Half a Billion Bees Died in Brazil in 2019: What Happened and Why

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-08-24.

Brazil's Reported Bee Losses in 2019 and the Pesticide Concern

Between December 2018 and February 2019, beekeepers in four southern and central Brazilian states reported that more than 500 million honeybees had died. An investigation by the Brazilian outlets Agência Pública and Repórter Brasil linked most of the deaths to farm pesticides, especially the insecticide fipronil and the neonicotinoid family. Both are tightly restricted in the European Union because of the risk to bees. The losses came as Brazil was approving new pesticide products faster than at any time in years.

Here is what was reported, what the evidence shows, why it matters beyond Brazil, and what helps bees.

What beekeepers reported

The figure of half a billion came from a survey of beekeeping associations and local reports, gathered by Agência Pública and Repórter Brasil and later published in English by Mongabay and summarised by Bloomberg. The losses by state were reported as:

  • Rio Grande do Sul: about 400 million bees, roughly 80% of the total;
  • Santa Catarina: about 50 million;
  • Mato Grosso do Sul: about 45 million;
  • São Paulo: about 7 million.

Beekeepers described hives that looked healthy one day and were full of dead and dying bees the next. Some said whole colonies collapsed within two days of showing symptoms. Salvador Gonçalves, who led the beekeepers' association in Cruz Alta, said crops near his hives were sprayed from aircraft in the morning and the bees were dead by the afternoon.

Two points help keep the number in perspective. First, it is a total built from beekeepers' reports for specific places and months, not a count of every bee in Brazil. Second, it covers only managed honeybees. Brazil has more than 300 native bee species, many of them stingless bees, and nobody tracks their losses. The true damage to pollinators may therefore be larger, but it is unmeasured.

What killed the bees

Laboratory tests on samples from Rio Grande do Sul pointed clearly at insecticides. In a study of 30 cases of colony loss in the state, about 80% of the bees tested had been exposed to fipronil. Neonicotinoids also turned up.

Fipronil is a broad-spectrum insecticide used on crops such as soy, maize and sugar cane, and also in some flea treatments for pets. It is highly toxic to bees. In 2013 the European Food Safety Authority found a high acute risk to honeybees when it was used as a maize seed treatment, and the EU restricted its use on maize and sunflowers that year. The US Environmental Protection Agency classifies it as a "possible human carcinogen" (Group C), based on thyroid tumours in rats. No human data were available at the time.

Neonicotinoids are systemic insecticides. They move into a plant's pollen and nectar, which is how bees encounter them. After two years of partial restrictions, EU member states agreed in April 2018 to ban outdoor use of the three main neonicotinoids (imidacloprid, clothianidin and thiamethoxam), with the ban taking effect at the end of that year. Only use in permanent greenhouses remained allowed.


Brazil's pesticide boom

Brazil is one of the world's largest agricultural exporters and one of its biggest users of pesticides. Approvals of new products had been rising for several years before the bee deaths:

  • Under President Michel Temer, approvals rose 46% in 2017, and 2018 brought 450 new products, a 13-year high.
  • After Jair Bolsonaro took office in January 2019, 290 new pesticide products were registered in roughly the first seven months. The tweet above says this was up 27% on the year before.
  • Greenpeace's investigative unit Unearthed found that of more than 1,200 pesticides and weedkillers registered over about three years, 193 contained chemicals banned in the EU.
  • Unearthed also reported that almost half of the products approved in Bolsonaro's first months contained active ingredients on the Pesticide Action Network's list of highly hazardous pesticides.

Other figures that circulated at the time, such as a 770% rise in pesticide use since 1990 and residue results from the health regulator Anvisa, came from secondary reporting that we could not trace to an original dataset. They are best treated as unconfirmed. The approval numbers above come directly from Unearthed's analysis of official registrations.

Why it matters for food, not just honey

Bees are the most important group of crop pollinators. According to the international science panel IPBES (2016), about three-quarters of the world's leading food crops benefit at least partly from animal pollination, worth an estimated $235 to $577 billion a year. Around 60% of crop species rely on animals for pollination, including most fruits, many vegetables, nuts, coffee and cocoa.

Staples such as wheat, rice and maize are wind-pollinated, so a world without bees would not starve outright. Its diet would become poorer and more expensive, though, with less fruit, fewer vegetables and less of the vitamin A and folate they provide. Modelling studies warn of exactly that.


The tweet above repeats two popular figures. "80% of flowering crops" is an overstatement. The better-supported estimate is the IPBES figure of about 75% of leading crops benefiting to some degree. The "$14 billion" refers to an older Cornell University estimate of honeybee pollination in the US, so it is dated but not made up.

Pesticides are one part of a bigger picture

Scientists studying pollinator decline name several pressures acting together:

  • Pesticides, especially neonicotinoids and other systemic insecticides;
  • Habitat loss, as wild flowers and nesting sites give way to farmland that grows a single crop;
  • Parasites and diseases, notably the varroa mite in honeybees;
  • Climate change, which shifts flowering times and ranges;
  • Pollution and invasive species.

Blaming one cause for every loss is usually too simple. The Brazilian case is unusual because the timing, the spraying reports and the lab results all pointed the same way. Globally, managed honeybee hive numbers have actually risen, driven by countries such as China and Argentina. Demand for pollination has grown much faster, though, and many wild bee species are declining. One global analysis found bee species records fell by about a quarter in 2006 to 2015 compared with before 1990.

What helps bees

  • Better pesticide rules: restricting the chemicals most toxic to bees, banning spraying while crops are in flower, and limiting aerial spraying near hives.
  • Warning systems: some farmers and beekeepers agree on spraying schedules, so hives can be closed or moved in time.
  • More flowers and nesting space: WWF and others have urged that unused land, field edges, parks and urban green spaces be managed for pollinators, with native flowering plants that bloom across the seasons.
  • In your own garden: grow a mix of native flowers, leave some bare soil and dead stems for nesting, provide shallow water, and avoid insecticides, especially on plants in bloom.
  • Support monitoring: citizen science bee counts help fill the gap left by untracked wild species.

The Brazilian bee deaths were a stark local event, but the questions they raised are global. How fast should new pesticides be approved? How should farmers and beekeepers share the same land? And how much is pollination worth to the food we take for granted?

Sources: Mongabay / Agência Pública and Repórter Brasil, Half a billion bees dead as Brazil approves hundreds more pesticides; Unearthed (Greenpeace), Brazil pesticide approvals; Wikipedia, Fipronil; Wikipedia, Neonicotinoid; Wikipedia, Pollinator decline.

COMMENTS