Originally published 2019-10-22.

Northview Church of Carmel, Indiana
In 2019, Northview Church, a large congregation based in Carmel, Indiana, used donations to cancel about $7.8 million in medical debt for roughly 5,940 families in Central Indiana. It did this by partnering with the New York charity RIP Medical Debt, now called Undue Medical Debt, which buys unpaid medical bills cheaply and then forgives them. The families did not have to apply, attend church or pay anything back.
How can a church cancel millions of dollars of debt without raising millions? The answer lies in the way medical debt is bought and sold. Here is how the Indiana campaign worked, how the charity behind it operates, and what research says about the real-world effects of this kind of relief.
What Northview Church did
Northview is a multi-site church with more than 10,000 attenders and campuses across Central Indiana. In June 2019 it announced that it would abolish around $2 million in medical debt for about 2,500 families in the communities around its sites.
Members of the congregation then gave more. According to the church, attenders contributed an additional $20,000 to keep the effort going, which more than doubled its reach. By early October 2019 the church announced a final total of about $7.8 million in debt relieved for some 5,940 families across ten communities. The church said that in some towns, all of the medical debt held in the portfolios it targeted was cleared.
Senior Pastor Steve Poe framed it as faith in practice, calling it a demonstration of God's love
. On social media he made a point that many people found striking, that the help came with no expectation of conversion:
We don’t serve others to convert them. We serve others because we have been converted.
— Steve Poe (@pastorstevepoe) September 16, 2019
How $1 can cancel about $100 of medical debt
When hospitals and doctors cannot collect on a bill after a long time, they often sell the debt in bulk to collection agencies or debt buyers, usually for a small fraction of its face value. The buyer then tries to collect the full amount from the patient, keeping whatever it manages to recover.
RIP Medical Debt used the same market for the opposite purpose. With donated money, it bought portfolios of old medical debt at those discounted prices, and instead of chasing patients for payment, it simply cancelled the debt. The charity says each donated dollar relieves, on average, around $100 of medical debt, although the exact ratio varies from one portfolio to the next.
That is why the headline figure and the money raised are so different. Donors did not pay $7.8 million in hospital bills. They paid the much lower price at which the debt was being traded, and the full face value was then wiped off people's records.
Who benefits and how they find out
Debt is not cancelled at random. The charity focuses on people for whom medical bills are a heavy burden, generally those with low incomes or with debt that is large compared with what they earn. Because the debt is bought in bundles, recipients do not apply and often have no idea that relief is coming. They learn about it from a letter telling them that a specific bill has been forgiven with no strings attached.
That meant most of the Indiana families helped had no connection to Northview at all. Church leaders said this was the point. Several other churches and community groups in the United States have since run similar campaigns, as have city and county governments using public funds.
The charity behind the purchase
RIP Medical Debt was founded in 2014 by Jerry Ashton and Craig Antico, two former debt-collection executives who knew from the inside how cheaply old medical debt changed hands. It gained national attention in 2016, when the HBO show Last Week Tonight with John Oliver bought a portfolio of roughly $15 million in medical debt and had it forgiven with the charity's help. In April 2024 the charity renamed itself Undue Medical Debt. By October 2026 it said it had relieved more than $49.6 billion of medical debt for over 31.6 million people.
What research says about the impact
Cancelling medical debt clearly removes a bill, a collector's calls and a source of stress. But the long-term effects are more complicated than the headlines suggest. A randomised study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research in 2024, which looked at around 213,000 people with medical debt, found that on average, relief through the charity did not measurably improve recipients' credit scores or mental health, and did not make them more likely to seek medical care they had been putting off.
The charity's leadership said those results did not match what it hears from the people it helps. Researchers and advocates have suggested several reasons for the gap: much of the debt bought is years old and already unlikely to be collected, and its effect on credit may have faded. Debt relief also does nothing to stop new bills from piling up. Many experts argue that preventing medical debt in the first place, through better insurance, financial assistance policies at hospitals and clearer billing, matters at least as much.
If you are struggling with medical bills
You cannot apply for relief from the charity, but there are practical steps worth taking:
- Ask for an itemised bill and check it for errors or duplicate charges.
- Ask about financial assistance. Nonprofit hospitals in the US are required to have charity care policies, and many patients qualify without knowing it.
- Negotiate. Hospitals often accept a reduced lump sum or an interest-free payment plan.
- Know your credit rights. The major US credit bureaus have stopped reporting paid medical collections and small medical debts.
- Get advice from a nonprofit credit counsellor or patient advocate before paying a collector.
Northview's campaign was a small, local act with a big number attached. It shows how creatively a community can use a broken market for good, and it also shows why lasting solutions to medical debt need more than generosity alone.
Sources: FOX 13: Indiana church pays off $7.8M in medical debt for 5,940 families (October 2019); Wikipedia: Undue Medical Debt.

COMMENTS