Originally published 2019-09-21.
On 24 July 2019, the five-member Board of Fire Commissioners of the Franklin Square and Munson Fire District, a volunteer fire district on Long Island, New York, voted unanimously for a resolution supporting a new federal grand jury investigation into the 11 September 2001 attacks. The resolution claimed there was "overwhelming evidence" that explosives had destroyed the three World Trade Center towers that collapsed that day. The vote was symbolic: a local fire board has no power to open an inquiry, and the official technical investigations concluded that the buildings fell because of aircraft impact damage and fire.
Here is what the commissioners actually voted for, why the vote meant so much to them, where the demand came from, and what the engineering investigations found.
Who voted and why it was personal
Franklin Square is a hamlet of about 30,000 people in Nassau County. Its fire department is made up of volunteers, and like many Long Island departments it has deep ties to the New York City Fire Department (FDNY). On 9/11 it lost one of its own: Thomas J. Hetzel, a member of the district's Hook and Ladder Company 1 who was also a full-time FDNY firefighter, died at the World Trade Center. The district also honours Robert Evans, a Franklin Square native and fallen firefighter. Members of the department went to Ground Zero on 12 September 2001 and spent weeks searching the debris, and some have since suffered long-term health problems.
The resolution was drafted and introduced by Commissioner Christopher Gioia and passed 5–0 with the votes of Commissioners Philip Malloy Jr., Dennis Lyons, Joseph Torregrossa and Les Saltzman. Relatives of Hetzel and Evans attended the meeting, and the audience applauded the result. Gioia said he hoped other fire districts would pass similar resolutions.
What the resolution said
The text did three things. It referred to a petition that a group called the Lawyers' Committee for 9/11 Inquiry had sent to the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, asking that its material be presented to a special grand jury. It asserted that there was evidence that "pre-planted explosives and/or incendiaries" brought down the Twin Towers and 7 World Trade Center. And it declared support for a full federal grand jury investigation and for any other official efforts to look into the events of that day.
The vote was publicised by the advocacy group Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth (AE911Truth), which has campaigned for years for a new investigation, and the story spread through alternative news sites. The group shared the news on Twitter a few days later:
New York Area Fire Commissioners Make History, Call for New 9/11 Investigationhttps://t.co/j4jd94AABm #engineer #architect #firefighter #fdny #Trump #giuliani #JonStewart #JohnFeal #HR1327 #MitchMcConnell pic.twitter.com/BgU4Bkvqh6
— AE911Truth (@AE911Truth) July 27, 2019
The hashtags in that post point to the wider political moment. In July 2019, first responders, the comedian Jon Stewart and advocate John Feal were pressing Congress to pass H.R. 1327, the bill that made the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund effectively permanent for responders and survivors with 9/11-related illnesses. That bill became law at the end of July 2019. It is a separate issue from questions about how the towers fell, but it explains why firefighters' voices carried particular weight that summer.
The 2018 grand jury petition
The fire board's resolution built on a petition filed in 2018 by the Lawyers' Committee for 9/11 Inquiry, an advocacy group, with the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, then Geoffrey S. Berman. Earlier reports sometimes said Berman himself filed the petition or won a court victory; that is not correct. The petition invoked a federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 3332, which says a US attorney who receives information about an alleged federal crime from any person must inform the grand jury of it.
In a letter dated 7 November 2018, the US Attorney's office replied only that it would comply with that law. It did not say what, if anything, it would present, and grand jury proceedings are secret. No indictment or public finding has resulted from the petition.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
What the official investigations found
The attacks were examined by the 9/11 Commission, whose 2004 report focused on how al-Qaeda planned and carried them out and how US agencies failed to stop them, and by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), which investigated why the buildings collapsed. NIST published its report on the Twin Towers in 2005 and on 7 World Trade Center in 2008.
For the towers, NIST concluded that the aircraft impacts severed columns and stripped fireproofing, and that the resulting fires heated and weakened the steel (without needing to melt it) until upper floors fell and the structures below could not stop them.
Building 7, a 47-storey tower that was not hit by a plane, is the focus of most alternative theories. NIST found that debris from the North Tower set fires on at least ten of its floors, and that the water supply to sprinklers on several lower floors had been cut. The fires burned for about seven hours. Heat caused long floor beams on the east side to expand, pushing a girder off its seat at Column 79 on the 13th floor; floors then gave way, Column 79 buckled, and the failure spread through the building. NIST's lead investigator, Shyam Sunder, said uncontrolled fires "caused an extraordinary event", describing WTC 7 as the first modern high-rise known to have collapsed primarily because of fire. NIST ruled out explosives and fuel-oil fires as causes.
Weighing the competing claims
Supporters of a new inquiry point to the speed and symmetry of the collapses, eyewitness reports of explosions, and the fact that NIST did not test the debris for explosive residue. Some have also cited papers claiming to have found thermite residue in WTC dust.
Mainstream engineers and investigators answer that loud bangs are common in large fires, that a controlled demolition of buildings that size would have required weeks of visible preparation and would have produced distinctive blast sounds and evidence, and that independent analyses, including tests by the US Geological Survey and the consultancy RJ Lee, found no sign of thermite or explosives in the dust. A later analysis of the chips cited as thermite found them consistent with paint-coated steel. The broad consensus among structural engineers is that the collapses were caused by impact damage and fire.
A local resolution, however sincere, does not change that technical picture. Its significance is as a sign of how deeply 9/11 still affects the communities that lost people, and of how much trust in official accounts has been worn down over two decades.
How to evaluate 9/11 claims yourself
- Separate grief from evidence. The losses of departments like Franklin Square's are real; that does not by itself make any particular theory of the collapses correct.
- Read the primary reports. NIST's reports and FAQs, and the 9/11 Commission Report, are public and set out their methods.
- Check what a source has actually done. A petition, a press release or a resolution is a request or an opinion, not a finding by a court or investigator.
- Look for peer-reviewed engineering work and how other experts responded to it.
Sources: AE911Truth press release on the Franklin Square and Munson resolution (July 2019, advocacy source); Fire Engineering: NIST, fire caused the collapse of WTC 7 (October 2008); Wikipedia: 9/11 conspiracy theories. Tweet: @AE911Truth.

COMMENTS