
In March 2019, the day after US prosecutors revealed the college admissions bribery scheme known as Operation Varsity Blues, a freelance writer named Jaimie Leigh posted a long Facebook message arguing that the scandal was only the crudest part of a much bigger system. She described years of paid work writing application essays, student papers, résumés and board applications for wealthy clients, and she traced how that help could follow a privileged child from admission to a corporate boardroom. The post was shared more than 31,000 times.
Her account is personal and cannot be checked line by line, but the pattern she described matches what researchers have since measured: at the most selective US colleges, money helps in many legal ways long before anyone thinks of a bribe. Here is what she wrote, the scandal that prompted it, how the criminal case ended, and what the evidence says about advantage in admissions.
The scandal that set it off
On 12 March 2019, federal prosecutors in Boston announced charges against dozens of people, including wealthy parents, college coaches and test administrators. The operation took its name from the 1999 film Varsity Blues. At its centre was William "Rick" Singer, a college consultant who ran a for-profit coaching business and a nonprofit called the Key Worldwide Foundation, through which parents' payments were passed as tax-deductible "donations."
Prosecutors said Singer used two main methods. In one, he arranged extra time on the SAT or ACT through false learning-disability paperwork, steered students to test centres where corrupt proctors could fix answers, and sometimes had a stand-in sit the exam. In the other, he bribed coaches to designate applicants as athletic recruits, complete with invented sporting records and edited photos. Parents allegedly paid him more than $25 million between 2011 and 2018. More than half of the 33 parents charged were accused of buying places at the University of Southern California; other schools named included Stanford, Yale, Georgetown, UCLA and the University of Texas.

The best-known defendants were actors. Lori Loughlin, pictured above at the Creative Arts Emmys, and her husband, the designer Mossimo Giannulli, were accused of paying $500,000 to have their two daughters admitted to USC as rowing recruits, though neither rowed competitively. Felicity Huffman was accused of paying $15,000 to have her elder daughter's SAT answers corrected.

Loughlin is shown here with her daughters and her husband. Her younger daughter, the YouTuber Olivia Jade, later left USC. Neither daughter was charged, and it remains disputed how much the children knew about what their parents arranged.
What Jaimie Leigh said in her post
Leigh, who works as a freelance writer, opened by saying the scandal surprised many people but was, in her view, small compared with what she had seen. She explained that she had spent several years taking whatever writing work came her way because she could not afford to refuse it, and that she had stopped doing this kind of work long before she posted. She also stressed that none of her current friends or clients were the people she was describing.

Her central argument was summed up in one line: "I think a lot of people seriously have no idea how thoroughly the system is rigged." The richest families, she wrote, buy influence with large donations to a university. The merely rich pay for a team instead: essay writers like her, test tutors, interview coaches, and consultants who know how to request extra exam time.


She called the result a composite. The applicant a university sees is, in her description, the combined work of every professional the parents could afford. Once the student is enrolled, she said, the same families hire writers again for coursework and theses, and she admitted to having written more student papers than she could count.


The "domino" career path she described
The most widely quoted part of the post was a step-by-step sketch of a privileged life, which she compared to a row of dominoes. A degree from an elite university, plus family contacts, leads to internships and interviews regardless of grades. An employer then supplies an executive coach and a senior mentor who teach the young hire how to dress, speak, and present a "personal brand," and who introduce them to powerful people in their city.


Next come charity work and nonprofit board seats chosen to fit that brand, followed by local awards, "40 under 40" lists and leadership programmes. Leigh added a note that some people earn those honours through genuine good work. Each step requires an application, a résumé or a biography, and she said that people like her wrote many of them.


The final domino, in her telling, is a paid seat on a corporate board, after which the cycle begins again with the next generation. Meanwhile, she argued, equally capable people lose out at every stage because they wrote their own applications and had no coach or mentor to polish them.




She ended with examples from her own work, including adult clients whose fathers phoned her to shape their "personal" letters, and a blunt conclusion: "There's no such thing as meritocracy."


How readers and celebrities reacted
The post drew thousands of comments. Many readers said it confirmed what they had long suspected, while some noted that similar advantages exist in other countries. One commenter found it credible but objected to Leigh's coarse nickname for the hypothetical rich student, and others asked whether exposing the system could change it.



Public figures joined in on Twitter the same week. The actor James Van Der Beek, star of Varsity Blues, joked about the film's famous line on not wanting someone else's life. The writer and producer Brian Koppelman pointed out a quieter advantage: graduating without student debt because a wealthy parent paid. Comedians and writers, including the team behind Full Frontal with Samantha Bee and Lena Dunham, added their own sarcastic takes.




What research says about money and admissions
It helps to separate three things that often get lumped together. Hiring a tutor or an editor is legal and common. Having someone else write work that a student submits as their own breaks academic rules and can lead to expulsion or a revoked degree. Bribing officials and faking test scores, as in Varsity Blues, is a federal crime.
The legal advantages are the larger story, and they have now been measured. A study by the Harvard and Brown economists Raj Chetty, David Deming and John Friedman, released by Opportunity Insights in July 2023, found that children from the top 1 percent of family incomes were about twice as likely to attend an Ivy-Plus college as middle-class children with the same SAT or ACT scores. Most of that gap came from higher admission rates, driven by three factors: preferences for children of alumni, extra weight on non-academic ratings that favour students from affluent private schools, and the recruitment of athletes, who tend to come from wealthier families.
Some institutions and states have responded. Johns Hopkins and Amherst dropped legacy preferences, and by 2024 Colorado, Maryland, Virginia and California had banned legacy admissions at some or all of their universities. US senators also proposed making donations taxable when the donor's child is applying to the same school, though those bills did not become law.
How the criminal case ended
Huffman pleaded guilty to honest services fraud and in September 2019 was sentenced to 14 days in prison, a $30,000 fine and 250 hours of community service. Loughlin and Giannulli pleaded guilty in 2020; in August that year Loughlin received two months in prison, a $150,000 fine and 100 hours of community service, and Giannulli received five months. Yale and Stanford became the first universities to rescind an admission and expel a student linked to the scheme.
Not every case ended in a conviction. One parent, Amin Khoury, was acquitted at trial in 2022; an appeals court later overturned most of the convictions of two others; and one father was pardoned in January 2021 before trial. Singer himself pleaded guilty and in January 2023 was sentenced to three and a half years in prison and ordered to forfeit more than $10 million. The case was retold in the 2021 Netflix documentary Operation Varsity Blues: The College Admissions Scandal.
What applicants without a paid team can do
Leigh's post was meant as a warning, not a guide, but the research points to some practical steps. Start with free help: school counsellors, teachers who know your work, and the official practice tests published by the testing organisations. Ask about application fee waivers, which most selective colleges and the Common App offer to students with financial need.
Write your own essay, and let someone you trust read it for clarity rather than rewrite it. Admissions readers are looking for a real voice, and an essay that sounds like a consultant can work against you. Finally, look beyond the most famous names. Many public universities and smaller colleges offer generous aid and strong outcomes, and the right fit matters more than the brand.
Explore a related story on our site: Elle Darby and Paul Stenson: The Hotel Collaboration Dispute.
Sources: Jaimie Leigh's original Facebook post (March 2019) and the replies and tweets shown above; Wikipedia: 2019 college admissions bribery scandal; Opportunity Insights: Diversifying Society's Leaders? (Chetty, Deming and Friedman); Wikipedia: Legacy preferences.

COMMENTS