Originally published 2020-04-19.

In September 2013 a newborn elephant calf named Zhuang Zhuang cried for about five hours after his mother attacked him at the Shendiaoshan Wild Animal Nature Reserve in Rongcheng, in China's Shandong province. Shortly after the birth she stepped on him. Keepers took him away, treated his injuries and brought him back, thinking it might have been an accident. When she stepped on him a second time, they separated the pair for good. The calf was inconsolable for hours before the staff managed to calm him, and the keepers then raised him themselves. He was reported to be doing well.
The pictures of a tearful baby elephant spread around the world, often with headlines saying he was grieving his mother's death. She did not die; she rejected him. The real story raises two good questions: why would an elephant mother reject her calf, and what do scientists actually know about emotion in elephants?
What happened at the wildlife park
Zhuang Zhuang was born in captivity, and the reports came from park staff via news agencies. According to the Christian Science Monitor's summary, the mother's rejection was immediate and repeated, which is why the keepers decided the calf could not safely stay with her. After the second attack he was moved out of her enclosure and comforted by staff.

The widely shared photograph shows the young calf with wet streaks running from his eyes. Staff said his crying went on for around five hours before he settled. From then on the keepers effectively adopted him and took over his care.
Some articles at the time said veterinarians blamed a kind of postpartum depression in the mother. That explanation was never backed by a published diagnosis, so it is best treated as speculation.
Why do some mothers reject their young?
Most elephant mothers are intensely protective, and calves are usually surrounded by attentive aunts, sisters and older siblings. Rejection is not the norm, but it does happen, in zoos and in the wild, and across many species. The Monitor listed cases involving a spider monkey, a meerkat, an aardvark, a wallaby, a seal and a lemur.
Biologists once saw maternal rejection and infanticide as purely pathological, a breakdown caused by extreme stress. More recent evidence suggests that "bad" mothering is fairly common in nature and can sometimes be part of a reproductive strategy, for example when food or water is uncertain and a mother cannot raise every offspring.
In captivity, other factors can play a role. Commonly cited ones include first-time mothers with little experience, a lack of older female relatives to model care, stress from the setting, and a painful or difficult birth. In Zhuang Zhuang's case, no specific cause was ever confirmed.
Do elephants cry from emotion?
This is where it pays to be careful. Elephants' eyes often look wet, and moisture running down the face can have physical causes, from irritation to the way their eyes are lubricated. Ethologist Marc Bekoff explored the question in a 2007 article titled "Do Elephants Cry?", and researchers still debate whether elephant tears are linked to feelings in the way human tears can be.
What is not in doubt is that the calf was distressed. Separation from the mother is one of the most stressful events a young mammal can face, and calling out, restlessness and refusing comfort are the behaviours we would expect. Whether his tears expressed sadness as ours do is harder to prove, but his reaction did not need tears to be real.
What research says about elephant emotions
Elephants are among the most studied animals when it comes to social bonds. Decades of field work, especially by Cynthia Moss and Joyce Poole with the Amboseli Elephant Research Project in Kenya, describe animals that live in close family groups led by an older matriarch and that respond strongly to injury and death.
Responses to death
Moss recorded family members trying to lift a dying female named Tina, then staying with her body and covering it with earth and branches. She also described a mother who walked slowly at the back of her family for days after her calf died. Elephants investigate the bones of other elephants, even unrelated ones, touching them gently with their trunks and feet.
Help and comfort
Field researchers report elephants assisting injured or stuck companions, and there are accounts of elephants staying beside injured people. Experiments have shown that elephants can cooperate: in a 2011 study by Joshua Plotnik and colleagues, pairs of Asian elephants learned to pull a rope together and waited for a partner when one was needed.
Elephants are not alone in reacting to death. Chimpanzees, some whales and dolphins, and other social species have been seen staying with or carrying dead young. So the claim, common in viral posts, that elephants are the only animals besides humans who mourn is not accurate. They are, however, among the clearest examples.
Emotion in animals: where science stands
For a long time scientists avoided words like grief or joy for animals, worried about projecting human feelings onto them. That has shifted. In 2012 a group of neuroscientists signed the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness, stating that many non-human animals, including all mammals and birds, have the brain structures that support conscious experience.
Researchers still distinguish between what an animal does, which can be observed, and what it feels, which has to be inferred. Elephants are a strong case because their behaviour around loss is consistent, long-lasting and seen across many families and decades of study. Elephants also have a large hippocampus, a brain region tied to memory and emotion, which some researchers link to their long memories and to signs of trauma in orphaned elephants.
What the story asks of us
If elephants feel distress, fear and attachment, then how we treat them matters. A few practical ways to act on that:
- Choose ethical wildlife experiences. Avoid venues that offer elephant rides or performances, and look for sanctuaries that let elephants behave naturally.
- Support conservation groups that protect wild elephants and their habitat and care for orphans.
- Check viral animal stories before sharing. Zhuang Zhuang's real story is moving enough without the invented detail of a dead mother.
The calf at Rongcheng survived because people stepped in and stayed with him until he calmed down. That is perhaps the most fitting lesson from a story about social animals: comfort works, for elephants and for us.
Sources: Christian Science Monitor: Baby elephant cries for 5 hours. Is Mom rejection unusual? (September 2013); Wikipedia: Elephant cognition. Photos: as published by the Daily Mail (September 2013). More animal stories: a grieving dog's daily walk and the rare Ili pika.

COMMENTS