
In early 2019, Reddam House, a private school in Sydney's eastern suburbs, took iPads and e-books out of its classrooms and went back to printed textbooks. The principal said students themselves had asked for the change, finding paper easier to learn from and screens full of distractions. The decision made headlines around the world, but what does the evidence actually say about tablets versus paper in school? In short: printed text tends to have a modest edge for understanding what you read, heavy computer use in class has not been shown to raise test scores, and the best results seem to come from using technology selectively rather than everywhere.
What Reddam House changed and why
The move was first reported by the Sydney Morning Herald at the end of March 2019. Reddam House removed both iPads and electronic textbooks from classroom use and returned to hard-copy books. According to the reports, the push came from students, who said the devices got in the way of learning and that they absorbed material better from paper.
Principal Dave Pitcairn pointed to two things. First, notifications and messages on the devices pulled students' attention away from the work. Second, students found it easier to move around a physical book, flip back to an earlier chapter and take notes alongside it. "The ease of navigation through the textbook was easier with the hard copy," he said, adding: "I believe they learn better the more faculties they use, the more senses they use in research and reading and making notes."
Earlier reports, repeated by several websites, said the school had used tablets for around five years and that its senior years had never fully dropped printed books. We could not confirm those details from the original coverage, so treat them as unconfirmed.
Not everyone agreed. Psychologist Michael Carr-Gregg, a parenting expert on Australian breakfast television, called the move a strange policy, arguing that children need digital skills for the future and that the real answer is balance rather than a ban. A parent of a Year 8 student, on the other hand, welcomed the change.
A short history of tablets in the classroom
Apple launched the first iPad in 2010, and within a few years schools around the world were buying them in bulk. Tablets promised lighter schoolbags, interactive textbooks, instant access to information and a way to prepare children for a digital workplace. Some education systems even rolled out a device for every student.
Early enthusiasm often ran ahead of evidence. In Quebec, a large study by the Canada Research Chair on Technologies in Education surveyed about 6,000 students in grades 6 to 10 who used iPads, along with 302 teachers. It found that students mostly used the devices to read electronic textbooks and PDFs, take notes and search online. But about a third admitted playing games in class, more than three-quarters of their use outside class was social or entertainment rather than homework, and 70% of teachers said they had rarely or never used an iPad before it arrived in their classroom. The researchers concluded the tablets had real potential, but only with proper teacher training.
What the OECD found about computers and test scores
The most widely quoted evidence comes from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Its 2015 report Students, Computers and Learning analysed results from the 2012 PISA tests, which assess 15-year-olds in reading, mathematics and science across dozens of countries.
- Countries that had invested heavily in information technology for schools showed no noticeable improvement in reading, mathematics or science.
- Students who used computers at school a little more than average did somewhat better than those who never used them, but those who used them a lot did significantly worse, even after accounting for background.
- Technology did not narrow the gap between advantaged and disadvantaged students.
- Across OECD countries, 72% of students used a desktop, laptop or tablet at school.
Andreas Schleicher, the OECD's director for education and skills, called the results disappointing and said schools needed to "find more effective ways to integrate technology into teaching and learning." He noted that high-performing East Asian school systems had been cautious about giving students access to computers, using technology mainly to support good teaching rather than replace it. The report also found that some uses, such as collaborative projects and quick quizzes that show teachers what students have understood, were linked to better outcomes.
Paper or screen: what reading research says
The Reddam House students' instinct that paper helps them learn has research behind it. A 2018 meta-analysis by Pablo Delgado and colleagues, published in Educational Research Review, pooled 54 studies from 2000 to 2017 with more than 170,000 participants. It found that people understood texts better on paper than on screens.
The effect was small but meaningful: the authors estimated it at roughly two-thirds of the reading progress a typical primary-school child makes in a year. Three details stand out:
- Time pressure matters. The paper advantage was larger when readers had a time limit and much smaller when they could read at their own pace.
- Text type matters. Paper helped with informational texts, the kind found in textbooks, but made no difference for stories.
- It is not going away. Contrary to expectations that "digital natives" would close the gap, the paper advantage grew slightly over the years studied.
One common explanation is that people tend to skim on screens, while physical books give a sense of place, such as where on a page or how far through the book something appeared, that helps memory. Notifications and the pull of other apps add further distraction.
Common myths about screens and students
Myth: blue light from tablets permanently damages children's eyes. The American Academy of Ophthalmology says there is no scientific evidence that blue light from digital devices damages the eye. Long screen sessions can cause digital eye strain, mainly because people blink less, but it does not cause lasting harm. The academy recommends the 20-20-20 rule: every 20 minutes, look at something about 20 feet away for 20 seconds. Screen light late in the evening can make it harder to fall asleep, so cutting screens before bed is sensible.
Myth: more technology automatically means more learning. The OECD findings show the opposite can happen when devices are used heavily without a clear teaching purpose.
Myth: technology has no place in school. The same research found that moderate, well-planned use can help, and digital skills matter for later life. The question is how devices are used, not whether they exist.
Claims that tablets cause depression, addiction or other health problems in children are much debated. Research on screen time and wellbeing is mixed and often shows associations rather than cause and effect. If you are worried about a child's mood, sleep or behaviour, talk to a doctor.
What parents and schools can take from this
- Match the tool to the task. Printed books suit deep reading and study; devices can be better for research, collaboration, practice quizzes and creative projects.
- Cut the distractions. If tablets are used, turning off notifications and limiting which apps open in class removes much of the problem principals describe.
- Train the teachers. The Quebec study and the OECD both found that technology works better when teachers are confident using it.
- Ask the students. At Reddam House the change came from students' own experience, and they are often the best judges of what helps them learn.
Reddam House did not reject technology outright; it decided that, for textbooks, paper simply worked better for its students. The research so far suggests that kind of selective, evidence-based choice is more sensible than going all-digital or banning screens altogether.
Sources: Starts at 60, 2 April 2019: School ditches "distracting" iPads (citing the Sydney Morning Herald); Education Week, September 2015: More technology doesn't mean more learning; MobileSyrup, December 2013: Quebec iPad study; Delgado et al. (2018), Educational Research Review: Don't throw away your printed books; American Academy of Ophthalmology: Should you be worried about blue light?. First reported on this site via Healthyfoodhouse.com.

COMMENTS