
In June 2019 the American science-fiction author Mary Robinette Kowal posted a Twitter thread about the time she found a lump in her breast while living in Iceland. With no referral, no appointment and a fee of a few dollars, she walked into the cancer centre in Reykjavík and had an examination, a mammogram, an ultrasound and an answer in about 45 minutes. In the United States, she wrote, a similar lump had taken two weeks and three separate office visits.
The thread drew more than 100,000 likes on its first tweet and thousands of replies, many from Americans describing long waits and large bills, and some from people in countries with universal coverage describing the opposite. Below is the thread in order, with context for each part, followed by a look at how Iceland's system works and what one personal story can and cannot tell us.
Who Mary Robinette Kowal is

Kowal, born in 1969 in Raleigh, North Carolina, began her working life as a professional puppeteer, performing with the Center for Puppetry Arts and Jim Henson Productions. She spent two seasons in Iceland working on the children's programme LazyTown, which is when the events in the thread took place.
She is better known today as a novelist. The Calculating Stars, the first of her Lady Astronaut books, won the Nebula Award and the Hugo Award for Best Novel, and she served as president of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America from 2019 to 2021. That profile is part of why the thread travelled so far.
The thread, step by step

She opened with the moment she found the lump and asked her show's production manager how to find a doctor. His answer was simply to go to the cancer centre, and he did not know what a referral was.

After she explained the idea of a referral, he gave her the centre's phone number. When she called, the staff told her to come in, and again seemed puzzled by the word "referral".

Appointments were possible if her schedule was busy, but not required. The nurse's reasoning was simple: she had found a lump, she knew her own body, so she should come in.

At the desk she was told that, as a non-Icelander, she would have to pay for the visit. Her name was called almost as soon as she sat down. She later corrected the price she gives here (see below).

A nurse examined her, agreed there was a lump and suggested a mammogram straight away. The machine, it turned out, was just across the hall.

About twenty minutes after arriving she was having a mammogram on a machine with warmed plates, a detail she clearly appreciated. The nurse wanted a closer look and led her next door for an ultrasound.

After the scan she dressed and returned to the waiting room, only to be called back almost at once with the result: a cyst, nothing more.

This is the heart of the thread. From walking in to having an answer took about 45 minutes. In the US, a similar lump had meant two weeks and three appointments, and she said she thinks of the contrast whenever she has to fight with American insurance.

A light postscript: she used her surname in the dialogue, but in Iceland, where people go by first names and patronymics rather than family names, staff almost certainly called her by her first name.

The next morning she corrected herself. The fee was 300 krónur, not 3; she had got used to dropping a decimal place in her head. At 2006 exchange rates that was still only around four US dollars, so her point stood.
Replies from the United States

One of the first replies came from a woman told after a routine check that her thyroid levels were dangerously low. It took two weeks to see a specialist and the first follow-up slot offered was eight months away.

Kowal answered with her own family's story. Her husband's surgeon wanted to operate quickly on severe carpal tunnel syndrome to avoid nerve damage; insurance approval took six months, and the damage became permanent.

Kelly Gregory wrote that she found a breast lump in 2009, while living in Nashville, while unemployed and uninsured because of a pre-existing condition. Finding someone to see her took three months.

By then the lump was large. Planned Parenthood moved her case along quickly, she wrote, but tests showed the cancer had spread: stage IV metastatic breast cancer, which is treatable but not curable.

She added that she was nearing nine years as a metastatic patient and expected the disease eventually to take her life, which she linked to the years she went without access to care in her late thirties.

Kowal's response was short and furious, a measure of how hard the replies were hitting even the author of the thread.

A man named Matt described losing his youngest sister, aged 25, to synovial sarcoma, a rare soft-tissue cancer, after symptoms first mistaken for an ovarian cyst. She went through treatment, remission and recurrence.

He wrote that she died four days after doctors spoke of her condition "slowing down", and that he arrived two hours too late to say goodbye because no one explained what that phrase meant.

The one mercy, he said, was that she was still a student on their father's insurance. Even so, the family was left with debt that his father was still paying off instead of planning for retirement.
Bills, ambulances and comparisons abroad

A reply about Italy: a mother who collapsed on holiday in Rome spent two days in an emergency department with blood tests, CT, MRI and ultrasound. When the family asked about billing, they were told there was nothing to pay.

The contrast came straight back from an American who collapsed at home, had similar tests, and was billed about $16,000 plus $1,400 for a three-mile ambulance ride. She kept her sense of humour about the hospital's wine list.

A woman in a small Kentucky town said a rear-end crash left her with an ambulance bill of more than $10,000 for a trip of under a mile, and that the other driver's insurer refused to pay.

The reply that followed joked that for that money she could have flown to New Zealand and been treated there. Surprise ambulance bills became a national issue in the US; the federal No Surprises Act of 2022 covers many out-of-network hospital bills but not ground ambulances.

From Britain, a man described collapsing at work in 2010 with a large kidney tumour, followed by seven weeks in hospital, surgery, three years of experimental chemotherapy and nine years of monitoring. He said he paid nothing, because the NHS is free at the point of use.

The last reply here made a wider argument: universal healthcare is the norm across wealthy Western democracies, and the United States is the notable exception.
How Iceland's healthcare system works
Iceland's system is mostly paid for through taxes, which cover roughly four-fifths of health spending; the rest comes from patient fees. Fees exist, as Kowal found, but they are modest, and children, older people and disabled people pay less or nothing. Private health insurance is almost non-existent and there are no private hospitals.
Under a 1973 law every resident registers with a primary care centre and a general practitioner, but, as the thread shows, people can also go directly to specialist services. The main hospital, Landspítali, is in Reykjavík, alongside a network of regional hospitals and health centres run by the central government. In a 2017 study in The Lancet on access to and quality of healthcare, Iceland ranked second in the world.
Some caution is fair. Iceland has fewer than 400,000 people, which makes some things simpler, and like other public systems it has waiting lists for planned surgery and pressure on staff. One quick visit in 2006 does not describe the whole system, and Americans with good insurance can also be seen quickly. What the thread captured is the absence of paperwork and the low price at the moment someone was frightened.
What the story means for anyone who finds a lump
Kowal's lump was a cyst, and many breast lumps turn out to be harmless. That is no reason to wait. Kelly Gregory's replies show what delay can cost. Family history matters, but most people diagnosed with breast cancer do not have a close relative with the disease, so a lack of family history is not a reason to skip a check.
The practical advice is short: if you notice a new lump or change in your breast, talk to a doctor promptly. If cost is the barrier, community health centres, Planned Parenthood clinics and state breast and cervical cancer screening programmes in the US can offer low-cost or free examinations.
Sources: Mary Robinette Kowal on Twitter (thread of 3–4 June 2019); Wikipedia: Mary Robinette Kowal; Wikipedia: Healthcare in Iceland; maryrobinettekowal.com.

COMMENTS