Does Babysitting Grandchildren Help You Live Longer?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-04-11.

Grandparent Caregiving and Longevity in an Observational Study

Depositphotos.com, Depositphotos.com

Does looking after your grandchildren help you live longer? One well-known study suggests there is a link. Researchers analysing the Berlin Aging Study found that grandparents who occasionally cared for their grandchildren had a mortality risk about 37% lower than grandparents who gave no childcare and than people without grandchildren. The finding is encouraging, but it shows an association, not proof that babysitting itself adds years, and it applies to occasional help rather than full-time care.

Here is what the research found, how it was done, why caring for others might matter for health, and where the limits lie.

What the Berlin study found

The paper, "Caregiving within and beyond the family is associated with lower mortality for the caregiver", was published in the journal Evolution and Human Behavior in 2017. Its authors were Sonja Hilbrand of the University of Basel, David Coall of Edith Cowan University in Australia, and Denis Gerstorf and Ralph Hertwig in Berlin.

They used data from more than 500 people aged 70 to 103 who took part in the Berlin Aging Study. Participants were first interviewed and tested in the early 1990s and followed until 2009. The researchers compared survival among people who gave different kinds of help with survival among those who gave none.

The headline results:

  • Grandparents who provided occasional childcare had a mortality hazard about 37% lower than grandparents who did not, and than non-grandparents. This held after the researchers accounted for physical health, age, socioeconomic status and characteristics of the children and grandchildren.
  • About half of the caregiving grandparents were still alive roughly ten years after their first interview. About half of those who did not help anyone had died within five years.
  • Helping beyond the family mattered too. Parents without grandchildren who helped their adult children, for example with housework, showed a similar pattern. Childless older adults who gave emotional support to others lived a median of about seven more years, compared with about four for those who did not.

Why caring for others might be linked to longer life

The researchers were careful not to overstate the cause. As Coall put it in Edith Cowan University's announcement, the study shows a positive link, but "we can only speculate as to why."

Several explanations have been suggested:

  • Purpose and routine. Having people who rely on you gives structure to the week and a reason to stay active.
  • Social connection. Caring for grandchildren keeps older adults in regular contact with family. Loneliness and isolation are well-established risk factors for poorer health.
  • A stress buffer. Coall suggested that helping others may soften the effect of stress, possibly involving hormones such as oxytocin, which is associated with social bonding.
  • An evolutionary angle. The authors linked their work to the "grandmother hypothesis", the idea that human lifespans may have lengthened partly because older relatives helped raise children. For most of human history, help with childcare was vital for survival.

The important caveats

The study is observational. It can show that caregivers lived longer on average, but not that caregiving made them live longer. Grandparents who are healthier, more mobile and more socially connected are also more likely to be asked, and able, to look after children. The researchers adjusted for physical health and other factors, but no observational study can rule out every hidden difference between groups.

The kind of care also matters. Grandparents who were primary or custodial carers were excluded, because the study focused on occasional help. Other research from Coall's group has found negative effects on physical and mental health in grandparents who provide full-time care. The authors were clear that helping is not a cure-all, and Coall said there is no ideal amount. Each person needs to judge what moderate help means for them.

What grandchildren gain

The benefits seem to run both ways. A study led by Professor Ann Buchanan at the University of Oxford, with Dr Eirini Flouri of the Institute of Education in London, surveyed 1,596 children aged 11 to 16 in England and Wales and interviewed 40 more. It found that involved grandparents contributed to children's well-being.

Two details stand out. First, closeness alone was not enough: the benefits came from grandparents who actively did things with their grandchildren. Second, close grandparent relationships appeared to cushion children during difficult events such as parental separation, offering stability while the family adjusted. The researchers also found that teenagers did not see living nearby as essential, because they used technology to stay in touch.

Making it work for the whole family

If you are a grandparent, or a parent hoping for help, a few principles keep the arrangement healthy:

  • Ask, do not assume. The research points to willing, occasional involvement. Help that feels obligatory or exhausting is unlikely to bring the same benefits.
  • Agree on limits. Set clear days, hours and expectations, and review them as health and circumstances change.
  • Share the rules. Talk through meals, screen time, naps and discipline so grandparents are not caught between generations.
  • Value non-childcare help too. The study found similar links for helping adult children with chores and for emotional support beyond the family. Volunteering and friendship count.
  • Watch for strain. Tiredness, pain or low mood are signs to scale back. Grandparents with health concerns should talk to a doctor about what is realistic.

Common myths about the study

"Babysitting makes you live longer." The study found an association, not a proven cause, and the link applied to occasional care.

"More childcare is better." There is no evidence of that. Full-time care has been linked to worse health, and the authors stressed moderation.

"Grandparents without grandchildren miss out." Older adults who supported their own children or other people in their community showed similar patterns. Staying connected and useful to others seems to be the common thread.

For families who enjoy time across generations, the research is a pleasant confirmation of something many already feel. It is not a reason to pressure anyone into childcare, and it is no judgment on grandparents who cannot provide it.

Sources: Hilbrand, Coall, Gerstorf and Hertwig, Evolution and Human Behavior 38(3), 2017, ScienceDirect: the full paper, Edith Cowan University news release (2017), University of Basel release via idw (2017), Berlin Aging Study, Phys.org: Oxford grandparenting study (2008), Lead Stories fact check (2019).

COMMENTS