
Yes, bees really did win a public vote for the planet's most irreplaceable living group. It happened in November 2008, at an evening debate run by the conservation charity Earthwatch at the Royal Geographical Society in London. Five scientists each championed one group of organisms, and an audience of around 650 people decided which one we could least afford to lose. Bees came out on top, with plankton a close second.
The result was a vote, not a scientific ranking, and that matters for how we read the many viral posts that later described bees as "officially" the most important beings on Earth. What the debate did do was put a spotlight on a real and well-documented problem: the pollinators that feed much of the world are under pressure. Here is what happened in the room, what the science says about why bees matter, and what ordinary people can do to help.
The 2008 Earthwatch debate: who argued for what
Earthwatch had been staging an annual public debate for eight years by 2008, each one built around a conservation theme. That year's event, titled "Irreplaceable", was chaired by broadcaster Andrea Catherwood and later aired on BBC Radio 4 on Christmas Eve. The challenge, as Catherwood framed it, was to find "the species we'd be hardest pushed to live without."
The line-up was strong:
- Bees – Dr George McGavin, an entomologist with a long career at the Oxford University Museum of Natural History and a familiar face from BBC natural history programmes.
- Plankton – Professor David Thomas of the School of Ocean Sciences at Bangor University.
- Fungi – Professor Lynne Boddy of Cardiff University's School of Biosciences.
- Bats – Dr Kate Jones of the Zoological Society of London, then vice-chair of the Bat Conservation Trust.
- Primates – Ian Redmond OBE, chairman of the Ape Alliance, the man who introduced David Attenborough to wild gorillas in 1978.
In the first round of voting, plankton led and bees were second. The two front-runners were then given five more minutes each to make a final pitch. Thomas gave a strong closing argument for the tiny drifting organisms that underpin ocean food webs and produce a large share of the planet's oxygen, but McGavin swung the room. His case rested on sheer dependence: roughly a quarter of a million species of flowering plants rely on bees, and so do many of the crops that end up on our plates. He also named the main pressures on bees as habitat loss and fragmentation, rising insecticide use and disease.
Speaking after the win, McGavin did not soften his message: "Bee populations are in freefall. A world without bees would be totally catastrophic."

Why bees matter so much: pollination in plain terms
Most flowering plants cannot move their own pollen. They need wind, water or animals to carry it from one flower to another so that seeds and fruit can form. Bees are the specialists of this job. Unlike many insects that visit flowers casually, bees deliberately collect pollen to feed their young, and their hairy bodies pick it up and spread it as they work.
The numbers are large, though they are often quoted carelessly. Researchers estimate that close to nine in ten flowering plant species are pollinated by animals of some kind, and about 60 percent of crop plant species use animal pollinators. That list includes most fruits, many vegetables, nuts, oilseeds and fodder crops such as clover and alfalfa that feed livestock. In the United States, the Department of Agriculture credits honey bees with around 80 percent of insect crop pollination.
Apples, cherries, blueberries, almonds, squash, cucumbers and melons all yield more, or better shaped, fruit when bees visit. Coffee, cocoa and many spices benefit too. Cotton plants are visited by bees as well, and some studies link that to better yields, although cotton can largely pollinate itself.

The effects ripple outward. Wild birds and small mammals eat berries and seeds from bee-pollinated plants, so a shortage of pollinators can thin out food supplies across whole habitats, not just on farms.
Common myths about bees and our food
Because the topic is emotional, it has collected a few exaggerations. Clearing them up makes the real case stronger, not weaker.
"Without bees, humans would starve within a few years"
This is overstated. The world's biggest staple crops by volume, including wheat, rice and maize, are wind-pollinated, and potatoes are grown from tubers. A world without bees would still have bread and rice. What it would lose is much of its variety and nutrition: fruit, vegetables, nuts and seeds would become scarcer and far more expensive, and diets would become poorer. That is serious enough without inventing a famine countdown.
"90 percent of bees have already disappeared"
Some viral versions of this story claimed that almost all bees had vanished in just a few years. There is no evidence for that. The real picture is mixed and still worrying. Managed honey bee colonies fell by about a quarter in Europe between 1985 and 2005 and by more than half in North America between 1947 and 2005, yet the global number of hives has actually grown because beekeeping expanded in countries such as China and Argentina. Wild bees are a different story. A 2021 analysis of global biodiversity records found that the number of wild bee species being recorded fell by roughly a quarter between 2006 and 2015 compared with the period before 1990.
"Saving bees means saving honey bees"
Honey bees are just one species among roughly 20,000 bee species worldwide. Bumblebees, mason bees, mining bees and many solitary species do a large share of pollination, and some crops, such as tomatoes and blueberries, are pollinated more effectively by them. Keeping more honey bee hives does not automatically help wild bees, and in some places it can increase competition for flowers.

What is driving bee decline
Scientists do not point to a single cause. Instead, several pressures stack on top of one another:
- Loss of habitat and flowers. Intensive farming, tidy lawns and urban sprawl remove the wildflowers bees feed on and the bare soil, hollow stems and old wood many species nest in.
- Pesticides. Neonicotinoid insecticides, the most widely used class, have been linked to harm to bees' nervous and immune systems. The European Union restricted their outdoor use in 2018.
- Parasites and disease. The Varroa mite spreads viruses such as deformed wing virus through honey bee colonies, and diseases can spill over to wild bees.
- Climate change. Shifts in temperature can put bees out of step with the flowers they depend on and change the ranges of species and their parasites.
Colony collapse disorder, in which worker bees suddenly abandon a hive, drew headlines in the late 2000s, around the time of the Earthwatch debate. It is now seen as one symptom of these combined stresses rather than a separate mystery.

How you can help bees at home and in your community
Large changes in farming policy matter most, but individual choices add up, especially in gardens, balconies and parks.
- Plant for a long season. Choose a mix of native flowering plants that bloom from early spring to late autumn, so bees always have something to feed on.
- Let a little wildness in. Mow less often, leave dandelions and clover for a while, and keep a corner with bare soil, dead stems or a log pile for nesting.
- Go easy on chemicals. Avoid spraying insecticides on plants in flower, and look for non-chemical ways to deal with pests.
- Offer water. A shallow dish with stones to land on helps bees on hot days.
- Buy local honey and support farmers who use pollinator-friendly practices such as hedgerows and flower strips.
- Join a count. Citizen science projects that record bee sightings help researchers track which species are doing well and which are not.
Bee "hotels" for solitary species can help too, provided they are cleaned or replaced regularly so they do not spread disease.


How readers reacted
When this story circulated on social media, the comments ranged from heartfelt to playful. One reader pointed others to the Pollinator Partnership, a non-profit dedicated to protecting pollinators. Another argued, fairly, that plants themselves deserve top billing, since bees depend on them too. Others joked about welcoming "bee overlords", insisted their own children were the most important living things on Earth, or reminded everyone that honey has to be bought, not taken from the bee.
The disagreement is a useful reminder of the debate's real purpose. Bees, plankton, fungi, bats and primates are all tied together in the same living web. Picking a winner was a way to get people talking about what we stand to lose.









Sources: Earthwatch release via Innovations Report (November 2008); Oxford Times; Wikipedia: Pollinator decline; Wikipedia: George McGavin. Photos: Pexels, Jason Riedy, PollyDot, Alexandre Dulaunoy, cbransto and Myriams-Fotos as credited above.

COMMENTS