US vs UK Ingredient Lists: Food Babe's Viral Comparison Checked

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-10-07.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Why do the same branded foods often have different ingredient lists in the United States and the United Kingdom? In 2019 a set of side-by-side pictures made by American blogger Vani Hari, known online as the Food Babe, went viral on Facebook after being shared by a user named Kacey Birch. The images compared US and UK versions of McDonald's fries, Quaker oatmeal, Mountain Dew, Heinz ketchup, Doritos and Kraft macaroni and cheese, and the US lists were almost always longer.

Some of the differences are real. American recipes have often used high fructose corn syrup where British ones use sugar, and certain synthetic dyes appear more often in US products because UK and EU labels for six colours must carry a hyperactivity warning. But several of the pairs compare different flavours, some lists are out of date, and a longer label is not automatically a less safe one. Below, each image gets a closer look, along with what the reactions said and what has changed since.

McDonald's fries and Quaker oatmeal

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

McDonald's fries: the US list includes a blend of oils, "natural beef flavor" made with wheat and milk derivatives, sodium acid pyrophosphate to keep the colour even and an anti-foaming agent in the frying oil. The UK fries use potatoes, sunflower and rapeseed oil, dextrose and salt. The beef flavouring is a genuine recipe difference and matters to vegetarians, but both the colour stabiliser and the anti-foaming agent (E450 and E900) are also approved in the UK and EU.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Quaker oats: the US box pictured is a Strawberries and Cream instant flavour, while the UK box is Oat So Simple Original, so the two are not the same product. The US version's long list comes mostly from its creamer, flavoured dried apple pieces and added vitamins and iron. A fairer test would compare plain oats with plain oats, which in both countries contain little more than rolled oats.

Mountain Dew and Heinz ketchup

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Mountain Dew: the US bottle listed high fructose corn syrup, brominated vegetable oil (BVO) and Yellow 5, while the UK drink used sugar, beta carotene for colour and no BVO. This was one of the clearest differences at the time. The US Food and Drug Administration revoked approval for BVO in food in July 2024, so it is no longer allowed in American drinks.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Heinz ketchup: the US recipe in the picture is sweetened with high fructose corn syrup and corn syrup, the UK version with sugar. Nutritionally, the two sweeteners are very similar, so the main difference is the ingredient source rather than safety. Heinz has also sold sugar-sweetened versions in the US for people who prefer them.

Doritos and macaroni and cheese

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Doritos: the US bag is Cool Ranch and the UK bag is Cool Original, related flavours but separate recipes. The US list includes Red 40, Blue 1 and Yellow 5, while the UK one uses annatto, a plant-based colour. Both contain monosodium glutamate and other flavour enhancers, so this pair is more about colourings than about one being "clean".

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Macaroni and cheese: the US box is Kraft Macaroni and Cheese, the UK box Kraft's Cheesey Pasta, which was coloured with paprika extract and beta carotene. The US list shown includes Yellow 5 and Yellow 6, but Kraft announced in April 2015 that it would remove artificial dyes and preservatives from its US Mac and Cheese, a change completed in 2016. This comparison is therefore out of date.

Is American food banned in other countries?

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

A protest sign reading "Wake up America, your food is banned in 30 countries" was included with the viral post. The number has no clear source. Particular additives have been restricted in particular places, but whole American foods are not banned in 30 countries, and many ingredients on US labels are also legal in Europe.

The truth is more specific. In the UK and EU, foods containing any of six synthetic colours, including allura red (Red 40), tartrazine (Yellow 5) and sunset yellow (Yellow 6), must carry the warning that they "may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children". Rather than print that, many manufacturers switched to natural colours for European markets. The NHS notes that the link to hyperactivity is not fully proven and that colours are probably only a small factor for most children.

US rules have since been moving closer. In April 2025 the FDA and the Department of Health and Human Services announced a plan for food makers to phase out six petroleum-based dyes, including Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6 and Blue 1, by the end of 2026. That phase-out relies largely on voluntary industry action, while several US states have passed their own binding bans.

What people said about the comparison

The post drew thousands of comments. Some readers questioned the comparison itself:

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

One commenter argued that US labels simply list more detail, while UK labels can group ingredients under broad terms such as "natural flavouring". There is some truth here: both countries allow umbrella terms for flavourings, but the way recipes are listed does vary.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Another reader wondered whether the UK was simply disclosing less. In fact, UK and EU law requires all ingredients to be listed in descending order of weight, so a shorter list usually means a simpler recipe, not hidden ingredients.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

This commenter pointed out that several pairs compare different products, such as a flavoured oatmeal against a plain one. That criticism holds up for the oats and Doritos pictures, as noted above.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

A reader suggested the products were the same and only labelled differently because of US lawsuits. That is not the case for drinks like Mountain Dew and ketchup, whose sweeteners and colours genuinely differed.

Others agreed with the post, joked about it or took a broader view:

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

One reply felt Americans were being sold cheaper products bulked out with fillers. Cost is part of the story: corn syrup has long been cheaper than sugar in the US because of farm policy and import quotas on sugar.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

A lighter response joked that the real scandal was the British name "Cheesey Pasta". Kraft did use different branding in the UK, which is a reminder that the two products were never sold as identical.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

One commenter suggested avoiding the debate by eating a plant-based diet. Most of the products compared are not meat dishes anyway, so the real question here is about processing rather than meat.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

Another reply put the responsibility on shoppers to read labels, noting that US supermarkets offer plenty of choice. Label reading is indeed the most practical tool consumers have.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

A longer comment argued that the products are probably made the same way and only declared differently, and that at least US labels show what is inside. As the drink and ketchup examples show, some recipes did differ, but the point about transparency is a fair one.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

A short reply took a swipe at British food in general. Taste preferences are one reason recipes vary: brands adjust sweetness, colour and flavour for each market.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

One commenter said they would avoid these processed foods whatever the label. Health bodies on both sides of the Atlantic do advise limiting foods high in sugar, salt and saturated fat, regardless of additives.

Comparing US and UK Ingredient Labels

A final reply criticised people who defend processed food as healthy. The comparison is better read as a prompt to check labels than as proof that one country's food is safe and the other's is not.

Who made the comparison, and how to read it

Vani Hari started her Food Babe blog in 2011 and has written two bestselling books. Her campaigns have pushed companies to drop ingredients, though companies such as Subway and Kraft said their changes were not a response to her petitions. She has also been widely criticised by scientists, who say she lacks training in food science, sometimes misreads research and encourages fear of chemical-sounding names. Both points are worth keeping in mind when looking at her images.

A few practical habits make comparisons like this more useful:

  • Compare like with like: same flavour, same product line, same year.
  • Look at nutrition, not just length: sugar, salt and saturated fat usually matter more for health than the number of ingredients.
  • Remember that names differ: the UK often uses E numbers or common names where the US uses chemical names, so the same additive can look very different on paper.
  • Check dates: recipes change often, and several in this set have changed since 2019.

Anyone with allergies, or a child who seems to react to certain foods, should talk to a doctor rather than rely on viral charts.

Sources: Food Babe (Vani Hari), creator of the comparison images; Wikipedia: Vani Hari; US FDA, 2 July 2024: FDA revokes regulation allowing the use of BVO in food; Morrison Foerster, April 2025: FDA seeks to phase out synthetic color additives; NHS 111 Wales: Food colours and hyperactivity. Comment screenshots are from the public Facebook post shared by Kacey Birch.

COMMENTS