The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

In September 2019, authorities near Courmayeur in Italy closed roads and evacuated selected properties after monitoring revealed instability in part of the Planpincieux glacier. The warning concerned a specific ice mass above Val Ferret in the Mont Blanc massif, during a period of concern about warming and glacier change across the Alps.


Stefano Miserocchi, the mayor of Courmayeur town, noted that “public safety is a priority”. Experts from the Fondazione Montagna Sicura (Safe Mountains Foundation) in the Aosta Valley also said that up to 250,000 cubic meters of ice was in danger of sliding off the Planpincieux glacier on the Grandes Jorasses peak.


The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

AFP


Specialists had been monitoring the glacier since 2013. In September 2019, they observed faster movement, and Miserocchi said the rate had “significantly increased.” The observations helped identify a potential hazard but could not pinpoint when the unstable section would detach. NASA’s contemporary account described the glacier’s front moving as much as 50 centimetres a day by late September, following the exceptionally warm summer.


In 2017, about 50 cubic meters of ice fell from Planpincieux, while in September 2018 a mass of ice broke away from the Glacier de la Charpoua, on the south-east side of the Aiguille Verte, on Mont Blanc's French side.


The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

AFP


Miserocchi’s order came into force and included the evacuation of homes and mountain refuges in the area. The action was described as precautionary and focused on the affected area of Val Ferret. Selected homes, refuges and access routes were treated differently from the wider resort: the warning did not mean that all of Courmayeur or the whole Mont Blanc massif was being evacuated.


The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

Reuters


The warning coincided with wider public concern about shrinking glaciers. In September 2019, environmental campaigners held a “mourning ceremony” for Switzerland’s Pizol glacier, which was reported to have lost about 90 percent of its volume since 2006. The ceremony used a familiar ritual of loss to draw attention to a long-term physical change in the mountain landscape. In August 2019, a similar event was held at a glacier in Iceland.


The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

According to The Guardian, the summer heatwave across Europe is also said to have accelerated the melting speed.



The 2019 Planpincieux Glacier Warning Near Mont Blanc

A roadblock in Courmayeur, Aosta, Italy, Photograph: Flavio Lo Scalzo/Reuters

Movement is not the same measurement as melting

The warning concerned a potentially unstable portion of Planpincieux glacier above the Courmayeur area. Monitoring how quickly ice moves helps specialists assess instability, but movement and melt are not interchangeable measurements. A glacier can deform, slide and fracture while also gaining or losing mass. Planpincieux is a hanging glacier, with its front on a steep slope. As NASA explains, blocks can detach as ice moves toward the edge and then fall toward the valley. That geometry helps explain why a change in movement prompted concern about the area below, rather than simply adding another measurement of how much ice had melted. The uncertainty about exactly when a break might occur was central to the precautionary response.

The warning in its September 2019 setting

The September 2019 closures were protective measures linked to observations made at that time. A mountain warning has a location, a date and a defined area of concern; those details allow residents and visitors to understand what the authorities were responding to. Later conditions require later observations, rather than an assumption that the same warning remains in force. Fondazione Montagna Sicura’s monitoring work provides the appropriate institutional context for this story. The monitoring brings two timescales into the same story. Repeated measurements can track movement over days, while satellite comparisons reveal changes across decades. NASA’s account paired Landsat views from August 1985 and August 2019 to show the broader retreat around Mont Blanc. Neither timescale replaces the other: long-term loss explains a changing landscape, while local observations help authorities respond to a developing hazard. The 2019 event illustrates why both are needed when interpreting news about a glacier above a travelled valley. Fondazione Montagna Sicura.

COMMENTS