Originally published 2019-05-11.

In April 2019 the Waorani people of Pastaza province in Ecuador won a court case that stopped the government from auctioning their land to oil companies. A three-judge panel in Puyo found that the state had not properly consulted the Waorani before offering about 180,000 hectares of their rainforest territory for oil exploration. The government appealed, and on 19 July 2019 the provincial court of Pastaza upheld the decision. The case is now seen as a key precedent for Indigenous consent in the Amazon.
Here is what the case was about, why the ruling mattered, and what it did and did not change.
Who the Waorani are
The Waorani (also written Huaorani) are an Indigenous people of the Ecuadorian Amazon, numbering only a few thousand: AFP put the figure at about 4,800 in 2019. They live mainly in the provinces of Pastaza, Orellana and Napo, between the Curaray and Napo rivers. Until the mid-20th century many Waorani groups had little contact with outsiders, and some related groups still live in voluntary isolation.
Their history with oil is long and painful. From the 1960s and 1970s onwards, oil roads and wells opened up the northern Ecuadorian Amazon, bringing settlers, logging and pollution into Waorani areas. Part of their land overlaps with Yasuní National Park, one of the most biodiverse places on Earth.
The oil auction and the 2012 consultation
In 2018 the Waorani of Pastaza learned that the government planned to offer an area known as Block 22 to oil companies. Sixteen Waorani communities live mainly inside this block. The government said the communities had already been consulted in 2012.
Waorani leaders said the 2012 process was nothing of the kind. Officials had held short meetings and, according to the court, relied on attendance sheets signed by community members as proof of agreement. People said they had not been told that signing in could later be presented as consent to oil drilling, and that they had not received clear information about the risks. In the words of the tribe's leaders, they had been tricked.
In February 2019 the Waorani announced a lawsuit. The official plaintiff was Nemonte Nenquimo, a Waorani leader. The case was filed together with the Waorani organisation CONCONAWEP and Ecuador's human rights ombudsman (the Defensoría del Pueblo), with legal support from the non-profit Amazon Frontlines.
What the court decided
The case was heard by the criminal guarantees tribunal in Puyo, the capital of Pastaza. After about two weeks of deliberation, the panel ruled for the Waorani on 26 April 2019, and the full written judgment followed in May.
The judges found that the 2012 consultation broke the Waorani's rights. They suspended the auction of their territory and ordered the state to carry out any new consultation according to the standards of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. These standards require that consultation be free, prior and informed, and done in good faith. The court also ordered an investigation into the officials responsible for the flawed process.
Lina María Espinosa, a lawyer for the Waorani, said outside court that the ruling has created a significant precedent for the Amazon
. The government appealed, arguing that the 2012 process had been valid, but the provincial court rejected that argument in July and confirmed the result.
Why Ecuador's constitution mattered
Ecuador's 2008 constitution gives Indigenous peoples strong collective rights. It describes their ancestral lands as inalienable, unseizable and indivisible
and requires prior consultation before the state exploits non-renewable resources on them. Ecuador was also one of the first countries in the world to write the rights of nature into its constitution.
There is an important limit, though. As in most of Latin America, oil and minerals under the ground belong to the state, not to the people living above them. That is why the case turned on consultation rather than ownership. The constitution does not give communities a full veto over drilling, but it does require the state to ask them properly and take their answer seriously. The Waorani won because the court agreed that this had not happened.
What the ruling did and did not do
The victory was real, but it is easy to overstate:
- It protected about 180,000 hectares (roughly 500,000 acres) of Waorani land in Block 22 from auction and drilling under the 2012 consultation.
- It set a precedent that other Indigenous nations in Ecuador can use when challenging consultations that were rushed, misleading or held without proper information.
- It did not ban oil drilling in the Amazon in general, and it does not stop the state from trying again with a new, proper consultation.
Environmental groups noted that millions of acres of Indigenous territory in Ecuador were planned for oil leases at the time. The Waorani case did not settle all of them, but it changed the rules the government had to follow.
Nemonte Nenquimo and the wider fight for the Amazon
The case made Nemonte Nenquimo internationally known. In 2020 she received the Goldman Environmental Prize and was named one of Time magazine's 100 most influential people. She had earlier co-founded the Ceibo Alliance, which links Indigenous communities in Ecuador, Peru and Colombia, and she is a co-founder of Amazon Frontlines. In 2024 she published a memoir with Mitch Anderson, We Will Not Be Saved (We Will Be Jaguars in the US).
For readers far from the Amazon, the lesson is simple. Some of the most effective forest protection comes from the people who live there, especially when courts back their rights. Supporting Indigenous-led organisations, and asking where the oil and minerals in everyday products come from, are practical ways to help.
Sources: Wikipedia: Waorani of Pastaza vs. Ecuadorian State; Wikipedia: Nemonte Nenquimo; Dawn (AFP): Amazon tribe wins first victory against oil companies (April 2019).

Yes!!
ReplyDelete