Originally published 2019-09-11.

On 1 and 2 September 2019, Michael Pintard, then the Bahamas' Minister of Agriculture and Marine Resources and the member of parliament for Marco City, rode out Hurricane Dorian in his home on Grand Bahama. The short video he recorded, showing grey seawater churning past his windows, became one of the defining images of the storm. Pintard estimated that the storm tide at his house reached 20 to 25 feet (roughly 6 to 7.6 metres), an estimate later cited in summaries of the hurricane.
His clip was only one of many. As Dorian crawled over the northern Bahamas, residents, politicians and news outlets shared footage of flooded living rooms, submerged airports and families sheltering in attics. Here is what those videos showed, how strong Dorian really was, and why it caused the worst disaster in the country's recorded history.
What Pintard's video showed
The footage is simple and frightening. Filmed from inside the house, it shows water that has already risen to window height, with waves slapping against the frames and debris drifting past. There is no street, no garden and no horizon, only moving water where the neighbourhood should be.
The clip spread quickly on Twitter on 2 September 2019, when a Bahamian commentator shared it with a note identifying the minister and his constituency. That original post, along with several other videos shared from the same account that day, has since been removed from X, so only the text survives below. The account later shared clips from other Grand Bahama residents, flagging clearly that he had not filmed them himself.
Minister of Agriculture and Marco City MP Michael Pintard, who lives on Grand Bahama, showing some utterly frightening footage of his home during the passage of Hurricane Dorian. pic.twitter.com/gugVsLMroB
— Travis C-Carroll (@TravisCC) September 2, 2019
(This post is no longer available on X.)
* I do not own this video nor did I take it. The images and videos out of Grand Bahama are getting worse. pic.twitter.com/lnQvmHz1SJ
— Travis C-Carroll (@TravisCC) September 2, 2019
(This post is no longer available on X.)
Pintard's experience mattered partly because of who he was. A cabinet minister in a solid house is better placed than most residents to weather a hurricane. If his home could take on that much water, the outlook for families in lower-lying, lighter-built homes on Grand Bahama and the Abaco Islands was far worse.
How strong Hurricane Dorian was
Dorian made landfall on Elbow Cay and Great Abaco on 1 September 2019 as a Category 5 hurricane, then struck Grand Bahama early on 2 September at nearly the same strength. At its peak it carried one-minute sustained winds of about 185 mph (295 km/h), with gusts estimated above 220 mph. Its minimum central pressure was around 910 millibars.
Some early reports described Dorian as the most powerful storm on the planet. That was an exaggeration. What can be said with confidence is narrower but still remarkable:
- It was the strongest hurricane to hit the Bahamas since reliable records began in 1851.
- Its landfall winds tied the 1935 Labor Day hurricane for the highest sustained winds recorded at landfall in the Atlantic, a mark later matched by Hurricane Melissa in 2025.
- It is the only storm on record to strike Grand Bahama at Category 5 strength.
The name Dorian was retired by the World Meteorological Organization in 2021, so no future Atlantic hurricane will carry it.
Why it did so much damage: the stall and the surge
Wind speed alone does not explain the destruction. After reaching Grand Bahama, Dorian almost stopped moving. It sat just north of the island for roughly a day, and the same communities endured hurricane-force winds for at least 24 hours. Category 5 winds affected a single land area for about 22 hours, the longest such spell recorded in the Atlantic basin.
A slow storm also keeps pushing seawater ashore. Storm surge of up to 23 feet was reported in the northern Bahamas, and much of Grand Bahama sits only a few metres above sea level. That is why so much of the footage shows water, not flying debris: whole neighbourhoods filled like basins, and the water had nowhere to drain while the storm stayed parked overhead.
This is also why a hurricane's category can be misleading. The Saffir-Simpson scale describes sustained wind speed. It says nothing directly about how high the sea will rise at a particular house, which depends on the shape of the coastline, the depth of the water offshore, the storm's size and, crucially, its forward speed.
Calls for help, attics and rooftops
As the water rose, emergency lines in the northwestern Bahamas were overwhelmed. The Weather Channel reported that officials were advising trapped residents to find anything that floats and to use hammers to break out through their roofs if water reached their attics. That advice reflects a grim reality of surge flooding: people who climb into an attic to escape rising water can become trapped there.
Find floatation devices and use hammers to escape your attics through the roof, officials in the northwestern Bahamas reportedly tell residents as they become overwhelmed with distress calls. More: https://t.co/e9ujsvGTmH pic.twitter.com/2vUrkZbNmA
— The Weather Channel (@weatherchannel) September 2, 2019
Hurricane Update: Iram Lewis,
— Dem House Leader (@kionnemcghee) September 2, 2019
Member of Parliament,
Central Grand Bahama sent me this video of Freeport International Airport: FPO pic.twitter.com/oDPIJXBnP9
* I do not own this video, nor did I take it. A resident on Grand Bahama shows the horror unfolding inside his home during Hurricane Dorian. pic.twitter.com/lJ2GQDBTrG
— Travis C-Carroll (@TravisCC) September 2, 2019
(This post is no longer available on X.)
Other videos showed Grand Bahama International Airport in Freeport under water, sent by local MP Iram Lewis, and water pouring through the windows of occupied homes. Rescue crews could not safely reach many neighbourhoods until the storm finally began to move away to the north on 3 September.
The human and economic toll
The full cost took months to measure. A damage assessment by the Inter-American Development Bank and the UN Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, published in November 2019, put the total impact at about US$3.4 billion, more than a quarter of the Bahamas' annual GDP. Abaco took 87% of the losses and 76% of the physical damage, and housing was the hardest-hit sector. The report counted 29,472 people whose homes or property were damaged.
By February 2020, 74 deaths had been confirmed in the Bahamas, 63 on Abaco and 11 on Grand Bahama. Hundreds more were listed as missing: 282 in the months after the storm and still around 245 in August 2020. The true death toll will probably never be known. Rumours of thousands of deaths circulated at the time, but those figures were never verified.
In the first week, the United Nations estimated that at least 70,000 people on Grand Bahama and Abaco had been left homeless. Seawater contaminated wells, making clean drinking water an urgent need. Cruise lines, aid agencies and foreign governments brought in water, food and supplies, and thousands of people were evacuated to Nassau and Florida.
What the footage teaches about hurricanes
Videos like Pintard's are powerful because they make an abstract warning concrete. A forecast that says "life-threatening storm surge" is easy to underestimate. A clip of the sea rising to a minister's windows is not.
A few lessons stand out for anyone living on a hurricane coast:
- Take surge warnings as seriously as wind warnings. Water has historically caused a large share of hurricane deaths, and it can rise very quickly.
- Watch the forward speed. A slow or stalling storm prolongs both the wind and the flooding, even if its category drops.
- Plan an escape route upward and outward. If you must shelter in place in a flood-prone area, avoid a sealed attic without a way to get onto the roof.
- Follow official evacuation orders. Local emergency managers know which areas flood first.
The Bahamas has spent years rebuilding Abaco and Grand Bahama, and the recovery has been slow and uneven. The footage from September 2019 remains a record of how quickly an ordinary home can be overwhelmed, and of how much depends on warnings being heard and acted on.
Sources: Wikipedia, Hurricane Dorian; Inter-American Development Bank, November 2019: Damages and other impacts on Bahamas by Hurricane Dorian estimated at $3.4 billion; videos shared on X by Travis C-Carroll, The Weather Channel and Kionne McGhee.

COMMENTS