Vietnam Children Carried Across a River in Plastic Bags to School

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

In September 2018, photos from Vietnam's mountainous north showed adults sealing children inside large plastic bags and towing them across a swollen, muddy stream so they could get to school. The children lived in Huoi Ha, a village in Na Sang commune, Muong Cha district, Dien Bien province, and the water they had to cross was the Nam Chim stream.

The images came from Vietnam's national broadcaster, Voice of Vietnam (VOV), and were shared around the world the following year. The short answer to what was going on: in the dry season a simple wooden bridge served the village, but from roughly June to October the stream rose too high and fast for it, and families used rafts or, at the worst moments, the plastic-bag method. According to VietNamNet, about 40 primary and secondary pupils from the village boarded at school during the week and went home at weekends, so each crossing mattered.

This is not a clever hack to admire. It was a dangerous last resort caused by missing infrastructure, and the story is really about access to education. Below, each photo is explained, along with what officials promised, what is known about the outcome and why safe routes to school matter so much.

The crossing, photo by photo

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

On the bank, two men open a large clear plastic bag for a boy in a red football shirt while mothers and younger children watch from the slope behind. The bag is meant to keep the child and his school things dry and to trap air so he floats.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

A villager in a green pith helmet hauls a bamboo raft along a rope stretched across the flooded stream, with a woman carrying a backpack standing behind him. Rope-guided rafts like this were the usual way across when the water was high but still manageable.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

A girl in a white blouse with an embroidered shoulder bag and a boy in red stand on a bamboo raft above the brown water. Their stillness says a lot: one slip into a current this strong could be fatal.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

At a calmer side channel, a man fills a plastic bag with a child while four young children watch from a boulder. Parents, not teachers, usually did the carrying, according to the district chairman quoted by VietNamNet.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

The view from inside: a boy crouches in the bag and looks up at the camera. It is the image that made the story impossible to forget, because it shows how small and exposed the children were.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

Chest-deep in the flood, a man swims while pushing a sealed bag ahead of him; a child's red clothing and shoes are visible inside. The knot at the top keeps water out and air in, but nothing protects against debris or a sudden surge.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

A still from VOV's video report: two men lower a child in a red shirt into the bag at the water's edge, among slippery boulders.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

Another frame from the video shows a man wading through fast brown water with the bag in his arms, far from either bank. The camera angle makes clear how wide the stream becomes in the rainy season.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

Near a large rock, a man drags the bag through churning water toward the shore. The rocks that make a handhold for the adult can also strike or snag a floating child.

Vietnam’s River-Crossing Schoolchildren: The Need for Reliable Access

Even after the crossing, the journey was not over: three girls with school backpacks walk down a muddy mountain track. VietNamNet's report described the road to the school in Na Sang's commune centre as many kilometres long, which is why pupils stayed at school during the week.

Why the stream became impassable

Dien Bien sits in Vietnam's far north-west, along the borders with Laos and China. It is steep, forested country where small streams react fast to heavy rain. Between about June and October the region's monsoon rains can turn a stream you could wade in spring into a fast, muddy river within hours, and temporary bamboo or wooden bridges are often washed away.

In August 2019, almost a year after the photos, the Vietnamese outlet VTC News reported that the temporary bridge at Huoi Ha had been gone since early June that year. Adults were swimming across with their belongings wrapped in plastic bags, and children were reportedly no longer allowed to make the crossing at all.

Floodwater is dangerous even for strong swimmers. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention advises against walking, swimming or driving through floodwater, which can hide debris and move far faster than it looks. A child in a bag cannot see, steer or escape if the bag tears or fills with water.

What officials promised, and what is confirmed

The photos prompted a quick official response. VTC News reported that on 27 August 2018 a project management board of the Vietnam Road Administration surveyed the site with Dien Bien's transport department and found it met the criteria of LRAMP, the World Bank-supported Local Road Asset Management Program. The plan was a three-span concrete bridge about 72 metres long and 3.5 metres wide, and the Ministry of Transport told the province to move quickly.

By August 2019, however, the commune chairman, Vang A Po, said the target of finishing before that year's rainy season had been missed, and locals had been told work would happen in the dry season. We could not confirm from a reliable source when, or whether, a permanent bridge was finished at Huoi Ha, so any claim that the problem has been solved should be treated as unverified.

There is a precedent nearby. In 2014, after a video of a teacher and children crossing the Nam Po stream in plastic bags went viral, Vietnam opened a 100-metre steel suspension bridge at Sam Lang village in the same province within a couple of months, Tuoi Tre News reported. A local woman of 68 told the paper it was the first time in her life she had seen such a strong bridge.

The video and the online reaction

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

When the photos spread internationally in 2019, thousands of people commented. Many offered help or reflected on their own lives; some questioned the method. A selection:

Here are some reactions to this dangerous method of crossing the river

A Facebook commenter from a university group called Engineers in Action asked who to contact about building a bridge. With nearly ten thousand reactions, it was the most popular reply and shows how quickly the story turned from shock to wanting to help.

Here are some reactions to this dangerous method of crossing the river

A reader wrote that the photos made her appreciate everyday conveniences and hoped funding could be found for a bridge, a common theme in the responses.

Here are some reactions to this dangerous method of crossing the river

A commenter from South-East Asia pushed back against outsiders mocking the families, saying the photos showed real hardship faced by people working to improve their living conditions.

Here are some reactions to this dangerous method of crossing the river

Another reply reflected on luck and gratitude, noting that not everyone in the world has safe roads and bridges.

Here are some reactions to this dangerous method of crossing the river

A shorter comment called the method smart under the circumstances. It is resourceful, but the people using it knew the risks and wanted a bridge, not praise for improvising.

Why a safe route to school matters

Stories like this are a reminder that school attendance is not only about classrooms and teachers. In remote areas, the road, the bridge and the weather decide whether a child can get there at all. When the only way across a river is dangerous, families face an impossible choice between a child's safety and their education, and absences pile up during exactly the months when school is in session.

Vietnam has invested heavily in rural roads and footbridges, including through the LRAMP programme, but mountain provinces like Dien Bien still have many small crossings that flood each year. Boarding arrangements, like the weekly stays the Huoi Ha pupils used, help reduce the number of trips but do not remove the need for a safe way home.

If you want to help with problems like this, the most useful route is usually through established organisations that build and maintain rural footbridges with local authorities, rather than one-off appeals that are hard to verify.

Sources: Photos: VOV (Voice of Vietnam); comment screenshots from Facebook. VietNamNet, 7 September 2018; VTC News, 3 August 2019 (Vietnamese); Tuoi Tre News, May 2014: Sam Lang bridge; CDC: floodwater safety.

COMMENTS