California's Fur Sales Ban (AB 44): What It Covers and Exempts

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
California’s Fur-Sales Ban: An Archived Report and Its Scope

California is the first US state to ban the sale and manufacture of new fur products. Governor Gavin Newsom signed the law, Assembly Bill 44, on 12 October 2019, and it took effect on 1 January 2023. Since then it has been illegal to sell, display for sale, trade or make new fur clothing, shoes, handbags and accessories anywhere in the state, in shops or online. Second-hand fur, leather, sheepskin and a handful of other items remain legal.

The same day, Newsom also signed a separate law banning most wild animals from circus acts. The two measures are often reported together, but they are different laws with different rules. This guide explains both, the exemptions that matter to shoppers and sellers, and what has happened since.

What AB 44 bans

AB 44 was written by Assemblymember Laura Friedman, a Democrat from Glendale. It defines fur as any animal skin, or part of one, with the hair, fleece or fur fibres still attached, whether raw or processed. A fur product is any clothing, covering or fashion accessory made wholly or partly of fur: coats and trims, of course, but also hats, gloves, shoes, slippers, handbags, key chains, jewellery and home decor.

Under the law it is unlawful to:

  • sell, offer for sale, display for sale, trade or otherwise distribute a new fur product in California;
  • manufacture a fur product in California for sale.

The ban covers retailers, wholesalers and online sellers delivering into the state. It does not make it illegal to own or wear fur. A Californian can still wear a coat inherited from a grandparent or bought before the deadline.

California’s Fur-Sales Ban: An Archived Report and Its Scope

A red fox in a wire-floored cage. Foxes, along with mink, raccoon dogs and chinchillas, are among the species most often raised on fur farms, an industry that animal-welfare groups estimate kills more than 100 million animals worldwide each year.

What is exempt

The law carves out a number of materials and situations. According to the chaptered bill text, AB 44 does not apply to:

  • Leather and hides: animal skins processed into leather with the hair removed, and cowhide, deerskin, sheepskin or goatskin with the hair still on (so shearling boots and sheepskin rugs are allowed).
  • Taxidermy specimens.
  • Used fur products, which can still be sold by non-profit thrift stores, second-hand shops and pawn shops.
  • Religious use of fur.
  • Traditional tribal, cultural or spiritual use by members of federally recognised or California-listed Native American tribes.
  • Fur from animals taken under a California hunting or trapping licence, and any activity expressly authorised by federal law.

Dog and cat fur were already banned under separate state and federal rules, so they sit outside AB 44 altogether.

Fines and enforcement

AB 44 is enforced through civil penalties rather than criminal charges. Some early reports gave the fines simply as $500 and $1,000, but the bill actually sets three steps:

  • up to $500 for a first violation;
  • up to $750 for a violation within a year of a previous one;
  • up to $1,000 for a violation within a year of a second or later offence.

Each fur product counts as a separate violation, so a shop with racks of coats could face large totals. Cases can be brought by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Attorney General, district attorneys, city attorneys or county counsel. Penalties go into the state's Fish and Game Preservation Fund, and investigators can recover their costs and legal fees. Sellers of exempt used or religious items must keep transaction records for a year.

Supporters, critics and the fashion industry

Animal-protection groups celebrated the law. PETA's executive vice president Tracy Reiman praised it publicly, and the groups behind it hoped other states would follow. California mattered more than most: according to Humane World for Animals, which campaigned for the bill, nearly a quarter of US fur product sales took place in the state. Before AB 44, four California cities had already passed their own bans: Los Angeles, San Francisco, Berkeley and West Hollywood.

The fur trade objected strongly. Keith Kaplan, communications director of the Fur Information Council of America, told California Apparel News that the group intended to challenge the law, arguing that it shut down legitimate businesses "by government fiat" and threatened workers. Industry representatives also argued that faux fur, usually made from petroleum-based acrylic or polyester, is not a sustainable alternative.

That environmental argument is genuinely debated. Synthetic fur is plastic and sheds microfibres; real fur requires animal farming, chemical tanning and dressing. Lifecycle comparisons depend heavily on how long a garment is worn and who funded the study, so shoppers looking for the lowest-impact option often choose second-hand pieces or skip fur-look clothing entirely.

By the time the law passed, much of high fashion was already moving. Gucci announced in 2017 that it would stop using fur, Versace followed in 2018 and Prada in 2019. Humane World for Animals lists later pledges by Canada Goose, Saks Fifth Avenue, Neiman Marcus and others.

California’s Fur-Sales Ban: An Archived Report and Its Scope

Activists holding "Say No to Fur" and "I Am Suffering" signs on the steps of Los Angeles City Hall. Los Angeles approved its own ban on fur sales in 2018, one of the local measures that paved the way for the statewide law.

The circus law signed the same day

The second measure, SB 313, by state senator Ben Hueso of San Diego, is the California Circus Cruelty Prevention Act. It bars circuses from using wild animals such as bears, tigers, elephants and monkeys in performances. Domestic animals, including dogs, cats and horses, are not covered. Older versions of this story blended the two laws into one, which confused readers about what the fur ban does.

Signing the package, Newsom said: "We are making a statement to the world that beautiful wild animals like bears and tigers have no place on trapeze wires or jumping through flames." The same set of bills also banned bobcat trapping and hunting, strengthened protections against horse slaughter and widened a ban on trading parts of several dead exotic animals.

What has happened since

The fur ban came into force on schedule on 1 January 2023. The phase-in period gave retailers more than three years to clear old stock and shift to fur-free lines. Used fur is still openly sold in thrift and vintage shops across the state, exactly as the law allows.

Humane World for Animals describes California as the first state to put such a ban into practice and says many other communities have since followed with local measures. Internationally, Israel became the first country to prohibit the sale of fur for fashion in 2021, and more than 20 countries have banned or restricted fur farming.

Practical answers for shoppers and sellers

  • Can I still wear my fur coat in California? Yes. The law targets selling and making new products, not owning or wearing them.
  • Can I sell my old fur? Used fur may be sold through second-hand channels such as thrift stores, consignment shops and pawn shops.
  • Are shearling and leather affected? No. Sheepskin, cowhide, deerskin and goatskin, with or without hair, are exempt.
  • Does it cover faux fur? No. Synthetic fur is not animal fur and can be sold freely.

Sources: AB 44 (2019), chaptered bill text; Governor's office release on the October 2019 animal-welfare bills, via Lake County News; California Apparel News, October 2019; CBS News, 12 October 2019; Humane World for Animals: California's fur ban takes effect.

COMMENTS