Fresno Police Shooting of Isiah Murrietta-Golding: Video and Aftermath

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-11-04.

A Video Alleging Police Shooting of a Fleeing Child

In October 2019, ABC30 in Fresno (station KFSN) aired footage that had not been seen publicly before: body-camera and daycare surveillance video of the moment a Fresno police sergeant shot 16-year-old Isiah Murrietta-Golding in the back of the head as he ran across a fenced yard. He was unarmed. The shooting had happened two and a half years earlier, on 15 April 2017, and every official review had already cleared the officer. The video changed the public conversation, and in April 2021 the City of Fresno agreed to pay the teenager's parents $4.9 million.

His first name appears in many reports as "Isaiah", but the court filings and most local coverage spell it Isiah. Below is what the footage shows, what police said, what the law allows when someone runs from officers, and how the case ended.

What the footage shows

The released material comes from two cameras. The first is a body camera worn by one of the officers. Officers had stopped a car at a shopping centre near Shaw and Fresno avenues, and the clip opens with commands to the teenager to walk backwards towards them. An officer can be heard saying, "Backwards. Towards my voice. Down on your knees."

Instead of kneeling, Isiah ran. The body camera follows the chase briefly and loses him when he climbs a fence into the grounds of a daycare centre, the Discovery Center.

The second camera belonged to the daycare. Its surveillance footage picks him up as he lands inside the yard and keeps running. According to ABC30's account, he had taken roughly eight steps when Sergeant Ray Villalvazo, who had reached the fence, crouched and fired a single shot. Isiah fell and did not get up again. He died of the wound.

The body-camera audio also captured a colleague telling Villalvazo "good shot" moments after the shooting, a remark that drew particular anger once the video aired.

Content warning: the clip below shows a fatal shooting.

Why police were looking for him

Fresno police said they wanted to question Isiah and his older brother about a deadly shooting the day before. The brother, who was 17 and not in the car, was arrested and later pleaded guilty to manslaughter in that case. Police also said the younger brother was known to carry a gun.

None of that was tested against Isiah himself. He was never charged, and his family's lawyer, Stuart Chandler, said officers did not hold an arrest warrant for either brother that day. CBS News reported that the family's lawyer argued the older brother's plea should have no bearing on whether the use of deadly force against the younger one was lawful.

The key point for understanding the case is simple: Isiah had no weapon when he was shot. No gun was found on him or in the yard.

How the shooting was reviewed and cleared

Villalvazo said that as the teenager ran, he reached towards his waistband several times and looked back at him, and that he feared for his life. The family's side said Isiah was holding up his trousers while running.

Three separate reviews accepted the officer's account. The Fresno Police Department's Internal Affairs Bureau, the Fresno County District Attorney's Office and the city all found the shooting justified, according to Valley Public Radio (KVPR). The city's Office of Independent Review also concluded that it was within policy, while recommending ten changes to department policies. No criminal charge was filed against Villalvazo.

In 2019, Police Chief Andy Hall defended the outcome, pointing to the homicide investigation and the gun-carrying reports. Legal analyst Tony Capozzi, watching the footage for ABC30, saw it differently and described an officer who simply walked up, crouched and fired.

What US law says about shooting someone who runs

People searching for this video often ask a fair question: can police legally shoot a person who is running away? The answer depends on what the officer reasonably believed at that moment.

  • Tennessee v. Garner (1985). The US Supreme Court ruled that police may use deadly force to stop a fleeing suspect only if they have probable cause to believe the person poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury to officers or others. Shooting an unarmed person who poses no such threat, simply to stop an escape, is an unreasonable seizure under the Fourth Amendment.
  • Graham v. Connor (1989). Courts judge any use of force by asking what a reasonable officer would have done with the information available at the time, without the benefit of hindsight. This standard gives officers considerable room when they say they saw a threatening movement.

That tension is exactly what the Murrietta-Golding case turned on. Reviews that accepted the "reaching for the waistband" account found the shot reasonable. The family argued that a teenager running away, with his back turned, inside a fenced daycare yard, was no immediate danger to anyone.

The lawsuit and the $4.9 million settlement

Isiah's father, Anthony Golding, filed a federal civil-rights lawsuit against the City of Fresno, former Police Chief Jerry Dyer and Villalvazo. His mother also brought a wrongful-death claim. The suit said the teenager never threatened any officer and made no threatening gesture during the chase.

The bodycam and surveillance clips became public through this litigation, which is why a 2017 shooting made headlines in late 2019. A trial was set for 2020, but the case was settled first. In April 2021 the city agreed to pay $4.9 million. Michael Haddad, a lawyer for the family, described it as the biggest settlement the city had ever paid and said the shooting was "totally unnecessary and sickening to anyone who saw the video."

A settlement is not an admission of wrongdoing, and it did not lead to criminal charges. It does show that the city judged the risk of letting a jury see the footage to be serious.

Comparison with the Walter Scott case

Many viewers compared the footage with the 2015 killing of Walter Scott in North Charleston, South Carolina. Officer Michael Slager stopped Scott, a 50-year-old Black man, over a broken brake light. Scott ran, and after a struggle involving a Taser, Slager fired eight shots at him from behind. A bystander's phone video contradicted the officer's first report.

Slager's state murder trial ended in a mistrial in December 2016. In May 2017 he pleaded guilty to a federal civil-rights charge, and in December 2017 a federal judge sentenced him to 20 years in prison.

The two cases share the same basic shape: an unarmed man running away, shot from behind, with the moment caught on camera. The outcomes differed sharply. In Scott's case the video led to a criminal conviction; in Fresno, the officer was cleared by every review, and the only accountability came through a civil payout.

What the case shows

Several lessons stand out from the record:

  • Video matters, but timing matters too. The footage existed in 2017, yet the public saw it only after a lawsuit forced it out. Earlier release policies might have changed how the case was debated.
  • "Reaching for the waistband" carries heavy weight. Courts and review boards often accept it as grounds for fear, even when no weapon is found. Clear camera angles are one of the few ways to test that claim.
  • Civil and criminal outcomes are separate. A large settlement can coexist with no charges, because the standards of proof and the decision-makers are different.
  • Independent review recommendations deserve follow-up. The ten policy changes suggested by Fresno's review office are where lasting change would come from, and residents can ask the city what became of them.

Whatever one concludes about the officer's state of mind, a 16-year-old who was not carrying a weapon died in a children's play yard. That is the fact that kept this case in the news long after the official reviews closed it.

Sources: ABC30/ABC7 News: new video shows deadly shot from Fresno police officer (2019); KVPR Valley Public Radio, 23 October 2019; CBS News: parents file wrongful-death lawsuit; ABC7, April 2021: $4.9 million settlement; Wikipedia: Tennessee v. Garner; Wikipedia: Killing of Walter Scott. Video: ABC30/KFSN.

COMMENTS