FaceApp Privacy in 2019: A Licence to Your Photos, Not Ownership

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published July 30, 2019.

FaceApp's 2019 Privacy Debate: Image Licenses Are Not Ownership of a Face

rawpixel

In July 2019 FaceApp, a photo editor that could make anyone look decades older, went viral for the second time. Celebrities posted their wrinkled future selves, millions of people joined in, and then a wave of headlines claimed the app now “owned” the faces of more than 150 million people. That claim was wrong in an important way. FaceApp’s terms gave the company a very broad licence to use what users uploaded; they did not transfer ownership of anyone’s face or photos.

The difference matters, but so does the underlying worry. A licence that wide is a real privacy trade-off, and the episode is still one of the best examples of why it pays to read what an app asks for before tapping “accept”. Here is what the terms said, what the company and security researchers said, and what you can check on your own phone.

What FaceApp is

FaceApp was created by Wireless Lab, a small company in St Petersburg, Russia, founded by former Yandex executive Yaroslav Goncharov; it is now run by FaceApp Technology Limited, registered in Cyprus. It launched on iOS in January 2017 and on Android shortly after. The app uses neural networks to change a face in a photo: adding a smile, swapping hairstyles, changing apparent gender or, most famously, adding age.

It had already been controversial before 2019. In 2017 a “hot” filter was found to lighten skin tones, and a set of “ethnicity” filters was pulled within days after criticism. Goncharov apologised and blamed bias in the training data.

By mid-2019 FaceApp was reported to have passed 100 million downloads on Google Play and was briefly the top app in the iOS App Store in many countries. Download totals, however, are not the same as the number of unique people whose photos were processed, so the widely shared “150 million faces” figure was always an estimate.

What the terms actually said

The 2019 terms of service stated that users kept ownership of their content. In the same breath they granted FaceApp a “perpetual, irrevocable, nonexclusive, royalty-free, worldwide, fully-paid, transferable sub-licensable license” to use it. The licence covered reproducing, modifying, publishing, distributing and displaying user content, along with any name, username or likeness connected to it, in any media, without paying the user.

In plain terms: you still owned your selfie, but the company had permission to do almost anything with it, forever, and to pass that permission on. That is very broad, yet it is not unusual. Many social networks and photo apps have used similar wording, mostly so they can store, process and display what you upload without legal risk. The question is less what the words allow in theory than what the company actually does, and how much you trust it.

These were the terms in force during the 2019 controversy. Apps update their terms regularly, so anyone deciding today should read the current version rather than rely on old quotes.

The company’s response and what researchers found

As criticism grew, FaceApp issued a statement. It said photos were processed in the cloud on Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud, that only the picture a user chose to edit was uploaded, and that most images were deleted from its servers within 48 hours. “We never transfer any other images from the phone to the cloud,” the company said, according to TechCrunch. It also said it did not sell or share user data with third parties, that user data was not transferred to Russia even though its research team was there, and that users could request deletion through the app’s support menu.

At the height of the scare, some people claimed the iOS app quietly uploaded a user’s entire camera roll. A former Rackspace manager, Rob La Gesse, warned that the app needed access to all photos and could keep working in the background. Security testing reported at the time did not support the bulk-upload theory: researchers found no evidence that FaceApp sent anything other than the selected photo. Granting an app permission to see your photos is not the same as the app copying them all.

In the United States, Senator Chuck Schumer nonetheless asked the FBI and the Federal Trade Commission to look into the app, citing its Russian origins and national-security concerns. The request reflected political worries about foreign data access rather than proof of misuse.

Why the worry was still reasonable

Even without bulk uploads, people had reasons to think twice. Face images are biometric data: unlike a password, you cannot change your face if it leaks. A broad, permanent licence means you are trusting the company’s behaviour, not the contract, to protect you. And the Facebook and Cambridge Analytica scandal of 2018 had shown that data gathered for one purpose can end up being used for very different ones.

Data breaches are another risk. Any company that stores personal data, even briefly, can be hacked, and stolen images can be used for scams or impersonation. That applies to every photo app, not just FaceApp.

Licence versus ownership: a quick guide

  • Ownership means you hold the copyright in your photo. Under most terms of service you keep it.
  • A licence is permission to use your content. It can be narrow (only to provide the service) or broad (any use, any media, forever).
  • “Irrevocable” and “perpetual” mean you may not be able to withdraw that permission later, even after deleting the app.
  • “Sub-licensable” and “transferable” mean the company can pass rights on to others, such as partners or a future buyer.
  • Your likeness is also protected separately in many countries by privacy and data protection laws, such as the EU’s GDPR, which can give you a right to have data deleted regardless of what a contract says.

How to protect your photos when using any app

  • Grant limited photo access. Recent versions of iOS and Android let you share only selected photos instead of your whole library. Use that option whenever an app offers it.
  • Read the licence section. Search the terms for words like “perpetual”, “irrevocable” and “sub-license” to see how broad the permission is.
  • Check the privacy policy for retention. Look for how long uploads are kept and how to request deletion.
  • Review background permissions. Turn off background refresh and location for apps that do not need them.
  • Think before uploading other people’s faces. Your friends did not agree to the app’s terms.

FaceApp’s 2019 moment was mostly a lesson in reading carefully, for app users and for headline writers alike. The company never owned anyone’s face, but users did hand over far more permission than most of them realised.

Sources: Header image: rawpixel. Wikipedia: FaceApp; TechCrunch: FaceApp responds to privacy concerns, July 2019; 9to5Mac, July 2019; FaceApp terms of service (current version).

COMMENTS