Originally published 2019-05-01.

In March 2019 a surgical team at Steve Biko Academic Hospital in Pretoria, South Africa, replaced the tiny bones of a patient’s middle ear with titanium copies made on a 3D printer. The University of Pretoria described it as the world’s first middle-ear transplant using 3D-printed bones, and the news travelled fast, often under headlines claiming a cure for deafness. The real achievement is narrower but still important: a new way to rebuild the sound-conducting chain of the ear for people with one particular kind of hearing loss.
Here is how the middle ear works, what Professor Mashudu Tshifularo’s team actually did, who it could help, and how it compares with treatments that already existed.
How the middle ear carries sound
Behind the eardrum sit three of the smallest bones in the body, the ossicles. The malleus (hammer) is attached to the eardrum, the incus (anvil) links it to the stapes (stirrup), and the stapes presses on the oval window, the entrance to the fluid-filled cochlea of the inner ear. The stapes is the smallest bone in the human body.
The chain works like a lever. It collects vibrations from the relatively large eardrum and concentrates them onto the much smaller oval window, raising the pressure enough to move the fluid in the cochlea. Without that boost, most sound energy would simply bounce off. If the ossicles are missing, broken, fused or disconnected, the result is moderate to severe hearing loss even when the inner ear and hearing nerve are perfectly healthy.
What conductive hearing loss is
Doctors divide hearing loss into two broad types. Sensorineural loss comes from damage to the cochlea or the hearing nerve, and is the type caused by ageing and loud noise. Conductive loss happens when sound cannot get through the outer or middle ear to reach a working inner ear.
Common causes of conductive hearing loss include:
- earwax or a blocked ear canal;
- fluid behind the eardrum, the most frequent cause in children;
- a perforated or scarred eardrum, or a cholesteatoma, an abnormal skin growth in the middle ear;
- otosclerosis, in which abnormal bone growth fixes the stapes in place;
- ossicles damaged by infection or head injury, or malformed from birth.
The Pretoria procedure targets the last group, and only when the inner ear still works. It does nothing for sensorineural loss, which is why “cure for deafness” overstated what it offers.
What the Pretoria team did
Professor Mashudu Tshifularo heads the Department of Otorhinolaryngology (ear, nose and throat) at the University of Pretoria. His approach starts with a scan of the patient’s ear. The faulty ossicles are then reproduced in titanium on a 3D printer, so the replacement matches that patient’s anatomy, and only the bones that are not working are swapped. The surgeons work through an endoscope passed along the ear canal, which avoids a larger incision behind the ear.
In its media release, the university said two patients had already benefited and that titanium was chosen because the body tolerates it well. It argued that replacing only the faulty bones carries less risk than existing prostheses, could make ossicle reconstruction during ossiculoplasty and stapedectomy simpler, and reduces the risk of damage to the facial nerve, which runs close to the middle ear.
The March 2019 operation
The publicised operation took place on 13 March 2019. Accounts of the patient differ slightly. The university’s advance notice described a patient born with an underdeveloped middle ear, while the national government’s statement the next day described a 35-year-old man whose middle ear had been destroyed in a car accident and who could hear again afterwards. It is possible that more than one patient was treated that day.
Tshifularo summed up his enthusiasm simply: “3D technology is allowing us to do things we never thought we could.” He also made clear that the work depended on money he did not yet have, appealing for sponsors to help the invention move beyond a handful of patients.
Was it really a world first?
Replacing middle-ear bones is not new in itself. Surgeons have rebuilt the ossicular chain for decades. The modern stapedectomy, in which a tiny piston replaces part of the stapes in people with otosclerosis, was first performed by the American surgeon John Shea in 1956 and has success rates of roughly 80–95%. Ossiculoplasty using ready-made prostheses of plastic, ceramic or titanium is a routine operation in many countries.
What was new in Pretoria was the use of 3D printing to produce patient-specific titanium copies of the ossicles from scans, combined with endoscopic surgery. That is a genuine step, and potentially an important one, but it is better described as a new technique for an existing type of reconstruction than as the first middle-ear transplant ever. The bones are implants, not tissue from a donor, so the word “transplant” is used loosely. Long-term published results comparing the 3D-printed approach with standard prostheses were not part of the 2019 announcements.
Who could benefit, and the cost question
According to the university, the operation can be done at any age, including on newborn babies, for conductive loss caused by birth defects, infection, injury or metabolic disease. The release also noted, citing the South African Hearing Institute, that hearing usually begins to decline from around the age of 30 or 40 and that more than half of people have significant hearing loss by 80, although most of that age-related loss is sensorineural and would not be helped by this surgery.
Tshifularo has said his goal is for the procedure to be affordable for patients in public hospitals, not only for private clinics. He describes his philosophy as “innovate or perish”, arguing that academics should build solutions for the communities around them. Then health minister Aaron Motsoaledi said the department would do everything in its power to mobilise resources and called on donors and business to support the project.
Options for people with conductive hearing loss today
Anyone with hearing loss should start with an assessment by a doctor or an ear specialist, because the right treatment depends entirely on the cause. Depending on the diagnosis, options include:
- treating infections or removing blockages such as wax;
- surgery to repair the eardrum, remove cholesteatoma or rebuild the ossicles, including stapedectomy for otosclerosis;
- conventional hearing aids, which amplify sound through the ear canal;
- bone-conduction devices, worn on a headband or implanted, which send sound through the skull straight to the cochlea.
Advances such as Pretoria’s 3D-printed ossicles may make reconstruction more precise and accessible in future, especially where surgeons can tailor each implant to the patient.
Sources: University of Pretoria media release, March 2019: UP academic pioneers world’s first middle ear transplant using 3D-printed bones; South African Government, 14 March 2019: Ear transplant done at Steve Biko Academic Hospital; Wikipedia: Ossicles; Wikipedia: Conductive hearing loss; Wikipedia: Stapedectomy

I had a eardrum transplant 58 years ago with a lambs eardrum by microscope at the mass general hospital in Boston Mass by Dr. GORSS a German doctor.
ReplyDeleteI had a whole in the top layer over the eardrum and was loosing my hearing. for years I had to have the top layer of skin taken off because it grew hair.. the operation took 9 hours by microscope, I can hear because of it. it was called a lambski
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete