Coca-Cola Tops 2019 Plastic Brand Audit: What the Ranking Means

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Coca-Cola Led the 2019 Plastic Brand Audit: What the Survey Measured

Yes: in the 2019 global brand audit run by the Break Free From Plastic movement, Coca-Cola was the brand found most often on plastic litter, for the second year running. Volunteers logged 11,732 Coca-Cola items in 37 countries, more than the next three companies combined. Nestlé and PepsiCo followed. What the ranking does not tell you is how much plastic each company makes worldwide, and that difference matters if you want to use the result well.

What the 2019 brand audit found

The audit was built on cleanups. In September 2019, around the time of World Cleanup Day, roughly 72,500 volunteers took part in 484 cleanup and audit events across 51 countries. They gathered 476,423 pieces of plastic from beaches, rivers, parks and streets, then sorted every piece by type and, where a label was still legible, by brand.

About 43 percent of the pieces carried an identifiable brand. Those branded items were then traced back to their parent companies, which is how individual labels such as Sprite, Fanta or Dasani end up counted under Coca-Cola.

The top ten parent companies in the 2019 report were:

  1. Coca-Cola
  2. Nestlé
  3. PepsiCo
  4. Mondelez International (Oreo, Ritz, Cadbury and other snack brands)
  5. Unilever
  6. Mars
  7. Procter & Gamble
  8. Colgate-Palmolive
  9. Philip Morris International
  10. Perfetti Van Melle

Coca-Cola stood out on almost every measure. Its 11,732 pieces came from four continents, and it ranked first for Europe and Africa and second in Asia and South America. Those items were roughly 2.5 percent of everything collected, branded or not. The movement announced the results on 23 October 2019:

How the ranking works, and what it cannot show

A brand audit counts litter that volunteers happened to pick up, in places they chose to clean. That makes it a strong snapshot of which labels keep turning up in the environment, and a weak tool for measuring a company's total plastic footprint.

A few details are worth knowing before you quote the list:

  • The ranking is based on reach, not just volume. Companies were ordered mainly by how many countries their plastic was found in. Unilever, for example, had more pieces than Mondelez but appeared in fewer countries, so it sat one place lower.
  • The sample is uneven. The report itself notes that volunteers were self-selected and that countries with active member groups are over-represented.
  • Most litter is anonymous. Over half the pieces had no readable brand, so they could not be assigned to anyone. Shredded films, foam and fragments rarely carry a logo.
  • Visibility favours drinks. A bottle with a bright label survives as a recognisable object far longer than a crisp packet or a sachet.

None of this makes the result meaningless. A brand that appears in 37 countries, from a single coordinated weekend of cleanups, is plainly part of the waste people are living with. But the honest headline is "most frequently found brand in the audit," not "proven largest polluter on Earth."

How much plastic does Coca-Cola actually make?

For a production figure you need a different source. In March 2019, as part of the Ellen MacArthur Foundation's New Plastics Economy commitment, Coca-Cola disclosed that it used about 3 million tonnes of plastic packaging in 2017. Reporters at the time worked out that this is in the region of 200,000 bottles a minute. Nestlé reported about 1.7 million tonnes. PepsiCo was among the large firms that did not publish a figure at that point.

Put the two sources side by side and a consistent picture appears: a company that sells drinks in single-use bottles across almost every country will also show up in litter across almost every country. The audit puts a face on the production numbers.

How people reacted

The response on social media split in a familiar way. Many people asked why small plastic bottles are still sold when cans and glass sit on the same shelf:

Others argued that the responsibility lies with whoever drops the bottle, not with the company that sold it:

Both points have some truth in them. Littering is a personal choice. Yet in many of the countries surveyed, waste collection is patchy or absent, and the person holding an empty bottle has no bin, no deposit scheme and no recycler nearby. That is why campaigners focus on the companies: they decide the packaging, and they operate at a scale no single shopper can match.

@cocacola @Nestle @PepsiCo @MDLZ and @Unilever are the top 5 corporate plastic polluters of 2019. It's time for them to be held accountable. Read the full @brkfreeplastic #BrandAudit2019 report: https://t.co/CPnNraLQlK BreakFreeFromPlastic @future_spain

— Víctor Cuevas 🌱 (@vcuevas) November 5, 2019

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Recyclable promises and what happens in practice

In 2018 Coca-Cola launched its World Without Waste plan, pledging to help collect and recycle the equivalent of every bottle or can it sells by 2030. The company has also shown sample bottles made partly from recovered marine plastic.

Break Free From Plastic's report is sceptical of pledges that rest mainly on recyclability. Its reasoning is simple, and summed up in one line:

"Making a product recyclable does not mean it is actually recycled." (Break Free From Plastic, Brand Audit 2019 report)

There are physical limits too. Each time PET is mechanically recycled its polymer chains get shorter and the material weakens, so bottles can only go round a limited number of times before they need fresh plastic mixed in. A lot of recycled PET also leaves the bottle loop altogether, turned into fleece, carpet or strapping that is seldom recycled again.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

Plastic itself is not the villain in every setting. It keeps medicines sterile, food fresh and water safe to carry, and it is light, which saves fuel in transport. The trouble is the single-use model for low-value items. Cheap shale gas in the United States has also made new plastic inexpensive, as reporting on the petrochemical build-out has noted, which makes it hard for recycled material to compete on price.

What actually reduces branded litter

The audit's authors pushed for three things: companies disclosing how much single-use plastic they put on the market, setting measurable reduction targets, and investing in reuse and refill systems. Some practical points follow from that:

  • Deposit-return schemes work. Places with a refundable deposit on drinks containers typically see much higher return rates, and fewer bottles on beaches.
  • Refill beats recycle when it is convenient. Returnable glass and refillable PET were once normal for soft drinks and still are in parts of Latin America and Europe.
  • Your own choices still count. Carrying a bottle, choosing cans or glass where recycling is good, and joining a local cleanup all help, and cleanups also feed data into future audits.
  • Read rankings carefully. When you share a result like this, quote the year and the method. It makes the point stronger, not weaker.

Break Free From Plastic has repeated the audit every year since, and Coca-Cola has kept appearing at or near the top. The 2019 edition remains a useful reference point: a single label, found tens of thousands of times by ordinary volunteers, tells you a lot about how today's packaging system works.

Sources: Break Free From Plastic, Branded Vol. II: Brand Audit 2019 report (PDF); Break Free From Plastic, Brand Audit 2019 page; Plastic Soup Foundation summary; Packaging Insights on the Ellen MacArthur Foundation disclosures; cover photo and embedded posts as credited.

COMMENTS