back to operating in exactly the same way as they did before coronavirus." The one change, the reporter said, was that security guards now tried to stop people taking photographs.
These were eyewitness reports from a small number of markets, not a survey of China as a whole. They do, however, fit a wider picture of uneven enforcement that conservation groups described throughout 2020.
What China's February 2020 ban actually covered
On 24 February 2020 the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress adopted a decision to "thoroughly ban the illegal trading of wildlife and eliminate the consumption of wild animals". It was a real tightening. Before it, only the 402 species on China's state priority conservation list were banned as wild meat, and other wild animals could be eaten with a permit. Afterwards, eating any terrestrial wild animal, including captive-bred ones such as civets and bamboo rats, became illegal, as did hunting, trading or transporting them for food.
The decision also left large gaps, which explains much of what reporters saw:
- Medicine, research and display were still governed by older laws. Wild animal products could therefore still be sold legally as traditional medicine, which is how bats and scorpions could appear on a stall as remedies rather than food.
- Aquatic animals, including many amphibians and reptiles classed as aquatic, were not covered.
- Farmed species on the livestock list, such as deer, were still allowed, and fur animals like mink and raccoon dogs remained on that list.
- Dogs and cats were not wild animals under the law, so selling them was a separate issue. The city of Shenzhen separately moved to ban eating dogs and cats in 2020.
The Oxford Martin School, which analysed the decision at the time, also noted that the markets themselves had not been closed permanently. A ban on eating certain species is not the same as a ban on live-animal markets.
Was the Wuhan market reopened?
No. The Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan, linked to many of the earliest known Covid-19 cases, was closed on 1 January 2020 for cleaning and investigation and never reopened as a market. Reuters found it still barricaded and empty in December 2020. The reports of reopened markets concerned other cities.
Before it closed, Huanan did sell live wild animals. A study published in Scientific Reports in 2021 documented 38 wild species on sale in Wuhan's markets between 2017 and 2019, including raccoon dogs, masked palm civets and marmots, most of them sold illegally. That study did not record bats or pangolins on sale.
Where the virus came from: what is known
The origin of SARS-CoV-2 is still debated, so it is worth being precise:
- Bats are the likely natural reservoir. The closest known relatives of the virus have been found in horseshoe bats in Yunnan in China and in Laos. That does not mean someone caught the virus by eating a bat; there is no evidence for that route.
- An intermediate animal is suspected but unconfirmed. Genetic studies of swabs from Huanan market stalls found virus-positive samples mixed with raccoon dog genetic material, which many scientists see as pointing to infected animals at the market.
- The market's exact role is unresolved. About two-thirds of the first 41 hospitalised patients had a link to the market, but some early cases did not. In 2025 the WHO's advisory group on pathogen origins said the weight of available evidence favours a spillover from animals, while a laboratory-related incident could not be ruled out because key data from China had not been shared. Several US agencies and the White House have favoured the lab hypothesis.
In short, the link between live-animal markets and pandemic risk is well established in general terms, even though the exact path of Covid-19 into humans has not been proven.
Silencing and shifting blame
The anger in 2020 was also about how China handled the outbreak. Li Wenliang, an ophthalmologist at Wuhan Central Hospital, warned colleagues in a private chat group on 30 December 2019 about patients with a SARS-like illness. On 3 January 2020 police made him sign a statement admitting he had spread rumours. He caught the virus from a patient and died on 7 February 2020, aged 34. In March 2020 Wuhan police withdrew their reprimand and apologised to his family.
At the same time, Chinese officials and state media promoted alternative origin stories. In March 2020 foreign ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian suggested on Twitter that the US Army might have brought the virus to Wuhan, a claim for which there is no evidence. State media also suggested that the virus began in Italy, misrepresenting an interview with Italian doctor Giuseppe Remuzzi about unusual pneumonia cases in late 2019; Remuzzi said his words had been twisted.
What changed afterwards
China did take further steps after spring 2020. Pangolins were given the country's highest level of protection in June 2020, and their scales were dropped from the official list of approved traditional medicine ingredients that year. A revised Wildlife Protection Law, passed at the end of 2022 and in force from May 2023, wrote the consumption ban into permanent law and tightened rules on markets and online sales.
Conservation groups still point to weak spots: the medicine exemption, wildlife farming for fur, and illegal trade that moves online or across borders. The risk is also not unique to China. Live-animal trade, bushmeat and wildlife farming exist in many countries, and public-health experts argue that preventing the next spillover depends on regulating that trade everywhere.
What readers can do
For readers who want to help, the most useful steps are simple. Avoid buying wildlife products, including exotic pets and traditional remedies made from wild animals. Support conservation organisations that work on wildlife trade, and check that tourist attractions involving animals are reputable. Campaigners also ran petitions in 2020, such as one on change.org calling for an end to China's animal markets.
Further background on this site: our earlier reports on China's temporary wildlife-trade ban and on the animals sold at the Wuhan market.
Sources: Daily Mail, March 2020: Chinese markets selling bats (original report and video); Oxford Martin School: China's announcement on wildlife trade – what's new and what does it mean?; Wikipedia: Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market; Wikipedia: Origin of SARS-CoV-2; Wikipedia: Li Wenliang; Wikipedia: COVID-19 misinformation by China.

COMMENTS