Do Men Mature Later Than Women? What Brain Research Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published September 8, 2019.

Brain Development and the Claim That Men Mature Later Than Women

© The Hangover / Warner Bros

Do men really mature later than women? Brain research gives a partial, more interesting answer. A 2013 imaging study of 121 people aged 4 to 40 found that the brain keeps reorganising its wiring well into adulthood, and that this reorganisation tends to happen earlier in females than in males. That is a finding about average timing in brain connections. It is not proof that any particular man is childish, or that women are naturally the grown-ups in a relationship.

The idea that boys and men lag behind is an old piece of folk wisdom, and popular comedies have made a whole genre out of it. Here is what the science behind the headline actually measured, where the popular version goes too far, and what maturity looks like when you set the stereotypes aside.

The study behind the headline

The research most often quoted for this claim came from Newcastle University in England, not Oxford as many viral versions said. Neuroinformatics researcher Dr Marcus Kaiser and PhD student Sol Lim, working with colleagues in Glasgow and Seoul, published it in the journal Cerebral Cortex in December 2013 under the title "Preferential Detachment During Human Brain Development".

The team scanned 121 healthy volunteers between the ages of 4 and 40 using diffusion tensor imaging, an MRI method that traces the bundles of nerve fibres linking one brain region to another. By comparing people of different ages, they could map how the overall network of connections changes as we grow up.

Brain Development and the Claim That Men Mature Later Than Women

© Friends / Warner Bros

What "maturing" means inside the brain

A child's brain is not simply a smaller adult brain. Early in life it builds a dense web of connections, and over the following decades many of them are trimmed away. This pruning sounds like loss, but it usually makes the system more efficient, much like clearing side roads so the main highways run faster.

The Newcastle team found that pruning was not random. Connections between distant regions, between the two hemispheres and between major processing hubs were preserved more than expected, while many shorter local links were removed. The researchers called this pattern "preferential detachment". Kaiser explained why the long links matter: "Long-distance connections are difficult to establish and maintain but are crucial for fast and efficient processing."

Lim described the logic of trimming the rest: reducing some projections "helps to focus on essential information." In other words, a more mature network is not one with more wiring, but one with better-organised wiring.

Where the sex difference comes in

The headline-making part of the paper was that these reorganising changes appeared earlier, on average, in the female participants than in the male ones. The university's own press release presented this as a possible explanation for why girls tend to mature faster during childhood and adolescence.

That is a reasonable hypothesis, but it is worth being precise about what it covers. The study looked at structural connections in a modest sample. It did not test emotional maturity, decision-making, kindness, reliability or how anyone behaves in a relationship. It also compared group averages across ages rather than following the same people over many years, so individual timelines were not tracked.

Some later retellings added that women's networks also decline sooner. That detail is not part of the university's summary of the findings, and it is better treated as unconfirmed.

Brain Development and the Claim That Men Mature Later Than Women

© Brooklyn Nine Nine / NBCUniversal Television Distribution

Do women have "more efficient" brains?

Many versions of this story also quoted Eduardo Calixto, a physiology and pharmacology professor at the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM), who told the Mexican newspaper La Jornada in 2018 that although men's brains are larger on average, women's brains work more efficiently, with advantages in memory and in the perception of colour and flavour, which he linked to hormones.

Part of that is well established: male brains are larger on average, largely in line with larger average body size. The rest is far more contested. Research on memory gives mixed results. Women tend to do better on some tasks, such as recalling episodes, words and autobiographical details, while men on average do better on certain spatial memory tasks, and many studies find no difference at all.

A large 2021 review of brain-imaging research concluded that, once total brain size is taken into account, sex explains only around 1% of variation in brain structure or lateralisation. Most individual brains are a mix of features, and the overlap between men and women is huge. Calling one sex's brain simply "better" goes well beyond what the evidence supports.

Brain development keeps going into adulthood

One point in this research applies to everyone. Brain networks keep changing long after the teenage years. Imaging studies over the past two decades consistently show that regions involved in planning, impulse control and weighing risks are among the last to settle, often into the mid-twenties. That helps explain why judgement typically improves through early adulthood for both sexes.

So when people joke that a 22-year-old "still has some growing up to do", they are not entirely wrong, whatever that person's sex. The timing varies from one person to the next, and life experience, education, stress and relationships all shape how the brain develops.

Brain Development and the Claim That Men Mature Later Than Women

© How I Met Your Mother / 20th Century Fox Television

Myths worth dropping

"Science proves men never grow up." No study shows this. The Newcastle research describes earlier average timing in females during development, not a permanent gap in adulthood.

"Women are the mature half of every couple." Group averages say nothing reliable about two specific people. Plenty of relationships have a man who is the steadier partner, or two partners who take turns.

"Brain scans can measure emotional maturity." They cannot. A scan shows structure or activity patterns; maturity is judged by behaviour over time.

What maturity looks like in real life

If you want to know whether someone, including yourself, is emotionally mature, everyday habits tell you far more than any study of fibre tracts. Useful signs include:

  • Taking responsibility for mistakes instead of shifting blame.
  • Listening to understand rather than just waiting to reply.
  • Handling disagreement without sulking, shouting or keeping score.
  • Keeping promises, including small ones.
  • Managing money, time and health without relying on a partner to do it.

These skills can be learned at any age. The brain keeps adapting throughout life, which is the more hopeful message hidden inside this research: maturity is not fixed by sex at birth, and people of any gender can keep growing into it.

Sources: Newcastle University press release, December 2013; ScienceDaily: Brain connections may explain why girls mature faster; Wikipedia: Sex differences in psychology (memory and brain-structure reviews); La Jornada interview with Eduardo Calixto, March 2018. Images: stills from The Hangover and Friends (Warner Bros), Brooklyn Nine-Nine (NBCUniversal) and How I Met Your Mother (20th Century Fox Television).

COMMENTS