
In late May 2019, screenshots began circulating of Facebook posts by a man in Tucson, Arizona, who said he was photographing the licence plates of everyone visiting the city's Planned Parenthood health centre. His stated plan was to identify the visitors and go to their homes to talk to them about abortion. The posts were shared by a pro-choice satire page, Planned Parenthood Baby Parts Emporium, and drew thousands of comments within days.
Photographing a car in a public place is generally legal in the United States. Turning a number plate into a home address is a different matter, because federal law tightly restricts who can get personal details from motor vehicle records. Showing up uninvited at a patient's door also raises obvious questions of harassment and safety. That is why so many people, including some who described themselves as opposed to abortion, reacted with alarm.
Below are the screenshots that spread online, each with context, followed by what the law says and what the clinic actually does. The man is identified in the screenshots by the name on his Facebook account; none of the claims have been tested in court, and we found no mainstream news report confirming the outcome.
The posts that started it
The first images are the profile picture and statements that set off the reaction.

This selfie was the profile photo attached to the posts. It was reproduced widely as the story spread, which itself shows how quickly a person's image can travel once a post goes viral.


The Baby Parts Emporium page published its warning on 28 May. It said the man was photographing plates and people at the clinic, and that, when contacted, Tucson police had described it as a non-issue they could not act on yet.
The second half of the post urged Tucson residents to stay alert and watch for anyone following or photographing them. The post was shared more than 5,000 times and gathered over 3,000 comments.

In this comment the man confirmed the plan in his own words: he was photographing plates so he could visit people at home. He also claimed police were comfortable with his protest, warned critics against violence, and then dared anyone who wanted to escalate to go ahead. Several readers saw that final line as inviting trouble rather than discouraging it.
How commenters reacted
Most of the replies fell into three groups: people who answered with donations, patients describing the care they had received, and people pointing out practical or legal problems with the plan.


One commenter said she was making a donation to Tucson's Planned Parenthood in his name, a protest tactic sometimes called "pledge a picketer". It was one of the most-liked replies, with more than 2,000 reactions.
Another claimed the Tucson centre did not offer abortions at all. We could not verify that claim, and it should be treated with caution: services differ from one Planned Parenthood centre to another, and Arizona's abortion rules have changed several times. Confident statements like this spread easily in fast-moving comment threads.



A woman who said she does not support abortion made a point many others echoed: opposing abortion does not give anyone the right to harass patients. She explained that she had used the clinic for birth control and routine women's health checks, and learned there that she was pregnant with her first son.
Another woman said the clinic helped diagnose her polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and pointed her towards treatment, and noted that it also serves men with condoms and STI testing.
A third recalled getting nappies, baby food and clothes there when her children were young and money was tight, as well as birth control. Practical help of that kind has varied between centres over the years, but her memory shows how differently patients see the clinic from the man outside it.


This commenter cited the often-quoted claim that abortion makes up only about 3% of Planned Parenthood's work. That figure counts individual services, not patients; in the organisation's 2023 report, abortions were about 4% of more than nine million services. Critics argue that a share of patients would be higher, so the number is best read with that caveat.
Next, a commenter imagined the man's research leading him to boxes of nappies, condoms, tampons and baby formula. Her point was that he would soon discover how much of the clinic's work has nothing to do with abortion.



Some replies turned the idea around, suggesting people follow and photograph him to show how it feels. Most readers recognised the point was rhetorical, and the commenter added that the law should cut both ways.
The next comment, from a woman who said she had once dated him, was a personal jab that we will not repeat here. It was among the most-liked replies, which says a lot about the mood of the thread, but mockery of a private person adds nothing to the facts.
Another reader suggested that everyone visit the clinic, so that he would be overwhelmed by plates to photograph. It was a light-hearted way of saying that intimidation only works when people feel alone, and that a crowd of ordinary visitors makes surveillance pointless.
Can a licence plate lead to a home address?

This commenter raised the key practical question. In the United States, the Driver's Privacy Protection Act of 1994 bars state motor vehicle departments from releasing drivers' personal information except for specific purposes, such as law enforcement, insurance, court cases and some licensed investigators. Obtaining that data under false pretences or for an unlawful purpose is itself illegal, and anyone who helped him through a work account could face both criminal and civil liability.
The law was passed after the 1989 murder of actress Rebecca Schaeffer, whose killer found her address through a private investigator who obtained it from motor vehicle records. Its history is a reminder of why lawmakers decided plate lookups should not be available to just anyone.




The first of these replies was a joke about his relationship status. Like much of the thread, it used humour to deflate a plan that many readers found frightening.
One woman said his plan only made her want to visit the clinic, so that he would come to her house and she could set him straight. Her tone was playful, but it reflects how many patients refused to be intimidated.
Another reader pointed out that Planned Parenthood is a major provider of birth control. Many people photographed in the car park, in other words, would simply be collecting a prescription.
A final comment in this group summed up a common feeling: patients should be able to pick up their contraception in peace. It is a simple expectation that most people, whatever their politics, would share.
What the police said

This screenshot shows a private message exchange between a Facebook user and the Tucson Police Department's page. The user flagged the posts as dangerous; the department's reply asked where he was posting so it could look. The user also shared a screenshot of another post calling for a "human wall" outside the clinic on Monday 3 June to stop women from entering.
Blocking a clinic entrance is not a grey area. The federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act of 1994 makes it a crime to use force, threats or physical obstruction to interfere with people getting or providing reproductive health care. Peaceful protest, leaflets, signs and counselling remain legal.



One user said they had already been in touch with Tucson police, who would be monitoring both the man and the original thread. We could not independently confirm what action, if any, followed.
Another commenter announced a further donation to Planned Parenthood in his honour. Turning a protester's campaign into funding for the very clinic he targets has become a familiar response online.
The last comment argued that every person he photographed should press charges. Whether charges would be possible would depend on what he actually did with the photos, but the instinct reflects a real principle: patients' privacy is protected for good reason.
Protest, privacy and where the line sits
Abortion is one of the most divisive issues in the United States, and people on every side have the right to make their case in public. The comments above show that many people who oppose abortion still draw a firm line at following patients home. Health centres serve people for contraception, cancer screening, STI testing and pregnancy care, so anyone photographing a car park is also recording people who came for entirely different reasons.
If you are ever worried about being followed or photographed near a clinic, tell the clinic staff, keep a note of what happened and, if you feel at risk, contact the police. Many health centres also have escort volunteers who can walk patients from their cars.
Sources: Screenshots as shared by the Facebook page Planned Parenthood Baby Parts Emporium and collected by Bored Panda; Planned Parenthood: our services; Wikipedia: Planned Parenthood (service statistics); Wikipedia: Driver's Privacy Protection Act; Wikipedia: Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act.

COMMENTS