Originally published 2020-03-07.

In November 2019, a video from Wuxi People's Hospital in eastern China showed surgeons handling a pair of lungs that were mottled, grey and black instead of healthy pink. The organs came from a 52-year-old man who had reportedly smoked heavily for about 30 years and had been declared brain-dead. Lung transplant surgeon Dr Chen Jingyu and his team rejected them for transplant because of the damage they found once the lungs were removed. The footage spread widely on Chinese social media, where some users called it the best anti-smoking advert they had seen.
Here is what the video showed, why the lungs could not be used, and what the evidence says about smoking and lung health.
What happened at Wuxi People's Hospital
Dr Chen leads one of China's busiest lung transplant programmes. The donor's family had agreed to donate his organs after brain death was declared, and because the donation moved quickly, no CT scan had been done beforehand.
Early checks looked acceptable. According to Dr Chen, the oxygenation index tests, which measure how well the lungs move oxygen into the blood, were fine. Only when the team harvested the organs and saw them directly did they decide the lungs were unusable. Media reports at the time said the surgeons found signs of emphysema, large air-filled blisters known as bullae, and calcified areas.
Dr Chen also explained that a smoker's lungs are not automatically refused. In his programme, donors generally need to be under 60 and recently deceased, and lungs with only minor infection and fairly clear chest X-rays can still be accepted. These lungs simply failed that standard once they were seen in person.
Why the lungs looked like that
Healthy lungs are soft, spongy and pinkish. Several things can change that appearance.
Tar and particles
Cigarette smoke carries fine particles and tar that settle in the airways and air sacs. Immune cells called macrophages swallow the particles but cannot break them down, so dark pigment builds up in the tissue over the years.
Emphysema
Smoking is the most common cause of emphysema, a condition in which the thin walls between the lungs' tiny air sacs break down. The air spaces become permanently enlarged, leaving less surface for gas exchange. In advanced cases large bullae form, which can rupture and collapse a lung. The damage does not reverse; treatment aims to control symptoms and slow progression. Emphysema is one of the main forms of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
Scarring and calcification
Repeated inflammation and infection can leave scar tissue and calcium deposits, making parts of the lung stiff and less able to expand.
A common myth: black lungs mean smoking
Videos like this one are powerful, but colour alone is not a reliable test of whether someone smoked. Some dark pigment, a condition known as anthracosis, is found to some degree in most people who live in cities, because everyone inhales soot and air pollution. Coal miners can develop heavily blackened lungs without ever touching a cigarette.
What makes a smoker's lungs dangerous is not mainly their colour but the structural damage underneath: destroyed air sacs, narrowed airways, scarring and the risk of cancer. That is why transplant teams look at function and tissue quality, not just appearance. Equally, a lung that looks relatively clean is no proof that smoking has done no harm.
What the evidence says about smoking
The health effects of tobacco are among the best-documented findings in medicine:
- Worldwide toll. The World Health Organization says tobacco kills more than 7 million people a year, including over 1.6 million non-smokers exposed to second-hand smoke. About 1.2 billion people use tobacco, around 80% of them in low- and middle-income countries.
- Lung cancer. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) links cigarette smoking to about 80% of lung cancer deaths in the United States. People who smoke are 15 to 30 times more likely to get or die from lung cancer than people who do not.
- Life expectancy. According to the CDC, people who smoke live at least ten years less, on average, than non-smokers.
- Broad damage. Smoking and second-hand smoke cause more than 480,000 deaths a year in the US alone, through cancers, heart disease, stroke and lung diseases such as COPD.
Some older reports quote higher figures, such as smoking causing 90% of lung cancer deaths. The CDC's current estimate is about 80%; the rest are linked to radon, workplace exposures, air pollution, second-hand smoke and other factors.
Why the story resonated in China
China has more smokers than any other country. A national survey by the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention found that 26.6% of people aged 15 and over smoked in 2018, a slight fall from earlier years, with rates far higher among men than women. Cigarettes are also deeply embedded in social life, offered as gifts and at business meals.
That is why the Wuxi footage hit hard. It turned abstract warnings into something people could see, and it also touched on organ donation: a man had generously given his organs, but decades of smoking meant his lungs could not save another life.
If you want to quit
The good news is that stopping helps at any age. The CDC notes that quitting before about age 40 reduces the risk of dying from a smoking-related disease by around 90%, and that benefits begin within weeks for circulation and breathing. Damage such as emphysema cannot be undone, but quitting slows further decline.
Willpower alone works for some people, but most succeed with help. Talk to a doctor or pharmacist about the options available where you live, and consider your country's free quitline or stop-smoking service.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Sources: FOX 13, Transplant doctor rejects damaged donated lungs from chain-smoker (19 November 2019); Daily Mail, original report (November 2019); WHO, Tobacco fact sheet; CDC, Lung cancer risk factors; CDC, Smoking and tobacco use; CDC, Tobacco-related mortality; China Daily, 2018 China adult smoking survey; Emphysema (Wikipedia); Anthracosis (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS