
Alma-Jade Chanter spent years on a strict raw vegan diet and says it left her with brittle teeth, ridged nails, aching joints and missed periods. In 2019 she told the agency PA Real Life that switching to the opposite extreme, an all-animal "carnivore" diet built around organ meats, brains, bone marrow and bone broth, made her feel better than she had in years. Her story went viral, partly because her favourite food is brain.
Her experience is real to her, but it is one person's account, and it says more about the risks of any very restrictive diet than about meat or plants. Below we look at what happened to her, what the carnivore diet actually is, and what the research says so far about its benefits and its risks.
From slaughterhouse videos to raw veganism
According to her interview, Alma-Jade was 13 when she watched undercover footage from slaughterhouses and factory farms. Disturbed by what she saw, she stopped eating all animal products. Within about a year she had gone further and was living on uncooked fruit and vegetables only.
For her, raw veganism became an identity as much as a menu. She travelled to raw-food and fruit festivals abroad and spent time with people who shared the same ideals. That community aspect is common in strict diet movements of every kind, from raw veganism to carnivore, and it can make it harder to change course when the body starts sending warning signs.
The warning signs she says she ignored

Alma-Jade Chanter in a mirror selfie shared with her story. Photo: PA Real Life, via LADbible.
Her parents grew worried, and a doctor told the family that her diet was short of essential vitamins and minerals and could cause lasting harm. She has admitted she did not listen. In her words, she was so dogmatic and hard-headed
that she put all her faith in the supposed benefits of what she was eating. She tried fasting and juice cleanses instead.
The symptoms she lists are consistent with long-term undernutrition:
- Missed periods. Periods often stop when the body is not getting enough energy or key nutrients.
- Ridged nails, thinning hair and joint pain. She put these down to poor calcium intake; low protein, iron and zinc can also play a part.
- Damaged teeth. She describes a dentist visit at which a front tooth broke because the enamel had worn away. Frequent fruit sugar and fruit acids erode enamel, especially when combined with low calcium.
In 2013 she was diagnosed with Graves' disease, an autoimmune condition in which antibodies push the thyroid gland to make too much hormone. It is the most common cause of an overactive thyroid and is far more common in women than men. Its exact cause is not known; genes, smoking, stress and infections are among the suspected factors. There is no good evidence that a vegan diet causes it, or that any diet cures it, so her diagnosis and her diet should be seen as two parts of her story rather than cause and effect.
The switch to meat, organs and brains

Poached lamb brain and liver, finished with sea salt: a typical plate in Alma-Jade's current diet. Photo: PA Real Life, via LADbible.
She says that once she accepted that her diet was making her ill, she slowly reintroduced animal foods. Her digestion needed several months to adjust to meat again. After that she added more fish and meat, and she reported that her thyroid function, hair and joints improved, though she still had flare-ups of pain and tiredness.
A friend then pointed her to Shawn Baker, a former orthopaedic surgeon who promoted an all-meat diet on social media from 2018 and wrote the book The Carnivore Diet. She moved to two meals a day of muscle meat, liver, heart, brain, animal fat and marrow, with bone broth for calcium. She told interviewers that organ meat gives her everything she needs, including vitamin C. Liver and some other organs do contain a little vitamin C, but whether the amounts are enough over years is one of the open questions researchers raise about the diet.
Her views on factory farming have not changed. She buys meat only from local farmers and butchers, and argues that if an animal is killed, the respectful thing is to use all of it, organs included.
What the carnivore diet is

Cuts of meat in a butcher's display. Photo: Pixabay.
The carnivore diet, sometimes called "zero carb", allows only animal foods: meat, fish, eggs and, for some followers, dairy. A stricter version known as the "lion diet" allows only beef, salt and water. The idea is not new. In the 19th century, writers and doctors such as James Salisbury promoted meat-based regimens, and some physicians prescribed animal-only diets to people with diabetes before insulin existed.
Supporters often point to traditional Inuit diets, but those also included plants gathered from the land, as well as a lot of seafood and raw organ meat, so they are not a direct match for a modern steak-and-butter plan.
What the research shows so far
The evidence base is small and mostly weak:
- The 2021 survey. The largest study, published in Current Developments in Nutrition, surveyed 2,029 adults following a carnivore diet. They reported high satisfaction and few side effects, and their average BMI fell from 27.2 to 24.3 over about 14 months. But every result was self-reported, and LDL ("bad") cholesterol was clearly raised.
- Criticism of that survey. Researchers from Liverpool John Moores, Leeds and Surrey universities pointed out that participants were recruited from online carnivore communities, that people on the diet for less than six months were excluded, and that the dietary questionnaires had not been validated. People who felt unwell and quit were unlikely to be counted.
- A 2026 review. A scoping review in Nutrients that pulled together nine studies found some improvements in metabolic markers, but rated the evidence as mostly low quality and flagged a consistent risk of deficiencies in vitamins C and D, calcium, magnesium and iodine.
The biggest structural problem is fibre. An all-animal diet contains none. A major 2019 analysis in The Lancet, drawing on 185 prospective studies and 58 clinical trials, found that people who ate the most fibre had a 15–30% lower risk of death from all causes and from heart disease than those who ate the least. Diets very high in red and processed meat are also linked with a higher risk of bowel cancer and gout, and raised LDL cholesterol is an established risk factor for heart disease.
Common myths on both sides
- "Her recovery proves meat heals." One person feeling better after leaving a diet that was clearly too narrow does not show that the new diet is ideal. Almost any change that restores protein, calcium and calories could help someone who was undernourished.
- "Vegan diets are inherently dangerous." Major dietetic bodies say a well-planned vegan diet can be healthy at every life stage, provided it includes vitamin B12 and enough protein, calcium, iron and iodine. A diet of raw fruit alone is a very different thing.
- "You can't get scurvy on meat." Fresh organ meats and raw meat contain small amounts of vitamin C, but cooked muscle meat contains very little. Researchers still list vitamin C as a nutrient of concern.
Practical takeaways
The lesson most experts would draw from Alma-Jade's story is about extremes. She moved from one diet that cut out whole food groups to another that does the same. Ethical concerns about factory farming are serious and widely shared, and there are many ways to act on them, from buying higher-welfare meat to eating a varied, well-planned plant-based diet.
If you are thinking about a major change to the way you eat, especially if you have a thyroid condition, a history of eating problems or other health issues, talk to a doctor or a registered dietitian first. Blood tests can show whether you are short of key nutrients, and a professional can help you build a pattern of eating that fits both your health and your values.
Sources: Interview with Alma-Jade Chanter by PA Real Life, published by LADbible (photos); ZOE: Does the carnivore diet really work?; Wikipedia: Carnivore diet; Wikipedia: Graves' disease; meat display photo from Pixabay.

COMMENTS