ASU Lecturer Brian Goegan, MindTap Fees and the 2019 Investigation

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-05-31.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

In April 2019 Brian Goegan, an economics lecturer at Arizona State University, emailed students to say his department had made them pay for an online homework platform and had set a minimum failure rate in introductory courses. The message spread on Reddit and made national news. A month later an independent review commissioned by ASU found no evidence of the secret grant or the failure quota he described, though it confirmed that many sections did require a paid digital product to submit homework.

The story is worth revisiting because the question at its heart has not gone away: why do so many college courses require students to buy access codes just to hand in assignments, and who decides that? Below is what Goegan alleged, how the university and the publisher answered, what the investigation concluded, and what students can do when a course comes with an extra digital bill.

What Brian Goegan claimed

Goegan taught large introductory economics classes, including ECN 211 (macroeconomics) and ECN 212 (microeconomics). His contract was not renewed, and before leaving he sent a message to students that he described as a disclosure of two policies he considered unethical.

The first policy, in his account, tied the department to Cengage, the textbook publisher. He said the department had agreed to make every ECN 211 and 212 student use MindTap, Cengage's online course platform, so that the provost's office could receive a large grant from the company. Assignments that instructors had previously posted on the free campus systems, Blackboard and Canvas, were moved inside MindTap, which meant a student who did not buy access could not turn in graded homework.

The second policy concerned grades. Goegan wrote that ECN 211, 212 and 221 instructors were told to keep at least 30 percent of students from passing, supposedly to create a baseline against which a new provost-backed teaching project could later look like an improvement. In his words, students were being "set up to fail" so the project could appear to solve a problem.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

Reddit

The screenshot above shows the email as it circulated on the r/ASU forum, where a student posted it under a title mocking the university's "Most Innovative" ranking. Goegan reportedly told the Arizona Republic that he went public because he had exhausted the people he could raise the matter with inside ASU.

How ASU and Cengage responded

The university disputed both claims. Executive Vice President Mark Searle issued a statement noting that a lecturer's contract can lapse for many reasons, including, as he put it, a refusal to accept "course-correction" after supervisors raise concerns. That was a pointed reference to Goegan's own performance, which he contested.

ASU spokesperson Bret Hovell said the university had not received money from Cengage in return for adopting MindTap, and Cengage issued its own denial. Both sides agreed on one point: MindTap was indeed required in many sections, and the university had negotiated a reduced price for students.

Early versions of this story also linked the dispute to a separate report that ASU had misused federal research money. That report concerned unrelated grant accounting and has no established connection to Cengage or the economics department, so it is left out here.

What the independent investigation found

After the student government asked for an inquiry, ASU hired Ruth V. McGregor, a former chief justice of the Arizona Supreme Court, to examine the allegations. Her report, published at the end of May 2019 and summarised by EdSurge, reached three main conclusions:

  • No large grant. She reviewed Cengage's payments to the university over several years and found nothing resembling the grant Goegan described, writing that no evidence of such an agreement exists.
  • No failure quota. She found no sign that department leaders had told instructors to fail a fixed share of students to make a new program look good.
  • A real, but debatable, requirement. Many introductory sections did require both a textbook and MindTap for homework submission. Other faculty she interviewed saw that as a teaching choice rather than a moral one; she summed it up as a matter of pedagogy, not ethics.

Goegan accepted that the grant question had been answered but said the arrangement itself remained open to criticism. In other words, the most dramatic parts of the viral story, a hidden payment and deliberate failing, were not supported, while the everyday complaint behind it, paying a publisher to submit homework, was accurate.

Why the email struck such a nerve

Students reacted strongly because the cost felt familiar. Online homework platforms such as MindTap, Pearson's MyLab and McGraw Hill's Connect are standard in large first-year courses. Access is usually sold per course or per semester, often bundled with an e-textbook, and the code expires at the end of term, so it cannot be resold the way a printed book can.

Universities and publishers argue that these tools give instant feedback, automate grading for classes with hundreds of students and are cheaper than a new hardback. Critics answer that a student who cannot or will not pay is effectively locked out of graded work, and that the price is set by a deal the student had no say in. Both arguments can be true at the same time, which is why the investigation's "pedagogy, not ethics" line satisfied administrators far more than students.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

Comments like the one above were typical: many readers searched for the story, found that it was real, and treated it as proof that money drives university decisions.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

Several students described the same experience at other campuses, reporting fees of around $80 a semester just to submit math homework on top of tuition and textbooks. These are personal accounts from a public forum rather than verified price data, but they match the general complaint about access codes.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

The same set of forum replies was shared repeatedly as the story travelled across social media and news aggregators.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

Most reactions focused on tuition already being high, which made a separate charge for homework feel like paying twice.

Common misunderstandings about the case

"He was fired for finding a scam." Goegan was a non-tenured lecturer whose contract was not renewed; the non-renewal was decided months before the email went out, and ASU publicly pointed to performance concerns. There is no public finding that he was dismissed in retaliation.

"ASU was paid to fail students." The independent review found no evidence of a payment or a quota. The claim rests on Goegan's account of meetings, which the investigator could not corroborate.

"Paying to submit homework is unusual." Unfortunately it is not. Mandatory courseware is common across US higher education, and many colleges now bill it automatically through "inclusive access" schemes that add the cost to tuition unless a student opts out.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

Some replies compared the situation to the 2019 college admissions bribery scandal, which was in the news at the same time, while others joked that the affair was an economics lesson in itself. One comment contains strong language, so the image is blurred.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

Readers also noticed that Goegan had sent the message in a way that was hard to delete quickly, including prepared emails students could forward to administrators.

What students can do about required course software

If a syllabus requires a paid platform, a few steps can lower the cost or clarify your options:

  • Ask before buying. Check whether graded work truly needs the platform or whether the code only unlocks optional practice.
  • Look for a grace period. Many platforms offer a short period of free temporary access, which buys time to see if financial aid arrives.
  • Compare the bundle with the standalone code. Campus bookstore bundles are sometimes cheaper, and sometimes much more expensive, than buying access directly from the publisher.
  • Check opt-out deadlines. If your school uses automatic billing, there is usually a deadline early in term to opt out and buy elsewhere.
  • Use official channels. If you believe a fee is unfair, the dean of students, the student government or a campus ombudsperson can raise it formally, as happened at ASU.
An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

The same comment thread appeared again in later reposts of the story.

An Arizona State Lecturer's Dispute Over Paid Homework Access

The ASU episode is a useful reminder that a viral email can be partly right and partly wrong. The secret grant and the failing quota did not stand up, but the frustration of paying a publisher to hand in homework was genuine, and it is a cost worth questioning at any university.

Sources: EdSurge: Investigation finds ASU had no unethical ties to textbook publisher Cengage (30 May 2019); r/ASU post of Goegan's email and reader comments. Goegan's interview comments were first reported by the Arizona Republic (azcentral).

COMMENTS