Louis Vuitton Crocodile Skins: PETA's Farm Footage and LVMH's Reply

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Terrifying Video Depicts Crocodiles Skinned For Louis Vuitton Bags

The footage at the centre of this story comes from PETA Asia's investigation of crocodile farms in Vietnam, two of which said they supplied skins to a tannery owned by LVMH, the parent group of Louis Vuitton. It shows crocodiles held in cramped concrete pens and pits, and workers cutting into the necks of animals that were still moving before skinning them. LVMH has said it stopped buying from the farms PETA named and in 2019 launched its own standard for "responsible" crocodile leather. Animal rights groups say that is not enough and want exotic skins dropped altogether.

Below is what the investigation showed, how LVMH responded, what has changed in the luxury industry since, and what shoppers can do if they want to avoid these products. A warning: the images and video further down are distressing.

What the investigation recorded

PETA first released the Vietnam footage in December 2016 and has recirculated it in campaigns several times since, including in 2020. According to PETA UK's press release, investigators visited three farms. Two of them said they sold skins to a tannery owned by LVMH.

The group described three main problems:

  • Confinement. At one farm, crocodiles lay almost motionless in thousands of small concrete cells, some of them shorter than the animals' own bodies. PETA Asia says about 5,000 crocodiles were kept this way for around 15 months before slaughter.
  • Crowding. At another farm, dozens of animals were packed together in bare concrete pits with no natural features.
  • Slaughter. At a third site, workers stunned crocodiles with electric shocks, cut open their necks and pushed metal rods down their spines. PETA says one animal was still moving after it had been skinned.

A reptile specialist consulted by PETA called the neck incisions "very painful and inhumane", and described the pits as overly restrictive and under-stimulating.

Terrifying Video Depicts Crocodiles Skinned For Louis Vuitton Bags

Terrifying Video Depicts Crocodiles Skinned For Louis Vuitton Bags

These stills from the footage show crocodiles being restrained, cut and skinned on bare floors, and the stripped carcasses afterwards. PETA Asia says skinning a single animal took 15 to 20 minutes.

Why crocodile skin is so valuable

Crocodile leather is one of the most prized materials in luxury fashion. The scales on the belly form a regular, glossy pattern that cannot be imitated exactly by cows' leather, and only a small part of each hide is suitable for the most expensive bags. That rarity is why a crocodile handbag from a top house can cost tens of thousands of pounds.

Most crocodile skins in the trade come from farms rather than the wild. Saltwater and Nile crocodiles are bred in countries including Australia, Zimbabwe, Zambia, Kenya, the Philippines, the United States and Vietnam. Farmed animals are typically killed young, while their skins are still the right size for handbags and small leather goods.

Supporters of the industry argue that regulated farming takes pressure off wild populations and gives local communities a reason to protect wetlands. Critics reply that no farm can meet the needs of a large, semi-aquatic predator, and that reptiles are particularly hard to kill humanely.

How LVMH responded

When the footage was first published, LVMH said that it and its suppliers had ceased all trading with the farms named by PETA in 2014, and that its crocodile skins came from other Asian suppliers.

PETA US then bought a share in LVMH so that its representatives could raise the issue at shareholder meetings. Some reports at the time described this as a large stake; in fact it was a token shareholding, a tactic PETA has used with many companies to gain a voice in the boardroom.

In February 2019 LVMH announced what it called the first standard for responsible crocodile leather sourcing. It said the standard was developed with technical experts, including the independent organisation NSF International, and rested on four pillars: preserving the species and respecting local communities, animal welfare, working conditions on farms, and environmental protection. Three farms supplying its Singapore tannery, Heng Long, were certified first. The company said its roughly 20 supplier farms in Australia, Zambia, Zimbabwe, Kenya, the Philippines and the US would be certified by the end of 2020, and that it already had full traceability of its skins.

Why campaigners are not satisfied

PETA dismissed the new standard almost immediately. Its argument is that welfare rules cannot change the basic facts: crocodiles are wild animals confined for their entire lives and then killed for a product nobody needs. LVMH has also said little in public about exactly how slaughter methods were changed, which leaves critics doubtful that practices on the ground are very different.

Later PETA Asia investigations, including footage from Indonesian slaughterhouses it says supplied LVMH, have kept the issue alive. The group continues to urge Louis Vuitton and the wider LVMH group to stop selling exotic skins.

Campaigners also point to rival brands that have already made that decision. Chanel announced in late 2018 that it would stop using exotic skins such as crocodile, lizard and snake, and designers including Vivienne Westwood, Victoria Beckham and Diane von Furstenberg made similar pledges.

The video above contains graphic scenes of crocodiles being killed and skinned. Viewer discretion is strongly advised.

What you can do as a shopper

Whatever your view of animal products in general, there are simple ways to make sure your money does not support practices you object to:

  • Check the label. "Crocodile", "alligator", "caiman", "exotic leather" and "porosus" (the saltwater crocodile's scientific name) all signal reptile skin. Watch straps and small accessories are common hiding places.
  • Ask the brand. Luxury houses increasingly publish animal welfare policies. If a company cannot say where a skin came from or how the animal was killed, that is useful information.
  • Look at alternatives. Embossed leather, plant-based leathers and high-quality synthetics now offer the crocodile look without exotic skins.
  • Buy second-hand. Vintage and resale markets let people enjoy luxury pieces without creating new demand.

The debate over exotic skins is far from settled, but the direction of travel is clear. Every major brand that drops crocodile leather makes it a little harder for the rest to argue that luxury requires it.

Sources: Footage and stills by PETA Asia; PETA UK: press release on the Vietnam crocodile farms (2016); PETA UK: LVMH wildlife skins campaign; Ecotextile News: Louis Vuitton responds to PETA exposé; The Business of Fashion: LVMH cuts ties to crocodile farms; FashionNetwork (AFP): LVMH vows new standards for crocodile farms; Retail Gazette: LVMH to ensure a responsible supply of crocodile skins.

COMMENTS