Live Animal Keychains in China: Why Sealed Fish and Turtles Die

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published January 26, 2020.

Live Animals Sold as Keychains: The Welfare Questions Behind the Images

A typical live-animal keychain: a small fish or turtle sealed in a palm-sized bag of coloured water, sold as a cheap trinket.

Live animal keychains are small sealed plastic pouches containing a living fish, turtle or other small aquatic animal in a little coloured water, sold as a souvenir or phone charm. They were reported for sale by street vendors in several Chinese cities during the 2010s, often near subway and train stations or in tourist markets, for the price of a snack. Vendors claimed the water held enough oxygen and nutrients to keep the animal alive for months. Biologists and welfare groups say the opposite: the animals slowly poison themselves, overheat or suffocate, and most die within days or weeks.

Here is what was sold, why the animals cannot survive in a sealed bag, what the law says, and what to do if you come across one.

What was sold, where and for how much

Reports from the mid-2010s describe vendors in Beijing selling fish, turtles and amphibians as key rings and mobile phone decorations. In 2017 a Malaysian reporter for The Star found a roadside vendor at the Zeng Cuo'an tourist market in Xiamen selling the pouches for 15 to 20 yuan, then around US$2 to US$3. Other accounts mention vendors near metro stations in Shanghai and elsewhere, with prices sometimes quoted at about US$1.50.

The animals were usually tiny: juvenile goldfish or other small fish, and hatchling turtles small enough to fit in a closed fist. Small sliders are the most commonly traded turtles in the world, and very young ones are easy to source in bulk, which helps explain why turtles featured so often.

The craze was strongest among teenagers and tourists, who saw the pouches as cute and inexpensive gifts. Videos of the keychains spread widely online and drew anger from viewers around the world, as well as from many people inside China.

Video footage of live-animal keychains on sale helped the story spread internationally and fuelled petitions calling for a ban.

The sellers' claim and the biology

Vendors told buyers that the water was specially treated with oxygen and nutrients, and some accounts said a food pellet inside would last up to three months. Even if the bag starts with a little dissolved oxygen, the real problem is waste.

Fish and aquatic turtles constantly excrete ammonia through their gills, skin and waste. In an aquarium, filters, water changes and beneficial bacteria convert that ammonia into less harmful compounds. In a sealed pouch holding a few tablespoons of water, nothing removes it. Ammonia levels climb, burning gills and skin and damaging internal organs. Carbon dioxide builds up at the same time, and with no surface for gas exchange, oxygen runs out.

Malaysian media quoted a marine scientist, Dr Sam Walton of Universiti Malaysia Terengganu, making exactly this point: the animals may have air at first, but they end up poisoning themselves with their own waste.

Live Animals Sold as Keychains: The Welfare Questions Behind the Images

Keychains like these were often clipped to bags or phones, exposing the animals to sunlight, body heat and constant shaking.

Heat, light and constant motion

A tiny volume of water changes temperature quickly. A keychain left in sunlight, in a hot car or in a trouser pocket can warm up within minutes, and warmer water holds less oxygen while speeding up the animal's metabolism, so it needs more oxygen just as less is available. Cold has the opposite but equally harmful effect.

Then there is movement. A keychain swings with every step and every bag being dropped on a desk. For a small fish or turtle, that means being thrown against the plastic hundreds of times a day, with no way to rest, hide or escape the light.

Turtles face an extra problem: aquatic turtles need to surface to breathe air and need somewhere to dry off and bask under warmth. A sealed bag provides neither. Fish and turtles are also not amphibians, despite occasional claims, and their care needs are completely different from frogs or newts.

What happens to animals that survive

Some buyers do cut the bags open and move the animal into a bowl or tank. That is far better than leaving it sealed, but it is only the start. A healthy red-eared slider, for example, can live 20 to 30 years and grow to around 15 to 20 centimetres, needing a large tank, a basking lamp, UV lighting and regular cleaning. A goldfish needs filtered water and much more space than most people expect.

Releasing a rescued keychain turtle into a park pond is not kind either. The red-eared slider is on the list of the world's 100 most invasive species and has established wild populations on six continents, where it competes with native turtles. Reptiles can also carry Salmonella bacteria without showing symptoms, so handwashing after handling matters, especially for children.

Live Animals Sold as Keychains: The Welfare Questions Behind the Images

Welfare groups argued that sealing a living animal in plastic treats it as a disposable accessory, whatever the price.

Petitions, laws and enforcement

Online petitions, including a widely shared Change.org campaign, called for the sale of live-animal keychains to be banned. Selling the pouches drew condemnation from activists, who warned that the animals could run out of air and die quickly and that the trinkets might pose health risks.

Legally, the picture is patchy. China has no national law that broadly prohibits cruelty to animals. A comprehensive draft animal protection law was produced in 2009, but it stalled and has not been enacted, so it is wrong to say China signed such a law. Protection comes instead from wildlife laws, disease-control rules and local regulations. That leaves trades like this in a grey zone where action depends on local officials, market managers and public pressure.

Attitudes are shifting. Pet ownership has grown rapidly in Chinese cities, rescue groups have become more visible, and in 2020 the city of Shenzhen banned the sale and eating of cat and dog meat, citing public health and changing ethical values. Recent reports of keychain sales are far rarer than in the mid-2010s, though it is hard to say how widespread the trade remains today.

Live Animals Sold as Keychains: The Welfare Questions Behind the Images

Images of keychains clustered on vendors' stands were shared widely online and became symbols of the campaign against the trade.

What you can do if you see them

  • Don't buy one, even to rescue it. Each sale keeps the supply going and tells the vendor there is demand.
  • Report it. Tell market managers, the online platform if sold online, or local animal welfare groups.
  • If you already have one, open it carefully. Move the animal into clean, dechlorinated water at the same temperature, then get advice from a vet or experienced keeper.
  • Never release it into the wild. Find a reptile or fish rescue that can rehome it.
  • Share accurate information. Explaining why the animals die is more persuasive than outrage alone.

A living animal is not a trinket. The keychain trade showed how easily novelty can override basic welfare, and also how quickly public awareness can turn a fashion into something people are ashamed to buy.

Sources: The Star: Live animal keychains (2017); Wikipedia: Animal welfare and rights in China; Wikipedia: Red-eared slider.

COMMENTS