Humpback Whale Breaches Behind a Fishing Boat in Monterey Bay

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

In spring 2019 a humpback whale burst out of Monterey Bay, California, directly behind a small sport-fishing boat, and two people on a nearby vessel caught the moment from different angles. Photographer Douglas Croft took the still frames and whale watcher Kate Cummings filmed the video. In the pictures the whale seems to tower over the angler, as if it is about to land on him. In fact it was some distance behind the boat, and nobody was hurt. Here is how the images were made, why the whale looks so enormous, and what humpbacks are doing when they launch themselves out of the water.

A Humpback Breach Beside a Fishing Boat in Monterey Bay

What happened in Monterey Bay

The breach happened during salmon season, when hundreds of small boats head out onto the bay. That timing overlaps with the return of humpback whales, which come to Monterey Bay in spring and summer to feed on krill and schooling fish such as anchovies. Large numbers of anglers and large numbers of whales in the same water make sightings like this more likely.

The whale in the photos had already breached several times further away. Humpbacks often breach in a series, so observers who had seen the first jumps were watching for the next one. The fishing boat, reportedly named Baja Sueno, happened to be in its path. The angler on board can be seen standing near the stern as the whale rises out of the sea behind him.

A Humpback Breach Beside a Fishing Boat in Monterey Bay

The first frame of the sequence: the whale’s head and pleated throat clear the surface behind the boat while its long pectoral fins begin to swing outward.

How the photographs were made

The striking angle was deliberate. After watching the earlier breaches, Croft went below deck and photographed through a porthole close to the waterline. Shooting from almost sea level means the camera looks up at the whale, which makes it loom against the sky instead of appearing as a dark shape on the water.

He also used a long telephoto lens. Telephoto lenses compress distance, making objects at different ranges appear stacked closer together than they really are. Croft himself has explained that the compression made the whale look nearer to the boat than it was. Video taken by the fishing boat’s captain from the flying bridge, he said, shows the breach was roughly 15 to 20 yards behind the boat.

The boat is closer to the camera than the whale, so normally it should look larger. That it looks so small is a fair hint at just how big the animal is. Croft joked that if he had been the fisherman, “I’d probably need some new underwear.”

A Humpback Breach Beside a Fishing Boat in Monterey Bay

At the top of the breach both pectoral fins are spread wide. On a humpback these fins can reach about a third of the body length, the longest of any whale, which is why its scientific name, Megaptera, means “big wing”.

A Humpback Breach Beside a Fishing Boat in Monterey Bay

A tighter vertical frame shows the whale’s knobbly head. The bumps are called tubercles, and each one contains a hair follicle, a reminder that whales are mammals.

Reading the moment: anticipation, not luck alone

Cummings, who filmed the breach, described how she guessed where it would happen. A whale that breaches repeatedly often travels in one direction underwater as it builds speed for the next jump. Because this one was heading toward the fishing boat, she expected the next breach to come up near it and framed her shot accordingly. Even so, she said, “I didn’t expect the whale and the boat to line up so perfectly.”

This is how much good wildlife photography works. People who spend time on the water learn to read behaviour, position themselves, and wait. The perfect alignment is chance, but being ready for it is skill.

The video shows the full sequence in real time: the whale rising, hanging for a split second, then falling back on its side with a huge splash.

Why humpback whales breach

Scientists do not have a single answer. Several explanations are discussed, and more than one may be true at different times:

  • Communication. The crash of a 30-to-40-tonne animal hitting the water is loud and travels far underwater, so breaching may signal location or status to other whales.
  • Removing parasites. The impact may help dislodge barnacles, whale lice or skin.
  • Play or excitement. Young whales in particular breach often, and the behaviour may simply be energetic play.
  • Looking around or reacting to weather. Some researchers have noted that breaching increases in rough conditions, when sound signals carry less well.

Getting that bulk out of the water takes a powerful upward sprint driven by the tail flukes. Adult humpbacks are usually around 14 to 15 metres long, and can weigh up to about 40 tonnes, so even a partial breach displaces an astonishing amount of water.

A Humpback Breach Beside a Fishing Boat in Monterey Bay

The whale twists as it falls back, a typical end to a humpback breach. The splash can be heard and seen from far across the bay.

Monterey Bay’s whales and their comeback

The humpbacks that feed off California come mainly from breeding populations that spend winter off Mexico and Central America. In summer they travel north to rich feeding grounds, and Monterey Bay, with its deep submarine canyon close to shore, is one of the best. That is why the bay has become one of the most reliable places in the world to watch whales from a boat.

Humpbacks were hunted heavily in the twentieth century. Commercial hunting of the species was banned in 1966, when the global population had fallen to a few thousand animals. Since then most populations have recovered strongly, and the IUCN Red List now classifies the humpback as Least Concern, with an estimated 135,000 worldwide. Some populations remain at risk, and two threats are particularly relevant to a scene like this one: entanglement in fishing gear and collisions with vessels.

Staying safe around breaching whales

This encounter ended well, but whales that breach close to small boats can damage them, and strikes have occasionally injured people. For anyone fishing or boating where whales feed:

  • Keep a good distance and never steer toward a whale or into its path.
  • If a whale is breaching repeatedly, assume it may come up again nearby and slow down or move away.
  • Keep fishing lines and gear tidy so they cannot snag a passing animal.
  • Follow local wildlife-viewing rules and the advice of whale-watching operators, who know the area and the animals’ behaviour.

Croft’s photograph went on to be widely shared and was featured as a photo of the day by Outdoor Photographer. Its appeal is easy to understand: it captures the sheer scale of a humpback in a single frame, with a person for comparison, at a moment that lasted only a couple of seconds.

Sources: Photos: Douglas Croft; video: Kate Cummings. Kendall Camera Club: Photo of the day by Douglas Croft; Wikipedia: Humpback whale.

COMMENTS