Why Female Moorland Hawker Dragonflies Play Dead to Avoid Males

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published July 30, 2019.

Yes, some female dragonflies really do "play dead" to get away from males. The best-documented case involves the moorland hawker (Aeshna juncea), a large dragonfly of ponds and bogs. In a study published in 2017, Swiss-based biologist Rassim Khelifa described females that, when chased by a male, suddenly stopped flying, dropped to the ground, landed on their backs and lay still until the male gave up and left. Then they flipped over and flew away.

Death-Feigning in Female Moorland Hawker Dragonflies

It sounds like a punchline, and the story was often told as one online. The real behaviour is more interesting than the joke. It is a rare, measurable tactic in what biologists call sexual conflict: a situation in which what is good for a male in a mating encounter is not what is good for the female. Here is what the researcher saw, why the females may do it, and what the finding does and does not tell us.

What the researcher actually observed

Khelifa, then at the University of Zurich, first noticed the behaviour while collecting dragonfly larvae at ponds in the Swiss Alps. Out of the corner of his eye he saw a female fleeing a male and then plummeting to the ground as if she had been killed. She had not. Once the male flew off, she came back to life.

He then watched more closely. According to the summary of the paper published by Phys.org, he recorded 31 cases in which a male pursued a female in the wild. In 27 of them the female dropped and feigned death, and the trick worked 21 times: the male lost interest and the female escaped. In the remaining six cases the male was not fooled and seized her anyway. National Geographic, reporting on the same study, noted that every female that did not fake death was intercepted by a male.

The results were published in the journal Ecology under the title "Faking death to avoid male coercion: extreme sexual conflict resolution in a dragonfly". It was the first time the behaviour had been described in any dragonfly.

Meet the moorland hawker

The moorland hawker, also called the common hawker or, in North America, the sedge darner, is a big insect: roughly 7.4 centimetres long, with a brown body and paired coloured spots along the abdomen. It lives across a huge belt of the Northern Hemisphere, from Ireland through Europe and Asia to Japan, and in northern North America. Adults fly from early summer into autumn, usually around boggy pools, upland lakes and heaths.

Like other dragonflies, it spends most of its life underwater as a larva, hunting small aquatic animals, before climbing up a plant stem and emerging as a winged adult. The adult stage is short, so a female has a limited window in which to lay her eggs. Anything that wastes that time, or injures her, matters a great deal for how many offspring she leaves behind.

Why would a female fake her own death?

Dragonfly mating is not a gentle affair. A male grabs a female behind the head with claspers at the tip of his abdomen, and the pair form the familiar "wheel" shape. Khelifa put it bluntly to National Geographic: "In a lot of dragonflies, males try to seize the female with or without consent."

Several details make the moorland hawker a special case:

  • Timing. The death-feigning happened when females had just finished laying eggs or were heading back to lay. At that point they have usually already mated and stored sperm, so another mating adds little for them.
  • No male protection. In many dragonflies a male guards the female after mating so rivals cannot get to her. Male moorland hawkers do not. The female lays her eggs alone, which leaves her open to repeated harassment.
  • Risk of harm. Males in this group can remove a rival's sperm, and forced mating can injure a female's reproductive tract. Harassed females can also be hurt or end up in the water. For an insect with a short adult life, that cost is serious.
  • Crowded breeding sites. Males far outnumbered females at the ponds Khelifa watched. He suggested that heavy male pressure may help explain why such an extreme tactic appears.

Females also use a quieter strategy: they lay eggs deep in dense vegetation, where males struggle to find them. When Khelifa removed some males from a site, females became more willing to lay in open spots, which supports the idea that avoiding males shapes their behaviour.

Playing dead elsewhere in the animal world

Feigning death, known to scientists as thanatosis or tonic immobility, is common in nature, but it is usually aimed at predators. Opossums, hognose snakes, many beetles and some frogs go limp when attacked. Many predators are triggered by movement and prefer live prey, so a motionless body can earn the victim a chance to escape.

Using the same trick against a would-be mate is much rarer. National Geographic noted that only a handful of species were known to practise "sexual death feigning" at the time, among them a spider and a praying mantis. The dragonfly case stood out because the female drops from flight, a fall that is itself risky, which hints at how costly unwanted mating must be.

Common misunderstandings about the study

"Female dragonflies always do this"

Not so. The observations come from one species at study sites in the Alps, and from a modest number of encounters. Khelifa suggested the tactic may exist in other species where females lay eggs unguarded, but that remained to be tested. The finding shows the behaviour exists; it does not show that every female, or every dragonfly species, uses it.

"They are just not in the mood"

Comparing the dragonfly to a person who claims to be too tired is a fun hook, but it hides the biology. Insects do not make the kind of choices people make about relationships. The behaviour is better understood as an evolved response that, on average, protects a female's ability to lay eggs and survive.

"It always works"

It does not. In about one in five of the recorded cases where a female feigned death, the male still grabbed her. Dropping out of the sky is a gamble, not a guaranteed escape.

Why this small discovery matters

Field observations like this one are a reminder that even familiar insects still hold surprises. Dragonflies have been studied for centuries, yet no one had formally described this response before 2017. Careful watching, rather than expensive equipment, was what revealed it.

The study also adds to a large body of research showing that mating is often a tug of war between the sexes, with each side evolving ways to tip the balance. Male claspers and sperm removal on one side, hiding in vegetation and feigning death on the other, are moves in that long evolutionary game.

If you live near a boggy pond or moorland lake, late summer is a good time to watch hawkers patrolling over the water. Seeing a female suddenly drop and lie still would be lucky, but now you will know what you are looking at.

Sources: Khelifa (2017), Ecology; Phys.org; National Geographic; Wikipedia: Aeshna juncea.

COMMENTS