Why an Owl Hatched a Wood Duck Duckling in Florida

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
An Owl and a Duckling Share a Nest-Box Photograph

Did an owl really raise a duckling? The short answer: an Eastern screech owl in Jupiter, Florida, almost certainly incubated and hatched a wood duck egg that had been laid in her nest box, and for a few hours in early April 2019 the two birds sat side by side at the entrance. The duckling then jumped out and walked off toward a pond. Nobody saw the owl "raise" it in any longer sense, and the most likely explanation is a well-known duck habit rather than a change of heart by a predator.

The photograph that made the story famous was taken by Laurie Wolf, a wildlife artist and amateur photographer who keeps nest boxes in her backyard. Here is what happened, why it happened, and what the picture can and cannot tell us.

What Laurie Wolf saw in her backyard

About a month before the photo, a female Eastern screech owl had moved into one of the wooden boxes on Wolf's property. Screech owls are regular tenants in such boxes, so this was nothing unusual. Wolf assumed the bird was incubating owl eggs and waited for the first owlet.

Then, as a storm was approaching, she and her husband looked up and saw the owl's head in the entrance hole. Next to it was a small, fluffy chick with a yellow face and a dark cap. It was not an owlet. It was a wood duck duckling.

Wolf told National Geographic that the pair were simply sitting together, side by side. She photographed them and shared the images, which quickly spread around the world under headlines claiming the owl had "adopted" the duck.

The happy ending, and why it was brief

Wolf's first reaction was delight, but worry followed. Screech owls are predators, and they do eat small birds. She contacted a raptor expert, who confirmed that the duckling could be at risk, and a local wildlife sanctuary agreed to look after it if she could catch it.

She never needed to. Before anyone could step in, the duckling dropped out of the box and made its way toward a nearby pond. Wolf did not see it again. BirdWatching magazine later reported that, a few weeks afterwards, the same box produced two genuine owlets, first spotted on 27 April 2019.

That short stay is exactly what biology predicts. Wood duck chicks are precocial: they hatch with open eyes and a coat of down, and they can walk, swim and feed themselves almost at once. In the wild they leave the nest cavity the day after hatching, leaping to the ground or water below, sometimes from heights of 50 feet without injury. A duckling that hatched in an owl box would have had every instinct telling it to jump.

How a duck egg ended up in an owl's nest

Wood ducks are cavity nesters. Unlike most ducks, they lay their eggs inside hollow trees near water, and they readily use artificial nest boxes. That puts them in direct competition with screech owls, which want the same kind of hole.

Wood duck females also practise what biologists call brood parasitism, or "egg dumping": they sometimes lay eggs in nests that belong to other birds, usually another wood duck or a close relative. A normal clutch is about 7 to 15 eggs, but boxes placed too close together can end up with 30 or more, many of which never hatch.

Christian Artuso, then the Manitoba director of Bird Studies Canada, explained the logic to National Geographic. Spreading eggs across several nests lowers the risk of losing everything if a predator finds one of them. He compared it to the familiar advice about baskets:

"You could think of it as not keeping all your eggs in one basket."

In Wolf's case, a wood duck most likely slipped into the box and laid at least one egg among the owl's. The owl kept incubating, and the egg that hatched first happened to be the duck's.

Why would an owl sit on a duck egg?

Birds do not count their eggs or inspect them closely. For most species the rule is simple: if there is an egg in your nest, keep it warm. Artuso suggested a second factor, known as a supernormal stimulus. Wood duck eggs are longer and roughly twice the volume of a screech owl's eggs, and many birds respond even more strongly to an oversized egg than to a normal one.

He also noted that owls may simply never have evolved a defence against a situation this rare. Brood parasites such as cuckoos target particular hosts again and again, and those hosts gradually learn to reject strange eggs. Wood ducks dump eggs in owl boxes only occasionally, so there has been little pressure on owls to notice.

This was not a one-off curiosity, either. In 2005, during his doctoral research on Eastern screech owls in Manitoba, Artuso documented a female owl that incubated and hatched three wood duck chicks. He published the observation in the Wilson Journal of Ornithology in 2007. His summary to National Geographic was that the behaviour is not commonly documented but certainly happens. Other mixed families are on record too, including an American kestrel incubating bufflehead eggs and an osprey fostering Canada goose goslings.

Common myths about the "owl mom" photo

"The owl chose to adopt the duckling"

There is no evidence of a choice. The owl incubated whatever was in her nest, as birds do. Artuso himself stressed that nobody can know what a wild owl is thinking. The picture shows two birds sharing an entrance hole, and nothing more about their relationship.

"The owl raised the duck for weeks"

Not in this case. The duckling left within hours of being seen. Wood duck chicks do not need to be fed by a parent; their mother's main job is to lead them to water and watch for danger.

"The duckling was always safe"

Probably not. Eastern screech owls eat insects, crayfish and small mammals, but also many small birds; more than 100 bird species have been recorded as their prey. Experts told Wolf the chick could be in danger, which is why a sanctuary was on standby. Its quick departure may well have been its best protection.

Meet the two species

The Eastern screech owl is a small, stocky owl, about 16 to 25 cm long, found across eastern North America from Canada to Mexico. It comes in grey and rufous (reddish) colour forms, and lives comfortably in suburbs as well as woodland. It does not build a nest; the female lays her eggs on the bare floor of a cavity or box, and in Florida clutches average about three eggs. Incubation takes around 26 days.

The wood duck is one of North America's most colourful waterfowl. It came close to disappearing in the late 1800s because of hunting and habitat loss. Legal protection from the Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918, and nest-box programmes from the 1930s onward, helped the population recover. Those same boxes are why encounters like this one happen: they attract ducks and owls alike.

If you keep nest boxes in your own garden

For anyone hoping to attract either species, a few practical lessons come out of this story:

  • Space boxes well apart and out of sight of each other. Crowded boxes encourage egg dumping, which leads to large clutches that often fail.
  • Expect neighbours. A box sized for wood ducks will also appeal to screech owls, and vice versa.
  • Do not handle or remove chicks yourself. If you are worried about a young bird, call a licensed wildlife rehabilitator or sanctuary for advice, as Wolf did.
  • Watch from a distance. Disturbing a nest during incubation can cause the adult to abandon it.

Laurie Wolf's photograph remains one of the most charming wildlife images of recent years. Its real value is that it shows a piece of animal behaviour that scientists knew existed but rarely see, captured in a single frame from an ordinary backyard.

Sources: National Geographic (Jason Bittel, 16 April 2019): Why this owl raised a duckling as its own; BirdWatching (Matt Mendenhall, 30 April 2019): The screech-owl that hatched a duckling now has owlets; Wikipedia: Wood duck; Wikipedia: Eastern screech owl

Related articles

COMMENTS