Ancient Cave Symbols: Were They the First Step Toward Writing?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-04-23.

Ancient Cave Symbols and the Question of Early Writing

Map: recurring geometric signs recorded in rock art on several continents, as charted by New Scientist from Genevieve von Petzinger's research.

Were the dots, lines and grids painted in Ice Age caves the world's first writing? The honest answer is no, not in the sense of a script that records spoken words. What researchers have found is something subtler and still remarkable: a small, stable set of abstract signs that people reused across Europe for tens of thousands of years, long before the first clay tablets of Mesopotamia. Those signs show that our ancestors were thinking symbolically very early, and they raise a fair question about how much older the roots of written communication might be.

This guide explains what was found, who found it, how experts disagree about it, and what would have to be true before anyone could call these marks "writing".

Where writing officially begins

Most textbooks place the birth of true writing in southern Mesopotamia, where Sumerian scribes began pressing marks into clay a little over 5,000 years ago. Their system, later called cuneiform, started as accounting tokens and pictures of goods, and only gradually came to record the sounds of language. Egyptian hieroglyphs appeared at roughly the same time, and writing was later invented independently in China and in Mesoamerica.

Scholars draw a firm line between this kind of writing and earlier symbols. A writing system is one in which marks stand for elements of a particular spoken language, so a trained reader can recover the same words the writer had in mind. A road sign, a tally stick or a family crest can carry meaning without doing that. Keep that distinction in mind, because it decides how the cave signs should be described.

Genevieve von Petzinger and the 32 signs

The modern interest in these marks owes a great deal to Genevieve von Petzinger, a Canadian palaeoanthropologist and rock art researcher. For decades, specialists studying European caves such as Lascaux and Chauvet had concentrated on the famous horses, bison and lions. The small geometric shapes around them were often treated as decoration or simply left out of site records.

Von Petzinger began by gathering the published records for 146 rock art sites in France into a database and found that the same shapes kept turning up. She then went underground herself. In 2013 and 2014 she visited 52 caves in France and southern Europe, crawling into side passages to record marks earlier surveys had missed.

Her conclusion was that the variety is surprisingly narrow. Across the whole continent she counts no more than 32 distinct signs, carved or painted over a span of roughly 30,000 years. They include:

  • simple dots, lines, circles, triangles, quadrangles and zigzags;
  • open angles, crosses and grid-like patterns, including a shape resembling a modern hashtag;
  • hand stencils, made by blowing pigment around a hand pressed to the rock;
  • the tectiform, a roof-like shape on a post;
  • the penniform, which looks like a feather or a branch;
  • the scalariform, a ladder shape, and the curving claviform.

She presented the work in a TED talk in 2015 and in her 2016 book The First Signs: Unlocking the Mysteries of the World's Oldest Symbols. The video is embedded further down this page.

Why the consistency matters

A random doodle would not survive for millennia. The striking point in von Petzinger's data is repetition across vast distances and time spans. According to her analysis, as summarised by Frank Jacobs at Big Think, hand stencils appear around 40,000 years ago and fall out of use around 20,000 years ago, while feather-shaped penniforms seem to start in northern France and spread south through Spain into Portugal. Roughly two-thirds of the signs appear to be present already in the oldest European sites, which suggests people brought the habit with them rather than inventing it on arrival.

Similar shapes, including the hashtag-like grid, have also been reported on rock surfaces in Africa, Asia, Australia and the Americas. Similar is not the same as identical, and simple shapes such as lines and dots can be invented many times independently. Still, the pattern fits a wider picture: by the time modern humans spread out of Africa, they were already in the habit of using abstract marks to carry meaning.

The signs were not confined to cave walls either. Von Petzinger points to portable objects carrying the same motifs, including a necklace of engraved deer teeth from a prehistoric burial in France, decorated with marks drawn from the same repertoire. Objects like that travel, and so do the ideas painted on them.

Sceptics and alternative explanations

Not every expert reads the evidence the same way. Jean Clottes, one of the best-known authorities on French cave art, has stressed that the signs are almost always found close to animal paintings. In his view the animals were probably just as symbolic as the signs, so the geometric marks cannot simply be singled out as the starting point of symbolic thought. The Bradshaw Foundation, which hosts an overview of von Petzinger's earlier database, summarises his position alongside her findings.

Other explanations have been suggested over the years. Some researchers link certain patterns, such as grids and zigzags, to visual effects people experience in altered states of consciousness. Others see clan or territorial markers, counting devices, or seasonal calendars. None of these ideas has been proven, and different signs may well have served different purposes.

Dating is another source of caution. The age of a painted animal does not automatically tell us the age of every mark beside it, and some engravings are hard to date at all. Claims about a whole system existing at a particular time rest on many individual dates, each with its own margin of error.

Sound, images and the roots of language

A related line of research approaches the question from linguistics. In 2018, MIT linguist Shigeru Miyagawa, MIT doctoral student Cora Lesure and Vitor Nóbrega of the University of São Paulo published a paper in Frontiers in Psychology proposing what they call cross-modality information transfer.

Their starting point is that many cave images sit in acoustic hot spots, places where sound echoes strongly, and often in deep, hard-to-reach chambers. They suggest early artists may have been linking what they heard with what they drew, turning sound into image. If so, cave art would have exercised the same mental machinery that symbolic language depends on. The authors describe it as a working hypothesis meant to prompt further research, not a settled finding.

Miyagawa put the broader idea memorably in an MIT news article: art, he said, is "not just something that is marginal to our culture, but central to the formation of our cognitive abilities."

Genevieve von Petzinger's TED talk on the 32 recurring signs of European cave art.

So, were they writing?

Pulling the threads together gives a clear, if less sensational, answer.

  • What is well supported: a limited set of geometric signs was used consistently over a very long period in Europe, and comparable marks appear elsewhere. This points to shared conventions and abstract thinking well before farming or cities.
  • What is debated: whether the signs formed a deliberate communication system with agreed meanings, and whether they were separate from the animal art or part of one visual language.
  • What is not supported: the idea that the signs record speech and could be "read" like a script. No one has deciphered them, and with no bilingual text or living tradition to compare, they may never be decoded.

Von Petzinger herself frames the signs as an early step in a long story of graphic communication, a precursor to writing rather than writing itself. That is still a big claim. It means the habit of storing ideas outside our own heads, on stone, bone and later clay, may go back tens of thousands of years further than the Sumerian tablets that usually open the history books.

How to read headlines about "the first writing"

Stories on this subject often promise that ancient symbols have been "cracked" or that writing is far older than we thought. A few quick questions help separate a solid finding from a hopeful one:

  • Is the claim about a catalogue of repeated shapes, a proposed meaning for them, or an actual decipherment? These are three very different things.
  • Does the date refer to a single mark, or to a whole system? One old engraving does not prove a system existed at the same time.
  • Are independent specialists quoted, including sceptics?
  • Is there a peer-reviewed paper or a book by the researcher, and does the article link to it?

Applied to von Petzinger's work, the answers are reassuring: careful field recording, published results and an open acknowledgement that the meaning of the signs remains unknown. That is exactly what makes her catalogue a useful foundation for future research.

Sources: TED: Genevieve von Petzinger; Frank Jacobs, Big Think; Alison George, New Scientist (map); Bradshaw Foundation: geometric signs; MIT News on Miyagawa, Lesure and Nóbrega (2018); Archaeology magazine: cuneiform; Open Culture.

COMMENTS