
© UNICEF/UNI207440/Chalasani
On 23 September 2019, sixteen children and teenagers from twelve countries, including Swedish activist Greta Thunberg, filed a formal complaint with the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child. They argued that five countries, Argentina, Brazil, France, Germany and Turkey, were violating children's rights by failing to cut greenhouse gas emissions fast enough. The case is known as Sacchi et al. v. Argentina et al., after Argentine petitioner Chiara Sacchi.
Two years later, in October 2021, the committee threw the complaint out on procedural grounds because the children had not first gone to court in the countries concerned. But in doing so it accepted a principle that climate lawyers still cite: a country can be responsible for harm its emissions cause to children living beyond its borders.
Who filed the complaint
The sixteen petitioners were aged between 8 and 17 when they filed. They came from countries on the front line of climate change as well as wealthy ones, and each described a specific way the crisis was affecting them. Among them were:
- Greta Thunberg of Sweden, who had started the school strike for climate in 2018;
- Chiara Sacchi of Argentina, whose name the case carries;
- Ridhima Pandey of India, who had already taken climate action in the Indian courts;
- Deborah Adegbile of Nigeria, who described asthma attacks worsened by heat and air pollution;
- Ellen-Anne of Sweden, a Sámi girl whose family's reindeer herding is threatened by changing winters;
- David Ackley III, Litokne Kabua and Ranton Anjain of the Marshall Islands, whose low-lying islands face rising seas.
The children were represented by the international law firm Hausfeld and the environmental legal group Earthjustice. They announced the case at a UNICEF press event in New York on the same day as the UN Climate Action Summit, where Thunberg gave her widely shared "How dare you" speech.
What the children argued
The complaint relied on the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the most widely ratified human rights treaty in the world. The petitioners said the five states were failing to protect several of their rights under it:
- the right to life (Article 6);
- the right to the highest attainable standard of health (Article 24);
- the right of indigenous children to enjoy their culture (Article 30);
- the principle that a child's best interests must come first (Article 3).
They asked the committee to find that climate change is a children's rights crisis, that each respondent was contributing to it, and to recommend that the states change their laws and policies to cut emissions faster, work with other countries on binding action, and give children a voice in climate decisions.

© UNICEF/UNI207440/Chalasani
Why those five countries and not the US or China
A common question at the time was why the complaint skipped the world's two biggest emitters. The answer is about which doors were legally open, not who pollutes most.
Children can only bring a complaint to this UN committee against a country that has accepted a separate treaty, the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on a communications procedure. Argentina, Brazil, France, Germany and Turkey had all done so, and they were also G20 economies and parties to the Paris Agreement. The petitioners argued that none of them had commitments consistent with keeping warming well below 2°C.
China has ratified the main convention but not the complaints protocol. The United States is the only UN member state that has never ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child at all. Neither could be named. Some early coverage implied that both had refused the same treaty; in fact their positions are different, and in both cases the obstacle was the complaints mechanism.
The 2021 decision: rejected, but with a landmark finding
In decisions published in October 2021, the committee declared all five complaints inadmissible. Under the protocol, people must normally use the courts in the country concerned before turning to the UN, and none of the sixteen had brought a case in Argentina, Brazil, France, Germany or Turkey. The committee was not persuaded by their arguments that domestic courts would be too slow, ineffective or blocked by state immunity.
The more important part came before that. On jurisdiction, the committee adopted a test drawn from a 2017 advisory opinion of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. When climate harm crosses borders, it said, children can fall under the jurisdiction of the state where the emissions came from, if there is a causal link between the emissions and the harm, the harm was reasonably foreseeable, and the state has effective control over the sources of those emissions. It found that states' power to regulate emissions gave them that control, and that the global nature of climate change does not cancel each country's own responsibility.
In other words, the children lost on procedure but won an argument of principle. The committee also wrote an open letter to the petitioners thanking them for bringing the case.
The climate strikes around the complaint
The complaint came in the middle of the largest climate protests the world had seen. On Friday 20 September 2019, organisers estimated that more than four million people joined strikes in some 150 countries, and a second round followed on 27 September. Estimates for the whole week ranged from around six million to 7.6 million participants.
In Washington DC, activists including Extinction Rebellion tried to block traffic on Monday 23 September under the banner Shut Down DC, timed to coincide with the UN summit in New York.
I’m in downtown DC where climate activists with Extinction Rebellion have blocked the intersection of K and 16th streets with a big sailboat that says “rebel for life.” @WTOP @WTOPtraffic #ShutDownDC pic.twitter.com/NWIO1aRvM3
— Alejandro Alvarez (@aletweetsnews) September 23, 2019
Climate is not the only environmental crisis
Some commentators at the time argued that a focus on carbon risks crowding out other problems, such as plastic pollution and the loss of wildlife. That concern is fair, but the issues are closely linked. The 2019 global assessment by the UN biodiversity panel IPBES warned that around one million animal and plant species face extinction, and it named climate change as one of the main drivers, alongside changes in land and sea use, direct exploitation and pollution. Cutting emissions, protecting habitats and reducing waste work best together rather than in competition.
The Sacchi case is part of a growing wave of climate litigation brought by young people, from national courts to regional human rights bodies. Its lasting effect is the committee's finding on cross-border responsibility, which future petitioners can build on, provided they take their case through national courts first.
For more on the young activist at the centre of the case, read Greta Thunberg's speech at the UN Climate Action Summit.
Sources: EJIL:Talk!, 20 October 2021 (Aoife Nolan): Children's rights and climate change at the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child; University College Cork, Youth Climate Justice case law database: Sacchi et al. v. Argentina et al.; Wikipedia, September 2019 climate strikes; photos © UNICEF/Chalasani; tweet by Alejandro Alvarez; originally reported by Truth Theory.

COMMENTS