
Istock
In July 2019 Tanzania's government announced that its elephants and rhinos were recovering after years of devastating poaching. According to the presidency, elephant numbers had climbed from 43,330 in 2014 to more than 60,000, and rhinos from 15 to 167 in about four years. The elephant figures fit a real turnaround in poaching pressure, but the rhino baseline was disputed, and neither number was an independent census. Here is what was claimed, what lay behind it, and how to read wildlife recovery figures.
What Tanzania announced in 2019
The statement came from the office of then President John Magufuli, shared by his spokesman Gerson Msigwa, and was widely reported by Reuters, Al Jazeera and others on 10 July 2019. It credited a national anti-poaching task force, set up in 2016, with reversing the decline. In the presidency's words, "elephant populations have increased from 43,330 in 2014 to over 60,000 presently."
The rhino claim was more dramatic: just 15 animals in 2015, rising to 167. The government did not publish a detailed survey report alongside the announcement, so journalists could only repeat the totals.
Tanzania says elephant, rhino populations rebounding after anti-poaching crackdown https://t.co/GWkNFSrwIi pic.twitter.com/eatpFQ4jqI
— Reuters Top News (@Reuters) July 13, 2019
How bad the poaching crisis had been
The low starting point is the most solid part of the story. A national census released in 2015 found that Tanzania's elephant population had fallen from roughly 110,000 in 2009 to just over 43,000 in 2014, a loss of more than 60 per cent in five years. Conservation groups blamed organised poaching for ivory.
The Selous Game Reserve in the south, once home to the largest elephant population on Earth with about 109,000 animals in the 1970s, was hit hardest. By 2013 it held about 13,000. UNESCO placed the reserve on its list of World Heritage in Danger in 2014.
Tanzania holds most of East Africa's elephants, so its losses shaped the whole region. East Africa's elephant numbers fell by around 62 per cent between 2006 and 2013, mainly to poaching. Across the continent, the WWF estimated that Africa had lost about 110,000 elephants in a decade, leaving roughly 415,000.
The crackdown: task force and the "Ivory Queen"
The 2016 task force brought police, wildlife rangers, intelligence and prosecutors together to target trafficking networks rather than only the hunters in the bush. Ivory demand from China and Vietnam had pushed poaching to an industrial scale, and the people moving tusks out of Africa were often far from the elephants.
The best-known result was the case of Yang Fenglan, a Chinese businesswoman in Dar es Salaam nicknamed the "Ivory Queen". Arrested in 2015, she was sentenced in February 2019 to 15 years in prison for leading an organised trafficking gang that smuggled tusks from more than 350 elephants to Asia, about 1.9 tonnes of ivory valued at roughly 5.4 billion Tanzanian shillings (about US$2.7 million). Two Tanzanian co-defendants received the same sentence, and she lodged an appeal.
China's domestic ivory trade ban, which took effect at the end of 2017, also cut into demand during the same period, so the task force was not the only factor at work.
The rhino numbers do not quite add up
The rhino figures need more care. The Independent reported at the time that figures cited by CITES, the convention that regulates trade in endangered species, put Tanzania's rhinos at about 133 in 2015, not 15. Going from 133 to 167 is steady progress. Going from 15 to 167 would be an elevenfold rise in four years, which is very hard for a slow-breeding animal.
Black rhinos usually give birth to a single calf every two to three years, so populations grow slowly even when protected. A large jump is more likely to reflect better counting, a different survey area, or animals moved in from elsewhere. Tanzania has received black rhinos from conservation programmes abroad, including translocations from South Africa and from zoos in Europe.
Tanzania's rhinos are eastern black rhinos, a subspecies now found mainly in Kenya, Tanzania and Rwanda. The species as a whole is classed as Critically Endangered by the IUCN, not merely Endangered, after numbers crashed from around 70,000 in the late 1960s.
The rhinos are making a comeback! 🦏https://t.co/THzt8gvdcf
— Global Citizen (@GlblCtzn) July 15, 2019
Why ivory and horn drive poaching
Elephants are killed mainly for their tusks, which are carved into ornaments and jewellery. Rhinos are killed for their horns, which are used in traditional medicine and increasingly bought as a status symbol in parts of Asia.
It is worth clearing up a common myth. Rhino horn is made of keratin, the same protein as fingernails and hair. Save the Rhino and medical researchers agree that it has no proven medicinal value, and the idea that it works as an aphrodisiac is false. International commercial trade in rhino horn has been banned under CITES since 1977.
Wildlife also matters to Tanzania's economy. Tourism is the country's main earner of foreign currency, bringing in about $2.5 billion in 2018, according to the government, and around a third of the country's land is set aside for conservation.
How to judge a wildlife comeback claim
Conservationists welcomed the news but urged caution. Mark Jones of the Born Free Foundation was reported as saying that a great deal of work remained to protect Tanzania's elephants and rhinos. A few questions help separate a genuine trend from a good headline:
- Who counted? Independent aerial surveys, such as those by Tanzania's wildlife research institute with outside partners, carry more weight than a single political statement.
- Same method, same area? Comparing surveys that cover different parks or use different techniques can create or hide a trend.
- Births or transfers? For rhinos especially, animals brought in from other countries can inflate apparent growth.
- What else changed? Market bans, prices and enforcement in buyer countries affect poaching as much as patrols on the ground.
There were other tensions too. The same government pressed ahead with a large hydroelectric dam at Stiegler's Gorge inside the Selous, criticised by the IUCN for flooding a large area of the reserve. Part of the Selous was later turned into Nyerere National Park.
The fair conclusion is that Tanzania did push back hard against ivory trafficking after 2015 and that elephant losses slowed. The exact size of the rebound, especially for rhinos, was never independently confirmed in 2019, and later surveys are the right yardstick for how lasting the recovery has been.
Sources: Al Jazeera: Elephant, rhino populations rise in Tanzania (10 July 2019); Wikipedia: Yang Fenglan; Wikipedia: Selous Game Reserve; Wikipedia: African bush elephant; Wikipedia: Black rhinoceros; Save the Rhino: Poaching for rhino horn; Born Free Foundation.

COMMENTS