Originally published 2019-10-21.

Research presented in 2019 suggested that women who routinely hold back their thoughts and feelings to keep the peace may carry a higher risk of artery disease. In a study of 304 midlife women, those who scored higher on a measure of "self-silencing" were more likely to have plaque in their carotid arteries, the vessels in the neck that supply the brain. The finding was an association, not proof of cause, and it was not about being loud. It was about whether women feel able to express themselves at all.
Some headlines summed the study up as "being a loud woman is good for your health". That framing misses the point. Here is what self-silencing actually means, what the researchers measured, what other studies have found, and how to apply the idea sensibly in everyday relationships.
What self-silencing means
Self-silencing is a pattern in which a person regularly suppresses their own opinions, needs or emotions in close relationships, usually to avoid conflict or the risk of losing the relationship. The concept was developed by psychologist Dana Crowley Jack in the late 1980s and set out in her 1991 book Silencing the Self, which grew out of interviews with depressed women. She also created a questionnaire, the Silencing the Self Scale, which researchers still use.
Typical items on the scale ask people whether they agree with statements about putting a partner's needs ahead of their own, avoiding disagreements, judging themselves by how others see them, or showing a pleasant face while feeling something quite different inside. Someone who scores high is not necessarily quiet or shy. They may be talkative and sociable while still feeling unable to say what they really think to the people closest to them.
The behaviour often comes from good intentions: protecting a partner, keeping family life calm, avoiding a fight at work. The problem is when it becomes the default, and a person's own needs consistently go unspoken.
The 2019 study on carotid plaque
The research was presented at the annual meeting of the North American Menopause Society (now called The Menopause Society) in Chicago in October 2019. It was led by researchers at the University of Pittsburgh, including psychologist Karen Jakubowski and women's health researcher Rebecca Thurston.
The team studied 304 nonsmoking women in perimenopause or after menopause, without existing heart disease. Each woman completed the self-silencing questionnaire and had an ultrasound scan of her carotid arteries. Women with higher self-silencing scores had greater odds of carotid plaque, even after the researchers accounted for standard cardiovascular risk factors.
Carotid plaque matters because it is a sign of atherosclerosis, the build-up of fatty deposits that narrows arteries. Plaque in the neck can raise the risk of stroke, and it is also a marker of hardening arteries elsewhere in the body, including the heart.
Several cautions apply. The study looked at women at a single point in time, so it cannot say whether self-silencing led to plaque, whether something else drove both, or how strong any effect might be for an individual. Results presented at a conference are also preliminary until they appear in a peer-reviewed journal. And despite what some reports claimed, the study did not measure shouting, outbursts, constipation or obesity.
Why holding back might affect the body
Researchers have proposed a few plausible routes, none of them fully proven:
- Chronic stress. Constantly monitoring one's words and swallowing frustration can keep the body's stress response switched on. Over time, raised stress hormones, blood pressure and blood sugar are linked with cardiovascular disease.
- Depression. Self-silencing is strongly associated with depression in many studies, and depression is itself a recognised risk factor for heart disease.
- Less support. People who do not share their needs may get less practical and emotional help from those around them, which can affect sleep, habits and how they cope with illness.
Psychologists also note that self-silencing is often tied to sensitivity to rejection. Keeping up an appearance of calm can feel safer in the moment, but it does not remove the underlying tension.
What other research says
The Pittsburgh study fits into a broader body of work on emotions, relationships and health. An analysis from the long-running Framingham Offspring Study, published in 2007, reported that women who said they kept their feelings to themselves during conflicts with their husbands had a higher risk of death over the following decade than women who expressed themselves.
In cancer research, an often-cited study of women with breast cancer, by psychologist Annette Stanton and colleagues in 2000, found that those who actively expressed their emotions about the illness reported better physical health and fewer medical visits in the following months. The benefit, though, seemed to depend on how emotions were expressed: processing and talking through feelings helped, while dwelling on distress did not.
That nuance runs through the whole field. Expressing emotions is not the same as venting anger at full volume. Studies on hostility and anger have linked frequent explosive anger with heart problems too. The healthier middle ground is honest, regular communication.
Speaking up without shouting
If you recognise yourself in the description of self-silencing, the goal is not to become louder. It is to make your perspective part of the conversation. A few approaches therapists commonly suggest:
- Start small. Practise stating a preference in low-stakes situations, such as where to eat or what to watch, before tackling bigger issues.
- Use "I" statements. Saying "I felt left out when plans changed" invites discussion; "you never include me" invites defence.
- Choose the moment. Raise important matters when both people are calm and have time, rather than in the middle of a crisis.
- Notice the pattern. Keeping a short note of the times you held back can show whether silence has become a habit with a particular person.
- Get support. A counsellor or therapist can help untangle long-standing habits, especially when they link to anxiety or low mood.
Respect works in both directions. Speaking up includes listening, and the aim is a relationship where both people's needs can be voiced without fear.
The takeaway for women's heart health
Heart disease is a leading cause of death among women, and the years around menopause are a time when cardiovascular risk tends to rise. The self-silencing research adds to growing evidence that emotional and social life belongs in the conversation about heart health, alongside blood pressure, cholesterol, smoking and activity.
It is not a reason for alarm, and it does not mean a quiet personality is dangerous. If you are worried about your heart, or about stress and mood, talk to a doctor, who can check your risk factors and point you towards the right support.
Sources: The Menopause Society (formerly NAMS); Wikipedia: Carotid artery stenosis; Jack, D. C., Silencing the Self: Women and Depression (1991); Eaker, E. D. et al., Framingham Offspring Study, Psychosomatic Medicine (2007); Stanton, A. L. et al., Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology (2000).

COMMENTS